Smith & Wesson Forum

Go Back   Smith & Wesson Forum > Ammunition-Gunsmithing > Ammo
o

Notices

Ammo All Ammo Discussions Go Here


Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old 05-28-2010, 07:16 PM
kbm6893 kbm6893 is offline
SWCA Member
Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357  
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: Pennsylvania
Posts: 6,625
Likes: 636
Liked 6,861 Times in 2,541 Posts
Default Which is more powerful? .45 or .357

230 grain .45 ACP vs. 158 grain .357. Which one has more stopping power? Both seem to be about the same price.
Reply With Quote
The Following User Likes This Post:
  #2  
Old 05-28-2010, 07:43 PM
Skeeziks Skeeziks is offline
Member
Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357  
Join Date: Apr 2010
Posts: 561
Likes: 0
Liked 10 Times in 8 Posts
Default

The 45 does...with the right bullets.
Reply With Quote
  #3  
Old 05-28-2010, 07:50 PM
Matt C. Matt C. is offline
Member
Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357  
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: N. DE.
Posts: 307
Likes: 465
Liked 211 Times in 50 Posts
Default

Dead heat.
Reply With Quote
  #4  
Old 05-28-2010, 08:44 PM
40cal's Avatar
40cal 40cal is offline
Member
Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357  
Join Date: Dec 2009
Posts: 258
Likes: 0
Liked 7 Times in 5 Posts
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Matt C. View Post
Dead heat.
+1 to that
IMO barrel length and distance to your target will come into play also. Over penetration may be an issue with the .357, all in all you can call it a draw.
__________________
2nd Admen.-Right to bear AR 's
Reply With Quote
  #5  
Old 05-28-2010, 08:49 PM
oldman45 oldman45 is offline
Member
Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357  
Join Date: Mar 2010
Location: Louisiana
Posts: 3,973
Likes: 95
Liked 336 Times in 138 Posts
Default

I got to ask.

What bullet would you suggest for a .45acp in select social situations? For some reason, I have concerns about which is the best so called "one shot stopper."

Without reloading bullets, which brand do you feel is best?
Reply With Quote
  #6  
Old 05-28-2010, 08:50 PM
OKFC05 OKFC05 is offline
Member
Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357  
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: Oklahoma
Posts: 8,158
Likes: 3,605
Liked 5,199 Times in 2,172 Posts
Default

Energy Calculator

Crunch the numbers; draw your own conclusions.
Reply With Quote
  #7  
Old 05-28-2010, 08:53 PM
cgt4570's Avatar
cgt4570 cgt4570 is offline
SWCA Member
Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357  
Join Date: Jun 2004
Location: Mount Carmel, TN USA
Posts: 3,167
Likes: 1,620
Liked 3,176 Times in 932 Posts
Default

Would you rather be ran over by a motorcycle going 180 mph or a semi truck going 65 mph? The end result is probably going to be the same. Just different physics principles at play.
__________________
Chris
SWCA #2243 SWHF #292
Reply With Quote
The Following 5 Users Like Post:
  #8  
Old 05-28-2010, 09:16 PM
flop-shank flop-shank is offline
US Veteran
 
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: The Rust Belt Buckle/Mich
Posts: 2,382
Likes: 0
Liked 41 Times in 32 Posts
Default

The best loads in each caliber, from full length barrels, should work about as well. In short barrels, I think the higher velocity of the .357 is a real plus since the .45 operates at much lower velocities. As barrels get shorter, the .45 may not be as reliable of an expender when heavy clothing is involved. Modern ammo is much better than that of the past so poor expansion doesn't seem to be as big of a problem as it used to be. Also lighter bullets, such as 200 and 185 grainers, can give snub .45s the velocity boost that they need .

The .45 generally will produce bigger expanded diameters, whereas the .357 generally will have more energy and some loads throw off serious secondary fragments.

As a service cartridge, many prefer the more powerful 125 gr. .357 offerings. I certainly do. Hot 125s should be good for over 700 fpe. from a 6" gun.
Reply With Quote
  #9  
Old 05-28-2010, 09:46 PM
Skeeziks Skeeziks is offline
Member
Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357  
Join Date: Apr 2010
Posts: 561
Likes: 0
Liked 10 Times in 8 Posts
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by oldman45 View Post
I got to ask.

What bullet would you suggest for a .45acp in select social situations?
When a piece of low-life scum is trying to kill me or mine...I would hardly call that a "social situation." ~

And if I did pull the trigger on him, the bullet would be a 200-gr. Gold Dot.
Reply With Quote
  #10  
Old 05-28-2010, 09:59 PM
Steve C Steve C is offline
Member
Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357  
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: Phoenix, AZ
Posts: 727
Likes: 1
Liked 133 Times in 93 Posts
Default

Quote:
230 grain .45 ACP vs. 158 grain .357. Which one has more stopping power?
Depends upon the ammo being used and type of bullet. In the .357 mag the 125gr JHP has a better record than any other ammunition.


