I have had a few of these in different configurations. My 686 SSR has the best trigger of all my revolvers including my Performance Center guns. I have the 686+ with a 3" barrel and I love the concealability and balance. I got the SSR for IDPA and 3" for carry. So, by best you have to define requirements and how it is going to be used. An 8" is not good for daily carry but good for hunting.