Your opinions please.
Which do you think is better for carry?

Unless you're married to Safariland, I prefer HKS . . .

__________________
Wisdom comes thru fear . . .

I've always used HKS even when I wasn't supposed to have a speedloader in my possession. However, lately people have been whispering in my ear that Safariland is better.

I strongly prefer Safariland to HKS. As far as I vs II, it depends on how you carry them. In a belt holder, the II gives a handle to grab. In a pocket, that is probably not an issue, and the I may fit more easily. When possible, I would pick a Jetloader over a Comp II, although the difference is probably small. A Comp III is larger than necessary, and offers nothing over a Jetloader.

They each have their advantages and disadvantages. HKS are easier to load, and you know how they release. Safariland release by pushing forward with purpose. I've seen Safariland disintegrate like they were hit with a hammer, and I've also seen them not release after a chunk of something got lodged under the star. The big knock on HKS is the twist to release, and they also tend to rattle a little with age. HKS is what I grew up with. I tried Safariland for while, but eventually went back to HKS.

__________________
Wisdom comes thru fear . . .

Always wore Comp II on duty belt and Comp I off duty. Now that I am retired, I prefer the Comp I. As stated above, easier for pocket carry. Know there are lots of HKS fans out there, but always found Safariland to be superior. Just pushing down to release rounds, instead of turning knob works better for me. Good luck!

I've had HKS release in a pocket, never with a Comp I or II. Comp II on the range, Comp I for carry

__________________
K & N S&W revolvers

Get your cylinder cut for moon clips.

Speed loaders are so old fashion.

__________________
NEVER GIVE UP YOUR GUN

What are ya' doin' down there . . . ?

__________________
Wisdom comes thru fear . . .

"Is that a speed loader in your pocket or are you just glad to see me"

__________________
NEVER GIVE UP YOUR GUN

I strongly prefer Safariland over HKS and prefer the Comp II over the Comp I.

Without going into the whole Safariland vs. HKS spiel...

My personal preference is COMP-1 for J-Frames, and COMP-2 for K/L Frames (and Colt D-Frames).

To be honest, though, I can't say I've ever come across a COMP-1 for the larger revolvers. I know they've existed, but I much prefer the taller profile COMP-2 for use with the service-sized Smiths.

Edit: Almost lost sight of your original question! For carry, the COMP-1 has the lowest profile by far. The COMP-2 isn't that much bulkier, but rides a little higher. I use Safariland's own Split Five/Six holders, in case you were wondering.

I gave away my HKS speed loaders after I tried a CompI.