There's also a lot missing in that data like recovered weight, secondary fragmentation, muzzle energy, in addition to some of the loads being fired from different guns with different length barrels.

In a recent podcast at proarms.podbean.com , Keith Jones talked about the street sucess that the 125 gr. Federal JHP amassed when his agency (my guess is Indianapolis) used it. It flat out works. You can overthink this stuff folks. That said, I agree that the Silvertip is a great load in a caliber full of excellent choices.