Last edited by Steve C; 05-28-2010 at 10:01 PM.
Reply With Quote
The Following User Likes This Post:
  #11  
Old 05-28-2010, 11:22 PM
LuddhaBuddha's Avatar
LuddhaBuddha LuddhaBuddha is offline
Member
Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357  
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: KY
Posts: 336
Likes: 0
Liked 13 Times in 10 Posts
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by oldman45 View Post
I got to ask.

What bullet would you suggest for a .45acp in select social situations? For some reason, I have concerns about which is the best so called "one shot stopper."

Without reloading bullets, which brand do you feel is best?
I carry either 230gr Federal HST or 230gr Winchester Ranger T-series, but would be fine with using gold dots or XTPs in either 230gr or 200gr.
Reply With Quote
  #12  
Old 05-31-2010, 04:12 PM
reerc's Avatar
reerc reerc is offline
Member
 
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: In the middle of Utah
Posts: 746
Likes: 54
Liked 26 Times in 18 Posts
Default

Oh goodie, a caliber war! (never saw one of these before ...)

__________________
Don't need no stinkin' sigline
Reply With Quote
The Following User Likes This Post:
  #13  
Old 05-31-2010, 05:50 PM
Skeeziks Skeeziks is offline
Member
Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357  
Join Date: Apr 2010
Posts: 561
Likes: 0
Liked 10 Times in 8 Posts
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by labrtvr View Post
Which is better for hunting, a 30.06 or an .270?
Well, isn't it obvious?
Reply With Quote
  #14  
Old 05-31-2010, 06:00 PM
kbm6893 kbm6893 is offline
SWCA Member
Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357  
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: Pennsylvania
Posts: 6,625
Likes: 636
Liked 6,861 Times in 2,541 Posts
Default

Not trying to start a war. It's an obvious question. If I asked which was more powerful, a .380 or a 9MM, would there be a debate? I don't think so. The .45 has a heavier bullet (230 grains vs. 158), but the magnum is a magnum, and I have fired the 45 ACP out of a revolver, and the .357 sure had more kick.

Just answer the question if you have an opinion, and keep the comments to yourself.
Reply With Quote
The Following 3 Users Like Post:
  #15  
Old 05-31-2010, 06:30 PM
Skeeziks Skeeziks is offline
Member
Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357  
Join Date: Apr 2010
Posts: 561
Likes: 0
Liked 10 Times in 8 Posts
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by kbm6893 View Post
Not trying to start a war. It's an obvious question. If I asked which was more powerful, a .380 or a 9MM, would there be a debate? I don't think so. The .45 has a heavier bullet (230 grains vs. 158), but the magnum is a magnum, and I have fired the 45 ACP out of a revolver, and the .357 sure had more kick.

Just answer the question if you have an opinion, and keep the comments to yourself.
Go back and read the first reply...it's mine.
Reply With Quote
The Following User Likes This Post:
  #16  
Old 05-31-2010, 08:17 PM
PDL's Avatar
PDL PDL is offline
US Veteran
Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357  
Join Date: Jun 2008
Location: NJ
Posts: 1,210
Likes: 314
Liked 75 Times in 33 Posts
Default

Since no one else has mentioned the obvious. The real answer is the one you can contol, and effectively put on target. Always depending on what that target is. Both work well for BGs, other targets might change the choice. I don't like .45 for hogs or bears, in those circumstance I'd want something else. Usually, in that kind of country I've got a .44 mag.
And magnum is really just a label.
I'm not up on enough science to tell you the energy transmitted to the target etc., if that's what you're looking for.
I've shot a boatload more .45acp than I have .357 so I personally trust it more. But I'm not shooting thru barricades or windshields etc.
__________________
Pete.
Reply With Quote
  #17  
Old 06-02-2010, 12:39 AM
JBoss JBoss is offline
Member
Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357  
Join Date: Apr 2010
Location: NE Wyoming
Posts: 24
Likes: 0
Liked 9 Times in 5 Posts
Default

The information posted on the following site may shed some light on the discussion about effectiveness of different calibers.

