I like new Iron. Own 2 current 41's and more 70's older pistols. I do not use the factory S&W for repair I have found 2 gunsmiths that excell in 41 repair. Not free but what is? Never heard of a 41 that could not be fixed. When they are shooting I really like them so they please me most of the time. New or old makes no difference to me. Love the 41's.