I have a 4516 & a 4566, both are excellent handguns. I've never considered my 4516 to be anything but awesome.

I agree that they need to lower their asking price closer to $400, maybe as much as $450 for a really nice one. Let them know that you don't consider the Pro Mag as having any added value to the deal.

I think you'll really enjoy owning one. Out of all of my 45 acp's, the 4516 gets the most range time. Never had any problems with it either.