I have Talons on 3 handguns. I tried the Hogue Hand All on one, I think it was the Gen 2 Glock 17. Didn't like it. Very difficult to install. Wouldn't stay in place. Made the grip too big and bulky.

The Talons on my Shield are great. Non slip grip without any added bulk. After 3 ½ years, and 2200 rounds, still in place. Go with Talons, you won't be disappointed.