Smith & Wesson Forum

Go Back   Smith & Wesson Forum > Ammunition-Gunsmithing > Ammo
Forum Register Expert Commentary Members List


Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Search this Thread Display Modes
  #1  
Old 08-09-2009, 06:08 PM
David LaPell's Avatar
Member
 
Join Date: Mar 2008
Posts: 4,876
Likes: 276
Liked 2,341 Times in 815 Posts
Default .44 Special vs .45 Colt on whitetail deer

Ok, most of you that know me know that I love old time cartridges. So, between the two, which would be better on whitetail deer? I have always had a warm place in my heart for both the .44 Special and the .45 Colt, but to me, there is something to be said about using a modern .44 Special like a 624 or 24-3 with a 250 grain cast Lyman #429421 behind Skeeter's old load of 7.5 grains of Unique against a whitetail buck.
__________________
Vaya con Dios
Reply With Quote
  #2  
Old 08-09-2009, 06:24 PM
US Veteran
 
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: The Rust Belt Buckle/Mich
Posts: 2,404
Likes: 0
Liked 14 Times in 10 Posts
Default

With a decent length barrel and the best factory loads in each caliber the deer likely won't know the difference. Handloaded hot, the .45 Colt in the right gun can out run the .44 magnum. So It gets the nod in that case.
Reply With Quote
  #3  
Old 08-09-2009, 06:25 PM
Member
 
Join Date: May 2009
Location: Texas
Posts: 2,089
Likes: 5
Liked 402 Times in 249 Posts
Default

I would prefer the 44 Special, but I would use one of Elmer Keith's 2400 loads for deer hunting.
Reply With Quote
  #4  
Old 08-09-2009, 06:53 PM
Member
 
Join Date: May 2006
Posts: 1,800
Likes: 44
Liked 312 Times in 155 Posts
Default

I vote for the bigger hole..........45LC.
Reply With Quote
  #5  
Old 08-09-2009, 07:59 PM
Member
 
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: Texas
Posts: 11,009
Likes: 6,413
Liked 3,102 Times in 1,732 Posts
Default

In factory loads, the .45. With suitable handloads, either.
But unless you're using a big Ruger SA, the thinner chamber walls in tthe .45 require the .44, if you're loading hot. Elmer Keith had discovered that by the 1920's!

I'm sure that your Skelton load will work to at least 60 yards, but is on the light side if you're deliberately hunting a deer, as opposed to taking a target of opportunity under ideal circumstances.

If you hunt with a handgun, I really think the .44 Magnum is a better choice, and you don't have to worry about acccidentally slipping a "Ruger only" .45 round into an old Colt New Service or SAA. Or, a M-25-5, this being the S&W forum...

T-Star
Reply With Quote
  #6  
Old 08-12-2009, 09:57 AM
Mule88's Avatar
SWCA Member
 
Join Date: Jul 2004
Location: Vandalia, Ohio
Posts: 1,643
Likes: 154
Liked 130 Times in 81 Posts
Default

With the right load, the whitetail wont know the difference between the 44 or 45. So shoot the one one you like and enjoy yourself.
Reply With Quote
  #7  
Old 08-12-2009, 10:19 AM
bmcgilvray's Avatar
SWCA Member
 
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: Texas
Posts: 2,224
Likes: 1,103
Liked 721 Times in 234 Posts
Default

Assuming good hits there's no way there's any difference in between the two cartridges.
Reply With Quote
  #8  
Old 08-22-2009, 05:38 PM
TJC TJC is offline
Member
 
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: NJ
Posts: 7
Likes: 0
Liked 0 Times in 0 Posts
Default

I have and load for a 25-5. The .45LC as stated is as good/better than a .44 Mag if loaded right. It also makes a bigger hole which is nice.
Reply With Quote
  #9  
Old 08-23-2009, 01:51 AM
Vulcan Bob's Avatar
Member
 
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: central pa
Posts: 3,862
Likes: 540
Liked 580 Times in 326 Posts
Default