Terminal ballistics as viewed in a morgue
Reply With Quote
The Following User Likes This Post:
  #18  
Old 06-02-2010, 01:40 AM
c.marsh c.marsh is offline
Member
Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357  
Join Date: Dec 2008
Location: houston,texas
Posts: 151
Likes: 2
Liked 1 Time in 1 Post
Talking BEST OF BOTH WORLDS

FEDERAL--200gr expanding fmj 45acp..........
Reply With Quote
  #19  
Old 05-07-2012, 03:00 PM
mistermills357's Avatar
mistermills357 mistermills357 is offline
US Veteran
Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357  
Join Date: Feb 2009
Location: St. Petersburg, FL
Posts: 181
Likes: 406
Liked 129 Times in 73 Posts
Default

I am going with the .357 Mag., in both 125 and 158 grain HP. I would choose it first. I fired into an old washer once, to see what would happen; I stood to the side and fired. The bullet ripped out of there and tore a gash with each shot. Each was about as long and wide as the top half of my thumb.
I have used it to stop a dog: and it strikes like lightening.
Even so, I have been back and forth on this, because those are my favorite calibers.
I have seen a .45 FMJ stopped by a coffee can, I shot it and the bullet struck the rim of the can.
In praise of the .45, let me add that the can flipped into the air at least knee high. It acted like it did not know which way to turn first. In more praise, I have fired 185grain Remington +P's in my .45 and I love that round: It is one of my favorite loads.

Last edited by mistermills357; 05-07-2012 at 03:25 PM.
Reply With Quote
  #20  
Old 05-07-2012, 03:20 PM
poordevil poordevil is offline
Member
Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357  
Join Date: Feb 2012
Location: Yuma
Posts: 801
Likes: 176
Liked 436 Times in 261 Posts
Default

My answer to your question, and just my own opinion is the better of the 2 you offer is 45 acp. I think the better anti-personnel round for the .357 is the 125 grs JHP at 1400 from a 4" BBL
Reply With Quote
  #21  
Old 05-07-2012, 03:22 PM
blujax01's Avatar
blujax01 blujax01 is offline
Member
Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357  
Join Date: Aug 2010
Location: C-Bus
Posts: 6,335
Likes: 4,311
Liked 4,916 Times in 2,086 Posts
Default

There is a paper entitled "Handgun Wounding Factors and Effectiveness" presented by the FBI Academy Firearms Training Unit.
The full text may be found here:
http://www.firearmstactical.com/pdf/fbi-hwfe.pdf

Excellent 20 minute read and the final paragraph sums it up quite nicely:
Kinetic energy does not wound. Temporary cavity does not wound. The much discussed "shock" of bullet impact is a fable and "knock down" power is a myth. The critical element is penetration. The bullet must pass through the large, blood bearing organs and be of sufficient diameter to promote rapid bleeding. Penetration less than 12 inches is too little, and, in the words of two of the participants in the 1987 Wound Ballistics Workshop, "too little penetration will get you killed." Given desirable and reliable penetration, the only way to increase bullet effectiveness is to increase the severity of the wound by increasing the size of hole made by the bullet. Any bullet which will not penetrate through vital organs from less than optimal angles is not acceptable. Of those that will penetrate, the edge is always with the bigger bullet.
Reply With Quote
The Following User Likes This Post:
  #22  
Old 05-07-2012, 04:04 PM
senecaap senecaap is offline
Member
Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357  
Join Date: Jan 2010
Location: The Smoky Mountains
Posts: 348
Likes: 94
Liked 178 Times in 78 Posts
Default

I say the .45, but across the spectrum, pistols to rifles, I am a moderate velocity heavy bullet guy. That said the .357, .45, 10mm, .44Spc & Mag are the Major league players. I like a .45 or .44 better than a .357 (for several reasons, hearing and recoil among them), but I like the .357 better than the 9mm and its ilk of bush leaguers, and as it happens I'm carrying a .357 today.
I guess what I'm saying is if I knew I was going to get into something, I would opt for a Government .45, but walking around not knowing whether anything will happen and carrying a 66 .357 doesn't bother me.
Reply With Quote
  #23  
Old 05-07-2012, 04:57 PM
xICEMANx xICEMANx is offline
Member
Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357  
Join Date: Feb 2012
Location: Utah
Posts: 229
Likes: 3
Liked 43 Times in 36 Posts
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by blujax01 View Post
There is a paper entitled "Handgun Wounding Factors and Effectiveness" presented by the FBI Academy Firearms Training Unit.
The full text may be found here:
http://www.firearmstactical.com/pdf/fbi-hwfe.pdf

