I've never shod a Bodyguard with aftermarket rubber, but I have put Pachmyer and Hogue on Ruger LCP's and LC9s. They are all a bit too tacky or sticky for my taste, but they all slick up over time with atmospheric oxidation and stray oil. I don't like grips to be too tacky. It slows down handling. The good news is that all of them are cheap, so go ahead and try what strikes your fancy.