Buckmark13, what did you end up getting and how did you like it? I'm interested in this topic because I also just acquired a 4" 686 which I will be carrying occasionally in the woods, OWB, strong side.
Any other recommendations that are good quality (as opposed to one size fits all) and won't break the bank?
I definitely appreciate the custom holsters but my occasional usage just doesn't justify the cost in most cases.
Thanks!