Smith & Wesson Forum

Go Back   Smith & Wesson Forum > Ammunition-Gunsmithing > Reloading
o

Notices

Reloading All Reloading Topics Go Here


Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old 08-31-2018, 04:39 PM
jimmyj's Avatar
jimmyj jimmyj is offline
Member
Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question  
Join Date: May 2003
Location: DUNNELLON, FLORIDA USA
Posts: 11,102
Likes: 1,690
Liked 16,300 Times in 4,231 Posts
Smile Fired Cases Question

Hi:
When the fired cases from a revolver has smut on them, what is the cause ?
I am thinking crimp too light or bullet lub ?

Thanks.
Jimmy
Reply With Quote
The Following User Likes This Post:
  #2  
Old 08-31-2018, 05:00 PM
k22fan k22fan is offline
Member
Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question  
Join Date: Feb 2010
Posts: 5,835
Likes: 5,161
Liked 5,242 Times in 2,483 Posts
Default

Obviously the pressure is to low to press the case walls tight enough against the chamber to seal off the gas. When that's happening there can not be any concern about bursting the cylinder so a little more powder might be the answer. More crimp might help a tiny bit but a heavy crimp does more to help slow powder magnum changes burn.
Reply With Quote
  #3  
Old 08-31-2018, 05:02 PM
rockquarry rockquarry is online now
Member
 
Join Date: Aug 2005
Posts: 7,552
Likes: 4
Liked 8,885 Times in 4,121 Posts
Default

Not sure how to respond as I don't know that I've ever encountered what you mention. Perhaps a photo would help.

I use only cast bullets in handguns and don't recall ever seeing but the slightest residue, if any, on cases fired in revolvers or automatics. Regardless of the type crimp used, I crimp everything as lightly as possible.

I'm somewhat skeptical of the "dirty powder syndrome" unless an unsuitable powder and/or the wrong charge weight is used in a load. Perhaps that will cause dirty cases, but I don't know that for sure.

Bullet lube often makes smoke upon firing and may leave residue on the outside of the cylinder and cylinder face, but it has minimal effect on brass. A soft lube is mostly consumed anyway and a portion of hard lube often stays on the bullet to the target.
Reply With Quote
  #4  
Old 08-31-2018, 05:17 PM
arjay's Avatar
arjay arjay is offline
Member
Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question  
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: Colorado
Posts: 15,082
Likes: 91,551
Liked 26,243 Times in 8,376 Posts
Default

I agree with k22fan.Too light of a charge
Reply With Quote
The Following 2 Users Like Post:
  #5  
Old 08-31-2018, 06:17 PM
fredj338's Avatar
fredj338 fredj338 is offline
Member
 
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: Kalif. usa
Posts: 6,836
Likes: 2,665
Liked 3,927 Times in 2,366 Posts
Default

Lubed lead bullets are always going to be dirtier shooting. The carbon mixes with the lube & you get stuff all over the gun. If you are getting large scorched sections of brass down the outsize, probably very low pressure.
__________________
NRA Cert. Inst. IDPA CSO
Reply With Quote
  #6  
Old 08-31-2018, 08:19 PM
hdwhit hdwhit is offline
Member
Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question  
Join Date: Sep 2016
Location: North Texas
Posts: 804
Likes: 86
Liked 482 Times in 300 Posts
Default

I concur with k22fan and arjay; too light a charge leading to insufficient pressure to expand the case walls against the chamber.

A big isn't necessary. A tiny increase in charge may be all that's needed to get the pressure into an appropriate range.
Reply With Quote
The Following User Likes This Post:
  #7  
Old 08-31-2018, 08:20 PM
jimmyj's Avatar
jimmyj jimmyj is offline
Member
Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question  
Join Date: May 2003
Location: DUNNELLON, FLORIDA USA
Posts: 11,102
Likes: 1,690
Liked 16,300 Times in 4,231 Posts
Default

