I began my law enforcement career with the model 19 and it is a fine weapon. The problem with .357 magnum ammo seems to be with the hyper-velocity 125gn rounds. Use 140-158gn and you should'nt have any problems. I currently load .357 ammo to about 950-1000 fps for general use in my guns but when I carry my model 19 I load 158gn factory loads. The model 66, which is the stainless steel version of the model 19 is also an excellent gun and both come in a 2 1/2" bbl for more concealable carry. Others have mentioned the L frame 686 and that is also an excellent choice. You can still find model 586s which are blue steel L frame guns and, like the 686s, they are fine guns also. Take your pick and as long as you exercise due care you should have no problems with model 19s, 66s or the L frame 986-586 series.