The retention strap goes around the back of the frame, so it will accommodate the 637 638 and 642 the same.
As far as retention, the non thumb break model is very snug fitting, especially at first. I would liken it to level 1 kydex retention. I highly doubt it would come out while running, but maybe during a fight, etc.
If you use a thumb break retention holster for your primary weapon, then I might lean towards that since you have that muscle memory.
I don't have long term experience with J frame ankle carry, although I would recommend carrying something on your other ankle to balance it out.
I really only carry a .380 for ankle carry anymore. It's lighter weight and quieter - no cartridge rattle.
|