Excellent 20 minute read and the final paragraph sums it up quite nicely:
Kinetic energy does not wound. Temporary cavity does not wound. The much discussed "shock" of bullet impact is a fable and "knock down" power is a myth. The critical element is penetration. The bullet must pass through the large, blood bearing organs and be of sufficient diameter to promote rapid bleeding. Penetration less than 12 inches is too little, and, in the words of two of the participants in the 1987 Wound Ballistics Workshop, "too little penetration will get you killed." Given desirable and reliable penetration, the only way to increase bullet effectiveness is to increase the severity of the wound by increasing the size of hole made by the bullet. Any bullet which will not penetrate through vital organs from less than optimal angles is not acceptable. Of those that will penetrate, the edge is always with the bigger bullet.
Doesn't .357 tend to penetrate more than .45acp? Yet .45 is a bigger bullet. HMMM. Heck alot of 9mm loads penetrate better than .40 and .45. Kinda of contradicts that last line.
Reply With Quote
  #24  
Old 05-07-2012, 05:18 PM
ColColt's Avatar
ColColt ColColt is offline
Member
Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357  
Join Date: May 2010
Location: TN
Posts: 1,299
Likes: 27
Liked 284 Times in 131 Posts
Default

The 357 with the 125 gr bullet has an excellent track record unequaled even today from all the accounts I've read. Something like a 97% stopping power factor(not hit in the knee cap of course). Tremendous damage to tissue. Penetration is nothing like the 45 ACP with ball ammo which has been know to penetrate excessively-like 2-3 ft in ballistic gelatin compared to 13-15 inches for the 357. The 158 gr soft points or SWC's and heavier will penetrate more than the 125 gr JHP.If you can stand the noise indoors you can't beat the 357 for defense purposes. Various LE agencies carried them for years and have reported huge successes in stopping the bad guys.

Last edited by ColColt; 05-07-2012 at 05:24 PM.
Reply With Quote
  #25  
Old 05-07-2012, 05:49 PM
rjb1 rjb1 is offline
Member
Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357  
Join Date: Nov 2010
Posts: 109
Likes: 0
Liked 70 Times in 36 Posts
Default

"The 357 with the 125 gr bullet has an excellent track record unequaled even today from all the accounts I've read."

That's true, but there is an aspect of those "accounts" that I noticed a number of years ago that may be worth a comment.
In one of the gun magazines a famous writer who specialized in the "caliber effectiveness" topic that has been going on for years (decades) presented a plot of "% of one-stop" kills for various calibers. One thing that struck me as an engineer was that first, the data was a bit sparse at the high end, and second, he used a polynomial fit to generate the equation that tried to "best-fit" the data. The tendency of a polynomial fit is that there is/was a fall-off of the curve at the upper end, due to the nature of the equation.
This tended to slightly overstate the effectiveness of the .357 compared to .44's and .45's.
I would have liked to see the same data curve-fitted with an exponential fit. This would have allowed the curve to gradually go up and would have a greater tendency to flatten out at the top end.
I always felt that this would be a better way of presenting the data and would not be quite as counterintuitive as to suggest that smaller is better when it come to bullets. (even accounting for velocity differences)
From personal experience, you can generate curve fits that appear at first glance to really fit the data well, but when you look at the output carefully you can have a terrible fit except at a few points.
Reply With Quote
  #26  
Old 05-07-2012, 05:57 PM
Rule3's Avatar
Rule3 Rule3 is offline
Member
Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357  
Join Date: Feb 2008
Location: Florida
Posts: 22,065
Likes: 10,777
Liked 15,465 Times in 6,787 Posts
Default

As I generally like to say, In the overall scheme of things does it really matter??? ( we are talking SD distance and not a 400 yard shot)

Big and slow or smaller and faster, they both penetrate and make a very nasty hole.

Either one will do the job as will other calibers.
__________________
Still Running Against the Wind
Reply With Quote
  #27  
Old 05-07-2012, 06:12 PM
SicSemper SicSemper is offline
Banned
Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357  
Join Date: Apr 2012
Location: Hoscton GA
Posts: 49
Likes: 3
Liked 1 Time in 1 Post
Default

Just another tool in the box for HD/SD
Reply With Quote
  #28  
Old 05-07-2012, 06:56 PM
ColColt's Avatar
ColColt ColColt is offline
Member
Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357  
Join Date: May 2010
Location: TN
Posts: 1,299
Likes: 27
Liked 284 Times in 131 Posts
Default

I don't think in the real world anyone's concerned with polynomial fit and curves but actually accounts from police departments and highway patrol encounters and what happened and how quickly. The 357 has proven itself over the decades...what, since 1935? It all seems to me to be about velocity. The 125 gr bullet is not a very heavy bullet compared to the 45 Colt or ACP cartridge with a 230 or 255 gr bullet but is moving at quite a bit higher velocity(1350+fps) whereas the ACP might break 850 or so. Consider the 300 Weatherby. There's no doubt it's a deadly cartridge as many can attest who have hunted with it all over the world. Conversely, I doubt you would get the same results from a 30-30 that shoots a similar weight bullet. That little 125 gr bullet traveling as fast as it does disrupts a lot of tissue and damage is extreme.

