I don't know about everyone else, but as the target increases to 25 yrds, my 45's always hit more accurate than the 9mms. 7-15 yrds, it's a toss up. My best 7 yrd, was with a 9mm Glock 43.

The 45 Shield re-coil isn't much more than the 9mm Shield. I'm just not much of a 40's fan, even though I have a S&W 40 CORE

I much prefer carrying the 45 Shield, because it IS what I like. Since I reload, it doesn't make much difference cost wise.