I have a 686+, 3" talo edition
The Scopesmith The Gun Room— — Back in Stock TALO Model! Smith & Wesson 150713 Model 686 Deluxe 357 Mag 3in 7rd – Adjustable White Outline/Red Ramp Sights Stainless Steel – Satin Finish – Textured wood grips
and carry owb in a Lobo Leather enhanced pancake holster with a thumb break.
Enhanced Pancake – Welcome to Lobo Gun Leather
I think the 3" is the perfect carry size and imo, nothing beats 7 rounds of .357