With proper bullet placement,(all calibers) Skeeters .44 Special load will work just fine! Used to use the same load in a Ruger .44 mag and had no trouble with the three whitetails I bagged. The only whitetail that left the front sight was one I nailed in the lungs useing the Speer .44 225 gr half jacket hollow point. It sorta blew up on a rib on the way in and not much of it reached the off side lung. Had to track that one for a bit, never used a jacketed hollowpoint again. Hard cast LSWC, big hole in, big hole out, works every time!
__________________
Stay safe people!
Reply With Quote
  #10  
Old 09-02-2009, 08:10 AM
US Veteran
 
Join Date: Nov 2008
Location: Colorado
Posts: 1,809
Likes: 199
Liked 2,719 Times in 540 Posts
Default

Many years ago, while serving on a US military base in the south, I took several whitetails using an issued M1911A1 .45 ACP 230-grain ball ammo. All were taken within 25 yards, and all were one-shot kills with heart-lung shots.

Both the .44 Special and .45 Colt are superior in power to the .45 ACP. I would recommend the heavy semi-wadcutter bullets for this use.
Reply With Quote
  #11  
Old 09-02-2009, 10:14 AM
Member
 
Join Date: Jun 2009
Location: Near Tallahassee, FL
Posts: 74
Likes: 0
Liked 2 Times in 1 Post
Default

Critters can't tell the difference.
Reply With Quote
  #12  
Old 09-02-2009, 10:17 AM
redlevel's Avatar
Member
 
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location: GA
Posts: 4,017
Likes: 2,309
Liked 3,565 Times in 1,055 Posts
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by David LaPell View Post
a 250 grain cast Lyman #429421 behind Skeeter's old load of 7.5 grains of Unique against a whitetail buck.
That will surely work, but I feel a whole lot more comfortable with my 7.5" Blackhawk .45 with a 250 grain SWC and 10.0 grains of Unique. I have recently reduced that load to 9.0 grains of Unique, but I still have several hundred rounds of the old 10 grain load.

That 10 grain load will punch through a 150 pound Georgia whitetail more times than not, usually taking out both front shoulders. The bullet will usually either pooch up under the off-side skin, or go clean through. That is from the Blackhawk or a Trapper 94 Winchester.

I believe I will "sight in" the Winchester this weekend. I have seen two nice bucks on one of my places, and my neighbor stopped me Saturday and told me he had seen them just minutes before, crossing the road going through my place. Gun season opens here in five or six weeks.
__________________
Georgia On My Mind
Reply With Quote
Reply

Tags
44 magnum, 624, colt, military, model 25, ruger, saa, skeeter, skelton, wadcutter, winchester

Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes

Posting Rules
Ammo Thread, .44 Special vs .45 Colt on whitetail deer in Ammunition-Gunsmithing; Ok, most of you that know me know that I love old time cartridges. So, between the two, which would ...
Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
WTS Colt Python Snub/Colt Detc Special NIB DFW roman3667 GUNS - For Sale or Trade 4 11-17-2011 01:19 PM
FS: 25-7 45 Colt, Colt SAA 44, 1905 4th 32-20, 44 Special 2nd Model, Kart 22 conv. FRBowers GUNS - For Sale or Trade 4 11-05-2010 07:36 PM
SPF Colt Agent, Colt Detective Special in Nickel NukeFromOrbit GUNS - For Sale or Trade 0 12-20-2009 09:33 PM
.44 Special vs .357 Magnum for whitetail David LaPell Ammo 9 09-08-2009 02:09 AM
.44 Special for Whitetail David LaPell Reloading 16 01-12-2009 10:29 AM

Powered by vBadvanced CMPS v3.2.3
smith-wessonforum.com tested by Norton Internet Security smith-wessonforum.com tested by McAfee Internet Security

All times are GMT -4. The time now is 02:37 PM.


S-W Forum, LLC 2000-2015
Smith-WessonForum.com is not affiliated with Smith & Wesson Holding Corporation (NASDAQ Global Select: SWHC)