Lots of great thoughts regarding carrying a revolver over a semi auto so far. For me, I just shoot a revolver better than a semi. Perhaps it is my age (late 50's), but I so enjoy the feel of a revolver over a semi. When you find the right stocks for a revolver, then you have a marriage made in Heaven. A good K, L, or J frame just seems to disappear when concealed. Never worry about the butt end sticking out and screaming "gun".

Just my .02 worth. For me, I love my revolvers. So much so that I only have 3 semi autos left ... and they are my Glocks. Just can't seem to part with those ugly, extremely reliable semis!!

Doc