I have a Marlin made 94 Cowboy that I shoot 180 gr cast gas checks through. I have used it for deer and hog hunting out to about 100 yards. A great rifle. The Rossi's are not quite as slick, but they are a durable and sturdy rifle. If I could not find a Marlin in 357 I would not turn my nose up at a Rossi. I have a Rossi in 44 mag and it is a decent carbine that will get the job done and a lot more inexpensive than a pre-Remington Marlin.