I carry a Smith 44sp with a 4 inch barrel, round butt. Shoots 240gr Hornady JHP. Maybe I do not practice enough, but, I only shoot about 50 rounds/month, not cost prohibitive. There is not much difference in a 3 or 4 inch barrel when it comes to concealed carry. I am also looking at the Ruger GP100 44sp although I don't care for the sights.