Model 25-5 stainless????

O

oneharleypapa

Member
Joined
Sep 9, 2010
Messages
29
Reaction score
30
Location
Georgia
Has anyone ever heard of a model 25-5 in stainless? I saw one this week that appears to be stainless. I thought it might be satin nickel but i removed the side cover and scratched the inside and it appaears to be stainless. The serial number is N6788xx. What year would that be.
 
Register to hide this ad
Welcome.Unless it is a mismarked gun, it is not stainless.A nickle gun will have a "N" on the cylinder,elsewhere too I believe.The gun may have been refinished too.
All stainless guns start with a 6 in the model number.There is a 625.
 
Yes I know about the 6 in the model number there is no N on the cylinder but there is the letters X3.
 
They did make a 625-5 - for about a year and a half. If it is a .45 Colt chambered gun, and a dash 5 at that, it'll have a full underlugged barrel. If it doesn't, it's been re-finished in some type of after market finish like metaloy, hardchrome, etc.
 
oneharleypapa said:
Yes I know about the 6 in the model number there is no N on the cylinder but there is the letters X3.
Click to expand...

N 600000 would have been a 1979 gun. The X3 is an assembler's or fitter's stamp and doesn't indicate a finish type. If it has a satin finish, agree it probably has been hard chromed or otherwise refinished.
 
A stainless gun would have a model number beginning with the numeral 6. As in 66, 686, 0r 625.
A model 25 would not be stainless.
 
A stainless steel, 4 inch standard barrel .45 Colt is one gun that S&W should have made but never did. I kept waiting for them to do so. Good thing I didn't hold my breath!
 
Guys I have purchased this gun and totaly disassembled it. I may be new to the S&W forum but I have been in the firearms business for 25 yrs. I know about the "N" for nickel and the "6" for stainless. I removed a small amount of metal from the sideplate with a file and the finnish goes all the way thru.I am totaly baffled by this gun and may spend the money to get a factory letter. Thanks for all the info and will let you know any other info I find and would appreciate any and all feedback. After looking at ordinary run of the mill stuff all day at the shop it is refreshing to see something interestig
 
Not stainless

I suspect you're looking at a gun that has been bead blasted and is now in the 'white'. The bead blast would give it a matte look.
 
I believe that if there isn't any other markings to show anything other than a 25-5, S&WIowegan nailed it. I know you are hoping that in spite of what everyone says here that you have something rare or special, but there are enough hardcore S&W collectors here, that if one in SS ever had been made, they'd know about it and it most likely would have went to someone very special or been some sort of backdoor deal. Lettering it would be 99,99% pointless.
 
Last edited:
Just thinking... If you scraped off some of one of the hard chrome or industrial nickel finishes, wouldn't the metal underneath be silver, too? It is just chrome moly.
 
I've got a similar 25-9. It looks identical to my 624 and 629 except for the front sight. No letter or tests yet. Serial# BFR01XX. It has a black insert front sight. Top strap appears to be bead blasted, everything else appears to be polished. Stampings are very crisp. Hammer and trigger are case hardened. I haven't taken it apart. I got it about a year ago. It shoots good. If it ain't stainless it oughta be.
 
BUFF said:
Just thinking... If you scraped off some of one of the hard chrome or industrial nickel finishes, wouldn't the metal underneath be silver, too? It is just chrome moly.
Click to expand...


That was my thought too, when I read that. It would be very difficult to scratch the surface of a hardchrome type finish without going right on into the bare steel under it, which would also appear "white/SS".
 
Try sticking a magnet to the sideplate, that should solve the riddle.............
 
Magnets won't work. The stainless alloy Smith uses is just as magnetic as the carbon steel...well, as far as I can tell, I'm sure a calibrated magnetic test may prove other wise.

Scratch through the finish and put a drop of cold blue on the scratch. Stainless steel and regular steel look the same, but, only carbon steel will change color.

I am virtually certain you have a hard chromed 25-5.

Reminds me of the mismarked model 64 I have with the blue finish...........


:)
 
This is another of those once or twice a week threads. The probability that the gun has an aftermarket hardchrome or satin nickel finish is about 99.9%, especially if the gun is clearly marked M25-5 in the frame's yolk cutout. The factory stainless steel finish has easily discernible grain from the buffing wheels while hardchrome almost universally has a soft matte, bead blasted finish.

;)

Bruce
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Dump1567
65-5 show and tell
2
Replies
27
Views
1K
roninflag
R
C
pondering another Satin Nickel 469
Replies
14
Views
547
cschell
C
S
Ruger Redhawk replacing S&W 25-5 (.45s and family)
2 3
Replies
49
Views
3K
Mike SC Hunter
M
S
S&W 25-5 cylinder reaming
2
Replies
20
Views
2K
Shrek Of The Arctic
S
madmikeb
Picked up a 629 "Frankengun"!
Replies
9
Views
582
CWH44300
C

Latest posts

Back
Top