As for sheer power and tremendous wound potential and the proverbial "one shot stopper" as a defense round, I vote for the 357 Magnum. Having said all that, I wouldn't want to fire one indoors. That's why I keep a 4506 with 200 gr Corbon hollow points under my pillow.

Last edited by ColColt; 05-07-2012 at 06:58 PM.
Reply With Quote
  #29  
Old 05-07-2012, 06:56 PM
smithnframe smithnframe is offline
Banned
Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357  
Join Date: Jul 2011
Location: Shiner, TX
Posts: 327
Likes: 71
Liked 53 Times in 34 Posts
Default

As Elmer Keith used to say "A heavy chunk of lead where it will do the most good"
Reply With Quote
The Following User Likes This Post:
  #30  
Old 05-07-2012, 07:05 PM
eshap2 eshap2 is offline
Member
Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357  
Join Date: Mar 2012
Location: CALIFORNIA
Posts: 101
Likes: 9
Liked 12 Times in 9 Posts
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by kbm6893 View Post
230 grain .45 ACP vs. 158 grain .357. Which one has more stopping power? Both seem to be about the same price.
45 THE ONLY WAY
Reply With Quote
  #31  
Old 05-07-2012, 07:10 PM
OK Hog Shooter's Avatar
OK Hog Shooter OK Hog Shooter is offline
Member
Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357  
Join Date: Oct 2010
Location: Central OK
Posts: 2,327
Likes: 610
Liked 420 Times in 263 Posts
Default

I don't want to get shot by either! ...for that matter, I'm not real fond of getting shot by a.22, either. Heck... I once got hit in the eye with a corn cob... during a barn corn cob fight... now THAT hurt!!! It was a country thing.

Hog
__________________
Isaiah 55:8-9
Phil. 4:13
Reply With Quote
The Following 2 Users Like Post:
  #32  
Old 05-07-2012, 07:12 PM
ColColt's Avatar
ColColt ColColt is offline
Member
Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357  
Join Date: May 2010
Location: TN
Posts: 1,299
Likes: 27
Liked 284 Times in 131 Posts
Default

We use to put berries from hedge bushes in our BB guns and shot at each other! I got hit in the side with no shirt on in the summer...now, that will smart!
Reply With Quote
  #33  
Old 05-07-2012, 07:21 PM
amazingflapjack amazingflapjack is offline
US Veteran
Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357  
Join Date: May 2010
Location: North Central Florida
Posts: 5,947
Likes: 24,644
Liked 6,195 Times in 2,575 Posts
Default

comment-comment-comment.
Reply With Quote
The Following User Likes This Post:
  #34  
Old 05-07-2012, 07:22 PM
blujax01's Avatar
blujax01 blujax01 is offline
Member
Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357  
Join Date: Aug 2010
Location: C-Bus
Posts: 6,335
Likes: 4,311
Liked 4,916 Times in 2,086 Posts
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by xICEMANx View Post
Doesn't .357 tend to penetrate more than .45acp? Yet .45 is a bigger bullet. HMMM. Heck alot of 9mm loads penetrate better than .40 and .45. Kinda of contradicts that last line.
Maybe but what I took away from it was that anything after 12" is gravy. So a .45 that will penetrate 12" will do more damage than a .357 at any depth.

As others have said though, it's all academic.
Reply With Quote
  #35  
Old 05-07-2012, 07:23 PM
blujax01's Avatar
blujax01 blujax01 is offline
Member
Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357  
Join Date: Aug 2010
Location: C-Bus
Posts: 6,335
Likes: 4,311
Liked 4,916 Times in 2,086 Posts
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by amazingflapjack View Post
comment-comment-comment.
mumble-mumble-mumble ...
Reply With Quote
The Following User Likes This Post:
  #36  
Old 05-07-2012, 07:24 PM
David LaPell's Avatar
David LaPell David LaPell is offline
Member
Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357  
Join Date: Mar 2008
Posts: 5,543
Likes: 667
Liked 6,774 Times in 1,312 Posts
Default

I laid out the argument before, I'll stick with the .357.

