I would go with ahrends grips. I have been reviewing the threads and altamount grips do get quite some bashing for fit, finish, quality of product, etc., but everyone seems pleased with Ahrends. I have some Ahrends on order from them round to square butt targets goncalo alves for $70.00. I also added the tung oil finish for $20.00 more and $7.00 for shipping. You can also see gripseller on ebay, he is one of their dealers and you can see the actual grip you will receive. I also have a brand new 686 and wanted some wood grips but that round butt threw me off for a while. I wanted the square butt grips because that is what I am used to with my N frame model 28 and these grips were the way to go. You might want to look at ahrends tactical grips also