I don't personally have but one S&W autopistol - the 1911PD with 4.25" barrel. Mine has the laser grips and I love it. It is thin, accurate, and a Commander-sized 1911 is 'ideal' for me. That being said, I would probably select a couple of M&Ps as a second and third choice. I have an XD45 (4") and love it. I'm sure the M&Ps are as good or better. I got a Kholster and occasionally carry the XD, but for me though the 1911's thinness makes a huge difference. Also, I get a consistent firing grip on the draw every time with a 1911, whereas sometimes I have to adjust with the XD. The 1911 is a 'known quantity' for me.