The Clash of the Cartridges: .357 Magnum vs. .45 ACP - Gun News at Guns.com
__________________
Vaya con Dios
Reply With Quote
The Following 2 Users Like Post:
  #37  
Old 05-07-2012, 08:44 PM
The Last Standing Knight The Last Standing Knight is offline
Member
Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357  
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: Southeast Texas
Posts: 1,648
Likes: 736
Liked 1,410 Times in 535 Posts
Default

This is the way I look at it, a 20mm cannon is useless if you can't hit anything with it. In short, it is the ability to call your shots at realistic ranges under pressure...not which is bigger or most powerful.
A Beeman Air Rifle can be just as deadly as a S&W M28 or a Colt 1911 in the right hands.
__________________
The Last Standing Knight
Reply With Quote
  #38  
Old 05-07-2012, 09:30 PM
brucev brucev is online now
Member
Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357  
Join Date: Feb 2008
Location: The Peach State! GA!!!
Posts: 5,913
Likes: 14,218
Liked 6,250 Times in 2,325 Posts
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by ColColt View Post
We use to put berries from hedge bushes in our BB guns and shot at each other! I got hit in the side with no shirt on in the summer...now, that will smart!
Yes! Shooting across the road taking cover in the ditches... it was really something. Later we graduated to pine cone wars (using green pine cones of course). Then came the ultimate... Whamo Wrist Rocket Slingshots using pecans. One of those things from inside 15-20 yards would really light someone up. When we all moved up to bows and arrows, we rapidly decided to stop shooting at each other There was just to much risk of injury.
__________________
<><

Last edited by brucev; 05-07-2012 at 09:38 PM.
Reply With Quote
  #39  
Old 05-07-2012, 10:20 PM
smithman 10's Avatar
smithman 10 smithman 10 is offline
US Veteran
Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357  
Join Date: Feb 2005
Location: Virginia
Posts: 749
Likes: 2,225
Liked 1,234 Times in 369 Posts
Default .45 vs. .357

After reading that post from the guy in the morgue now I'm a skeered to go outside with my little J-frame .38! I'd have to shoot 'em 15 times it looks like and they still might get me.

Shoot, might just as well leave my .38 at home and plan on running as fast as my 64-year old legs can carry me.

Problem is I just can't figure out a good way to carry a great big pistol with a caliber that starts with 4.

What should I do?

Terminal ballistics as viewed in a morgue
Reply With Quote
  #40  
Old 05-07-2012, 10:44 PM
OldArcher's Avatar
OldArcher OldArcher is offline
Member
Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357  
Join Date: May 2012
Location: The event horizon...
Posts: 49
Likes: 192
Liked 13 Times in 9 Posts
Default It all depends...

Which are you a better shot with? What platform? Are you shooting through barriers? Oh, my, so many questions, hmmmm?

Okay, here's the long and short of it...

Placement, placement, placement...

A .44 caliber S&W revolver holds the longest record of accuracy in history- STILL... Though not "powerful" compared to round count, bullet weight, nor velocity of some of today's firearms, it still has NO equal in the most important category... Comparing the 230gr .45acp with the 158gr .38 Special, is like apples and oranges... As no handgun, that I know of, can use both calibers, it's a subjective at best...

If you were to compare, say, S&W's Governor, using .45 Colt and .45acp, out of the same weapon, comparison's could be made, and objectively so... Here, the .45LC can be loaded to exceed the pressures found in a .44 Remington Magnum. However, the use of full-moon, half-moon, and third-moon clips would be efficacious, vis-a-vis HKS' speed loaders, where you have "all, or nothing at all." The ability to use 6, 3, or even 2 rounds in combination to reload, is awesome...

Which hit's harder? .45acp over any standard velocity .38 Special. Which is more accurate? Ever see the great movie, "Any Given Sunday?" That's it, in a nutshell... Accuracy is everything...

Use what you shoot best- don't let "experts" sway you. Go to the range, and find out for yourself. THEN, practice, practice, practice, and never stop practicing...

As for speed, Wyatt Earp put it best. "Make haste, slowly..." In other words, placement/aim, making your first shot count, was paramount to survival...

OA, out...

Gee, here's where I show how OLD I am... I should have used .357, instead of .38 Special... Okay, here's where the velocity vs mass comes into play... .357 is, indeed, faster and lighter. So, too, was the 9mm. Using this as a baseline, the .45acp has stopped more people in combat, when used in the same theaters of combat as the 9mm... Same goes for the .38 Special. In police combat, there have been more kills, with .357, as not that many police or LEO organizations used .45acp. Where there was commonality, cops invariably preferred the .45acp. The most highly regarded .357 goes back to the SuperVel load of 125gr. at more than 1450fps. Dynamic results were encountered, but that was before the FBI tests developed after the Miami Massacre... Today, so many perps wear soft to hard body armor, that you NEED blunt force trauma, just to get their attention... It used to be the venerable FTS drill... Armor, helmets, shields, and face plates have obviated that... No more, two to COM, one to the head... NOW, use all three to the head, if necessary... With the .45acp, you have less chance for a small, fast bullet to curve around the skull, just inside the skin... One 230gr. SCHP, and all you need is a sponge and a squeegee...

