When I got my 625-6 used, it was wearing the factory Hogues and just did not feel "right." Probably because my original 625 (1988 Model) had worn the Pachmayr Grippers (also factory) when purchased new by me. After refitting with the newer version the Decelerator Gripper, it feels like an old friend! As noted above, it is probably all personal preference. I also prefer the Compac for my 3" Model 60, rather than the factory Hogues or Uncle Mike's Boot Grip. To my grip it seems like trying to point and shoot a banana.