First handgun I ever bought with my own money was a 6-inch 686-3 in the early summer of 1989, I was 16 years old. I was either late 30’s or early 40’s when I got my first N-frame, a 6-inch Model 28-2.

The 686 is a better looking revolver IMO, and has a smoother and more enjoyable double action trigger stroke. But the 6-inch Model 28-2 balances better for me while the full lug 6-inch Model 686 feels muzzle heavy at arm’s length.

I love them both and I have more sentimental attachment to the 686, but on a range day and especially for my heaviest full-nuts .357 Magnum, I’m more likely to grab the 28-2.