First post. As to the 586, I carried one on duty back in the day with two different Sheriff depts. and got great service from it,and it got a lot of magnum rounds thru it. Mine was slicked up for duty,narrowed trigger,action polish,and fitted grips. I had forgotten about the old recall,but I never had one problem with mine and still remains one of my favorite all time revolvers.I don't see how you could go wrong with a 586.
I wish I had another one.