I'm suffering over that question this very week. My historical numbers are easy, its a tie between the M1950 44 I bought from Lee in very early 2010 and the K22 2nd I bought from David Carroll about 6 or 7 years ago. I think the value of the K22 has continued to go up.

My suffering is caused by me finding a Winchester M21 of a configuration I would like and it'll be at the show this weekend. So my high dollar gun may change between now and Saturday.

But as Feral just stated, the values may be all distorted by current value. The guns I feel have the greatest market value right now didn't cost me much when I bought them, they just kept going up.

Worse still, I have guns I'm actively seeking. No, I won't tell because it might distort the prices even worse.

__________________
Dick Burg