I don't like the feel of any rubber grip I have tried at all, either the Pachmayr or Hogue.

I have large hands and have both a pair of Troopers and a set of Nills.

The Troopers should not be too large since they are made based on a tracing of your hand but the shape may not to everyone's liking.

They both fit my hands very well but of the two, I like the Nills a little bit more. The Troopers will take about 16 weeks to get and cost a little less than the Nills depending on the options. The Nills are narrower at the bottom and have a slight "palm swell" that the Troopers do not have. Both cover the backstrap which I like.

The next set I buy will probably be Nills but I'll have to order direct from Nill to get the non-finger groove version I prefer.