I think the 19 is a better deal in terms of cash and in terms of resale/collectible value. Still, price is high. If you do buy, make sure the box is original (serial number should match the gun) and make sure the nickel is factory original (box should note that), too. If not, the gun is $150-$200 over priced.

I prefer N-frame 357s, but $600+ for a run of the mill 28-2 is at least $100 too much. Of course, I live in Florida and there are a lot of gun stores and shows available to me. Idaho may be different.