Thank you for the opinions everyone. Still a tough choice. I live in a smaller town so I figured overall the prices might be a little higher here. The 19 has been at the shop for a few months already, I don't know how long the 28 has been at the other one though I see more 19s than 28s. This is only the third 28 I have seen here and the other two were closer to $1000. I think I will try for the 28 and if it gets sold before I get there then I will go for the 19.
The guy who was selling the 28-2 also had two other revolvers I was looking at. A model 60 snub in not so great shape for $499 and a model 586 in decent shape and after market grips for $699. Not too familiar with either of those models.