Shinbone did not ask for suggested guns for his needs/wants. He asked for suggestions on a "specific" gun. He obviously has other guns and knowledge about them. He even has guns that would serve the purpose stated, but he wants a 6" model 66!
So my answer is...-1 simply because I like P&R guns. They're not better, I just like them. I would not turn down a no dash unless it had SS sights. Those are for collecting, not shooting.
Good luck in your search. That is part of the fun too.
Dan