My choice? Bigger is better... 200gr +P trumps light and fast...

OA

Last edited by OldArcher; 05-07-2012 at 10:55 PM. Reason: Clarity and expansion of theme
Reply With Quote
  #41  
Old 05-07-2012, 11:12 PM
Powder Burns's Avatar
Powder Burns Powder Burns is offline
Member
 
Join Date: Oct 2007
Posts: 68
Likes: 0
Liked 10 Times in 5 Posts
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Skeeziks View Post
And if I did pull the trigger on him, the bullet would be a 200-gr. Gold Dot.
+1.
I also like 125gr more than 158gr in .357.

Last edited by Powder Burns; 05-07-2012 at 11:15 PM.
Reply With Quote
  #42  
Old 05-07-2012, 11:34 PM
SicSemper SicSemper is offline
Banned
Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357  
Join Date: Apr 2012
Location: Hoscton GA
Posts: 49
Likes: 3
Liked 1 Time in 1 Post
Default

When the .357 came out there slogon was "The .357 takes the proof out of bullet proof."
Reply With Quote
  #43  
Old 05-08-2012, 12:24 AM
WrongWay WrongWay is offline
Banned
Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357  
Join Date: May 2012
Location: Cincy, OH
Posts: 290
Likes: 294
Liked 104 Times in 59 Posts
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by kbm6893 View Post
230 grain .45 ACP vs. 158 grain .357. Which one has more stopping power? Both seem to be about the same price.
Check out this website, might be helpful.

StoppingPower.net Forums
Reply With Quote
  #44  
Old 05-08-2012, 08:15 AM
brucev brucev is online now
Member
Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357  
Join Date: Feb 2008
Location: The Peach State! GA!!!
Posts: 5,913
Likes: 14,218
Liked 6,250 Times in 2,325 Posts
Default

Re: OP. More powerful. It's a wash. Optimum loads in either caliber produce energy levels approximately similar to the point that any difference is irrelevant. If the issue is on target effectiveness, it depends. Some out of emotion will laud whatever they have used, seen used, etc. Experience is by many valued beyond theory advanced from any source.

Some will appeal to FBI research, which to some degree may be of worth. Some will prefer testing that is closer to that done by Thompson-LaGarde substituting goats for live cattle and human cadavers. Personally I don't know of anyone existent who has shot and killed enough men to know what they are talking about. But, there is a pool of men who have done so. That is the pool of policemen across our nation.

The very highest one shot stops are recorded for the .357 Magnum. According to Handgun Stopping Power by Marshall and Sanow, Fed. and Rem. produce 125 gr. JHP loads that penetrate 13-13.5 inches in 10% ballistic gelletin and produce 96% one shot stops. There are similar effective .45 ACP loads with penetration of up to 13.3 inches and 94% one stop shots. The difference is likely not meaningful.

Personally I've only shot game animals. I've killed and seen killed deer, hogs and various small game. I've watched heavy caliber rifles fail with good hits. I've seen deer drop like they were struck with the hammer of thor even though the round used was only a .30-30 or a .243 Winchester. I've killed a lot of deer using a plain .30-06. Not one has ever stood back up after I shot it. They all died on the spot. Does that mean the .30-06 is infallible. Of course not. It is simply my experience.

So... back to the OP... which is more powerful? Depending on how you want to weigh the evidence, factors, etc. involved, it will be the .357 Magnum... or the .45 ACP. It all depends. From my perspective, I prefer the .357 Magnum. I've seen what it can do. For that reason a 4" 66-2 occupies our bedside table loaded with 125 gr. Rem. JHP's. At across the room or down the hall distances it will doubtless live up to its 96% reputation. On the shelf underneath that nightstand is a RIA 1911 loaded with Winchester 230 gr. FMJ's. I haven't gotten around to buying a JHP load for that pistol. When I do, it will be loaded with them. And it will be on that shelf. If in a time of need it is the first thing that comes to hand, in comparison to the .357 Magnum, it will almost certainly be equally effective. Which ever comes to hand first will not be of much concern.
__________________
<><
Reply With Quote
The Following User Likes This Post:
  #45  
Old 05-08-2012, 08:03 PM
ColColt's Avatar
ColColt ColColt is offline
Member
Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357  
Join Date: May 2010
Location: TN
Posts: 1,299
Likes: 27
Liked 284 Times in 131 Posts
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by brucev View Post
Yes! Shooting across the road taking cover in the ditches... it was really something. Later we graduated to pine cone wars (using green pine cones of course). Then came the ultimate... Whamo Wrist Rocket Slingshots using pecans. One of those things from inside 15-20 yards would really light someone up. When we all moved up to bows and arrows, we rapidly decided to stop shooting at each other There was just to much risk of injury.
Yep, we had a sweet gum tree out back and I'd use the "cuckle berries" that fell to the ground (different from dingle berries) and use them in slingshots. Hurt like hell!
Reply With Quote
  #46  
Old 05-09-2012, 09:59 PM
m1gunner m1gunner is offline
US Veteran
Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357  
Join Date: Feb 2008
Location: middle Ga.
Posts: 2,525
Likes: 211
Liked 610 Times in 301 Posts
Default

