Hmmm,,,I just bought a Seiko mechanical watch which my wife thinks is identical to three other Seikos in the box. Geeeze, how could you think that, I ask her. But its the subtle differences that make it worth the money to the owner. I have nine L frames, all no dash, from 2 1/2 through 8 3/8 barrels. 585s, 686s, a 581 and a 681. I also have your early 19 with the 6" barrel. (Patridge front sight? Makes a great target gun for the .38 wadcutters.) But once in a while another early L frame will catch my eye and cause me to think about any particular hole it might fill. Clearly you have an enviable selection of 357 Magnum revolvers. And that one pictured is really pretty so good luck with that decision. As a side-note, I read that enviable list and my first thought was "where's the .22"