[QUOTE=jtcarm;139412910]For an HD gun, I'd stay with the 3". Much less barrel for someone to wrestle out of your hand.

If you let them get that close to your 3" or 5" it wont matter, you'll be dead soon.

“When You Have to Shoot, Shoot. Don't Talk.” - Tuco in 'The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly'