Smith & Wesson Forum

Go Back   Smith & Wesson Forum > >


Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old 11-24-2011, 11:16 AM
walnutred walnutred is offline
US Veteran
22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2? 22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2? 22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2? 22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2? 22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2?  
Join Date: Jan 2007
Location: Ohio
Posts: 3,624
Likes: 69
Liked 1,092 Times in 452 Posts
Default 22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2?

I've decided that my New Years present to myself this year will be a left handed Savage in either 22 Mag , 17 HMR or 17 HM2. While it might occasionally get used for pest control the main use will be at the local 100 yd rifle range. I have rifles in both Mag and HMR, I've just decided I want another left handed bolt gun except in a caliber for which I don't feel compelled to reload.

So which would you choose and why?
Reply With Quote
  #2  
Old 11-24-2011, 12:20 PM
novalty's Avatar
novalty novalty is offline
Member
22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2? 22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2? 22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2? 22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2? 22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2?  
Join Date: May 2009
Location: Southern Maine
Posts: 13,595
Likes: 468
Liked 1,789 Times in 961 Posts
Default

I would get .22mag, find it to be more readily available in my area.
Reply With Quote
  #3  
Old 11-24-2011, 12:27 PM
Trooperdan Trooperdan is offline
US Veteran
22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2? 22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2? 22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2? 22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2? 22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2?  
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: Wellington FL Aberdeen NC
Posts: 993
Likes: 1,368
Liked 542 Times in 212 Posts
Default

I'd hold out for a Savage in the new .17 Hornet that is coming out next year! But, that's me 'cause I'm a reloader!
__________________
Old paratrooper in NC
Reply With Quote
  #4  
Old 11-24-2011, 12:47 PM
Stevie Stevie is offline
Member
 
Join Date: Feb 2004
Location: OK. U.S.A.
Posts: 979
Likes: 3
Liked 193 Times in 126 Posts
Default

I've never shot the .17HM2...but between the .22 Winchester magnum and the .17HMR..I would go .22 magnum myself.
Reply With Quote
  #5  
Old 11-24-2011, 01:22 PM
charliek charliek is offline
Member
22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2? 22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2? 22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2? 22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2? 22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2?  
Join Date: Jul 2011
Location: Louisville
Posts: 35
Likes: 0
Liked 0 Times in 0 Posts
Default

I own both .22 mag and .17 HMR. handguns, and the .17 will shoot groups at 100 yds the same as my Colt New Frontier shoots at 25. I have a Savage 93 pre accu-trigger .17 HMR that shoots MOA or better at 100 yds. I would go with the .17 HMR handsdown, besides, it's a cool looking cartridge!
Reply With Quote
  #6  
Old 11-24-2011, 01:23 PM
perrazi perrazi is offline
Absent Comrade
 
Join Date: Jan 2009
Posts: 3,007
Likes: 845
Liked 870 Times in 479 Posts
Default

lot better ammo selection for the 22 mag and easier to find.
Reply With Quote
  #7  
Old 11-24-2011, 02:13 PM
Rule3's Avatar
Rule3 Rule3 is online now
Member
22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2? 22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2? 22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2? 22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2? 22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2?  
Join Date: Feb 2008
Location: Florida, NRA CERT RSO
Posts: 16,749
Likes: 6,551
Liked 6,712 Times in 3,500 Posts
Default

As a reloader I just can not see the purpose of a 22Mag? It ain't cheap to buy. I would rather have a 22 Hornet

But if not a problem buying ammo, then the 22 Mag due to availability of ammo and I know little about the 17's
__________________
"Running Against the Wind"
Reply With Quote
  #8  
Old 11-24-2011, 02:20 PM
growr growr is offline
Member
 
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: Montana
Posts: 2,862
Likes: 1,231
Liked 1,328 Times in 629 Posts
Default

My favorite gopher shooting cartridge! I have been out with others using all of the other calibers you mentioned including the vaunted 22 Hornet. My good friend has a Hornet and at the end of the day his comment to was that he had totally changed his opinion of the 22 mag.

In his words, " There wasn't anything that I could do with my Hornet that you couldn't do equally as well with your 22 Mag and your not spending a bunch of time looking for brass! Gonna have to get one of those Marlins.."

My gun is a Marlin 25MN with a Sightron 3-9 scope on it and I have about 6-7 magazines that I keep topped off when in a target rich environment.

Randy
Reply With Quote
  #9  
Old 11-24-2011, 03:34 PM
Kanewpadle's Avatar
Kanewpadle Kanewpadle is offline
US Veteran
22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2? 22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2? 22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2? 22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2? 22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2?  
Join Date: Nov 2009
Location: Washifornia
Posts: 6,846
Likes: 4,933
Liked 7,266 Times in 2,608 Posts
Default

I had the 17HMR Savage with Accutrigger. Very accurate. Fun shooting.

Considering the low cost of the Savage I would go with the 17 HMR. If your willing to pay the cost of 22 Mag or 17 HMR ammo to plink with, the 17 is a no brainer.
Reply With Quote
  #10  
Old 11-24-2011, 04:28 PM
JohnK JohnK is offline
US Veteran
22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2? 22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2? 22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2? 22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2? 22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2?  
Join Date: Oct 2002
Location: Tennessee., USA
Posts: 632
Likes: 1
Liked 200 Times in 101 Posts
Default

Both .17's are inherently more accurate, that most of the .22 Mags. Yes I own them all.

The much flatter trajectory, and better accuracy of the .17's make them a superior 100 yard target gun, and a superior small game load to over 100 yards.
__________________
NRA Instructor
Reply With Quote
  #11  
Old 11-24-2011, 04:39 PM
dmar dmar is offline
Member
 
Join Date: Aug 2008
Posts: 1,664
Likes: 1,642
Liked 1,021 Times in 465 Posts
Default

It all depends on what you are looking to do with it. The mag is a great all around cartridge, plinking and small game (especially at closer range) applications.

The .17 HMR is a very fun round. I agree that it is the ultimate ground hog/prarie dog round. I've taken prarie dogs out west, at 280 yards with the .17. And, it is very accurate, and a flatter shooting round. For hunting small game, at longer distances, or straight up target work, no question the .17 is the way to go. For all around use, the .22 mag would probably get the nod. If I could only have one, it would be the .17 HMR...
__________________
NRA Life Member
Reply With Quote
  #12  
Old 11-24-2011, 06:23 PM
Speedo2 Speedo2 is offline
SWCA Member
22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2? 22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2? 22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2? 22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2? 22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2?  
Join Date: Jan 2003
Location: Western PA
Posts: 1,124
Likes: 168
Liked 294 Times in 124 Posts
Default

removed PC

Last edited by Speedo2; 11-27-2012 at 09:39 PM.
Reply With Quote
  #13  
Old 11-24-2011, 08:27 PM
sheriffoconee's Avatar
sheriffoconee sheriffoconee is offline
Member
22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2? 22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2? 22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2? 22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2? 22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2?  
Join Date: Nov 2009
Location: Watkinsville, GA
Posts: 1,846
Likes: 0
Liked 108 Times in 39 Posts
Default

I am firmly committed to the 17 HMR....and my Savage rifle that shoots it...I am a lefty and my rifle is a righty, but we work it out somehow....
It is a supreme squirrel slayer, especially with the 17 grain pills...the 20s do a good job too....but my rifle loves the 17's more.
I have a SWR Spectre can on mine....which quiets the noise a bit in spite of the supersonic ammo....
I rarely shoot many of my 22LR rifles anymore for anything other than plinking...anything my LR rifles can do my 17 HMR seems to do better....and I have a good stock of ammo, so my 17 gets "the call" most of the time
Reply With Quote
  #14  
Old 11-24-2011, 08:31 PM
Kanewpadle's Avatar
Kanewpadle Kanewpadle is offline
US Veteran
22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2? 22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2? 22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2? 22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2? 22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2?  
Join Date: Nov 2009
Location: Washifornia
Posts: 6,846
Likes: 4,933
Liked 7,266 Times in 2,608 Posts
Default

I watched guys on Youtube shoot prarie dogs with the 17 HMR. The little dogs dropped right where they stood. Impressive.
Reply With Quote
  #15  
Old 11-25-2011, 10:50 PM
mtgianni mtgianni is offline
Member
22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2? 22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2? 22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2? 22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2? 22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2?  
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: SW MT
Posts: 2,406
Likes: 594
Liked 680 Times in 454 Posts
Default

I would yawn and look at centerfire 22's. Reload for a lot less than 22 mag or any 17 rimfire.
__________________
Front sight and squeeze
Reply With Quote
  #16  
Old 11-25-2011, 11:34 PM
jrd1976 jrd1976 is offline
SWCA Member
22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2? 22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2? 22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2? 22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2? 22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2?  
Join Date: May 2008
Location: Louisiana
Posts: 659
Likes: 55
Liked 270 Times in 117 Posts
Default

I would vote for the 22mag. the Winchester Supreme 34 grain HP is the most accurate and devastating brand out of my 6" S&W Model 48. I've taken cottontails, prairie dogs, jackrabbits and armadillos with it.

My son has a Savage bolt gun in 17Mach2 that is very accurate. However he wishes it was a 17 HMR for more velocity.
Reply With Quote
  #17  
Old 11-26-2011, 06:58 AM
walnutred walnutred is offline
US Veteran
22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2? 22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2? 22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2? 22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2? 22 Mag or 17 HMR or 17 HM2?  
Join Date: Jan 2007
Location: Ohio
Posts: 3,624
Likes: 69
Liked 1,092 Times in 452 Posts
Default

Thanks guys, your thoughts were interesting and informative. I decided on the 22 mag for the following reasons. Heck, who am I trying to kid. For what I'm doing there is no strong justification in choosing one over the other or even choosing a new rifle. If I was being totally practical I would probably have bought a 22LR for the 100 yd shooting I specified. However for what target grade 22 ammo costs I can buy ammo for any of the other three calibers mentioned.

As for rimfire over center fire. I ether still own or have owned and reloaded for 22 Hornet. 222. 223 and 22-250. So I'm at least familiar with the older 22 center fires. However most of my varmint hunting was actually either done with a 22 mag,32 S&W Long, 32-20 or 7x57 Ackley Improved. Sometimes though I just want to take an accurate firearm to the 100 yd range or back pasture without thinking about reloading or retrieving brass.
Reply With Quote
Reply

Tags
223, 22lr, anschutz, cartridge, colt, rimfire, ruger, savage, scope, winchester

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
Forum Jump

Powered by vBadvanced CMPS v3.2.3
smith-wessonforum.com tested by Norton Internet Security smith-wessonforum.com tested by McAfee Internet Security

All times are GMT -4. The time now is 05:03 PM.


S-W Forum, LLC 2000-2015
Smith-WessonForum.com is not affiliated with Smith & Wesson Holding Corporation (NASDAQ Global Select: SWHC)