As a collector of both Victory and Commando revolvers I find they group about the same for me.

Of course the smooth Victory grips versus the "checkered plastic/Coltwood" grips may be a detractor for the S&W when it's warm and my hands are a little sweaty.

Other than that they are both 4" fixed sighted 38spl revolvers, with each and every one having a slightly different personality.

Dale