My leanings are to the big chunk of lead moving at modest velocity. Muzzle energy figures make interesting conversation, as do geletin test data, but experience "shooting stuff" with both types of bullets speaks volumes.

The 36 caliber hi-tech hollow point, segmetated screamer may just fail to expand. The 230 gr 45 caliber round will always be at least .45 inches across.

The term "magnum" only refers to chamber pressure, it isn't some magical bullet property. Getting the job done with half the chamber pressure has advantages.

The 45 is known for excellent penetration (some call it excessive), but sometimes you have to shoot through something to hit your target.
A through and through will generate twice the number of "leaks" than will an entrance wound only.
Reply With Quote
The Following User Likes This Post:
  #47  
Old 05-10-2012, 07:59 AM
Stu Honea's Avatar
Stu Honea Stu Honea is offline
Member
Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357  
Join Date: Mar 2010
Location: Northwest Georgia
Posts: 832
Likes: 276
Liked 335 Times in 182 Posts
Default

Without possession of indisputable factual information,capable of being presented as an evidentiary article,which would lend credence to,or support a certain degree of accuracy,free of speculative assumption,in determining and providing a logically presumable correct answer to your question,I would decline to express a definite opinion.
__________________
Blessed be the Lord,my Rock
Reply With Quote
The Following 2 Users Like Post:
  #48  
Old 05-11-2012, 03:53 AM
ArchAngelCD's Avatar
ArchAngelCD ArchAngelCD is offline
Moderator
SWCA Member
Absent Comrade
Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357  
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: Northeast PA, USA
Posts: 8,877
Likes: 1,029
Liked 5,070 Times in 2,660 Posts
Default

Dead is Dead no matter how you get there!
__________________
Freedom is never free!!
SWCA #3437
Reply With Quote
The Following User Likes This Post:
  #49  
Old 05-11-2012, 01:25 PM
blujax01's Avatar
blujax01 blujax01 is offline
Member
Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357  
Join Date: Aug 2010
Location: C-Bus
Posts: 6,335
Likes: 4,311
Liked 4,916 Times in 2,086 Posts
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Stu Honea View Post
Without possession of indisputable factual information,capable of being presented as an evidentiary article,which would lend credence to,or support a certain degree of accuracy,free of speculative assumption,in determining and providing a logically presumable correct answer to your question,I would decline to express a definite opinion.
Wow if I took that stance I wouldn't even need an Internet connection!
Reply With Quote
  #50  
Old 05-11-2012, 01:29 PM
PALADIN85020's Avatar
PALADIN85020 PALADIN85020 is offline
US Veteran
Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357 Which is more powerful?  .45 or .357  
Join Date: Jan 2007
Location: Arizona
Posts: 10,440
Likes: 3,924
Liked 50,372 Times in 6,009 Posts
Default



Either one works fine. Shot placement is the key.

John
__________________
- Cogito, ergo armatus sum -
Reply With Quote
Reply

Tags
1911, 230gr, 243, 357 magnum, 380, 45acp, 642, cartridge, ccw, chamber pressure, colt, m28, model 28, ppc, remington, ruger, smith & wesson, smith and wesson, snubnose, sp101, thompson, weatherby, winchester, wwii

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
Forum Jump

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
15-22 in a more powerful caliber Kenneth07ex Smith & Wesson - The Wish List 4 02-23-2017 01:46 AM
Most Powerful ? walkinghorse The Lounge 21 01-09-2017 02:46 PM
38s&w more powerful than a .380? donniedee Ammo 41 06-03-2016 04:47 AM
If you like lite and powerful SilentKnight Ammo 4 09-05-2015 05:04 AM

Powered by vBadvanced CMPS v3.2.3
smith-wessonforum.com tested by Norton Internet Security smith-wessonforum.com tested by McAfee Internet Security

All times are GMT -4. The time now is 04:00 PM.


Smith-WessonForum.com is not affiliated with Smith & Wesson Holding Corporation (NASDAQ Global Select: SWHC)