.45 Auto Rim cases with a 200 grain cast LSWC and 4.5 grains Bullseye is what I am using
Reply With Quote
  #8  
Old 08-31-2018, 08:30 PM
Wise_A Wise_A is offline
Banned
Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question  
Join Date: May 2016
Posts: 3,121
Likes: 2,661
Liked 4,324 Times in 1,793 Posts
Default

It's only a problem if you think it's a problem.
Reply With Quote
The Following 7 Users Like Post:
  #9  
Old 08-31-2018, 11:36 PM
Nevada Ed's Avatar
Nevada Ed Nevada Ed is offline
US Veteran
Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question  
Join Date: Nov 2012
Location: Reno Nv
Posts: 13,376
Likes: 3,183
Liked 12,712 Times in 5,669 Posts
Default

I did a lot of X-lite 9mm loads to see what powders would still
work the pistol and be on the clean side, c/o the brass cases.

Any powder can be loaded too low for its burn rate and leave a
dirty case, even if it might eject and push a bullet out of the barrel.

However you do want a "Safe working" load that will not have a "Squib"
incase a powder throw is on the light side, which can happen.

I had a 3" Kahr 9mm that had a dirty starting load but just .1 more powder
added 30fps and the case was on the cleaner side, that I could live with.

In my 9mm pistol loads, CFE pistol has given me light loads with good accuracy.
W231 has also worked but I do not load 45 cal. so you will have to
get more info on what powders might work for you but.............
you might add .2 grains to your load and see if things improve
in accuracy and cleaner cases. Just a normal crimp should work.

Good shooting.
Reply With Quote
  #10  
Old 09-01-2018, 06:10 AM
alwslate alwslate is offline
Member
Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question  
Join Date: Dec 2009
Location: Indiana
Posts: 6,605
Likes: 3,691
Liked 7,166 Times in 2,994 Posts
Default

If by "smut" you mean the residue left on the cases from burning powder,
this is normal. Bullseye smokes up cases a little more than some other
powders. Wiping fired cases with paper towels is just part of handloading
and is no big deal.
Reply With Quote
The Following User Likes This Post:
  #11  
Old 09-01-2018, 08:00 AM
jake1945's Avatar
jake1945 jake1945 is offline
Member
Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question  
Join Date: Dec 2011
Location: S.E. Iowa
Posts: 672
Likes: 286
Liked 726 Times in 304 Posts
Default

My light loads in 45 colt smudge the brass pretty good. So yeah, load is too light.
Reply With Quote
  #12  
Old 09-01-2018, 12:30 PM
H Richard's Avatar
H Richard H Richard is offline
US Veteran
Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question  
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: West Central IL
Posts: 22,758
Likes: 18,437
Liked 22,313 Times in 8,245 Posts
Default

My wimpy 2.7 gr Bullseye or 3.0 231 in a 38 revolver do give a little residue on the case, but the accuracy is worth it, and I clean the gun every time anyway, so what?
__________________
H Richard
SWCA1967 SWHF244
Reply With Quote
The Following 4 Users Like Post:
  #13  
Old 09-01-2018, 01:07 PM
10mm_Shooter's Avatar
10mm_Shooter 10mm_Shooter is offline
Member
Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question  
Join Date: Jun 2009
Posts: 88
Likes: 0
Liked 46 Times in 31 Posts
Default

..as everyone has said, a low pressure load will leave "blow by" smut/carbon pick you term. It simply means the pressure did not expand the brass enough to completely seal the chamber, some blow by escaped rearward and dirtied your brass. I have low pressure loads with Green Dot and Red Dot, that will do that to my .38 brass and my .44 brass. Just yesterday I tried 6.0 grs of Green Dot, chornos at 815 fps, it has blow by, you get back to about 7.0 grs and that's just enough to eliminate the blow by. ….its a non-issue, if it bothers you, adjust your charge or change powders to generate more pressure(with in limits of course).
Reply With Quote
  #14  
Old 09-02-2018, 06:46 AM
ArchAngelCD's Avatar
ArchAngelCD ArchAngelCD is offline
Moderator
SWCA Member
Absent Comrade
Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question  
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: Northeast PA, USA
Posts: 8,877
Likes: 1,029
Liked 5,070 Times in 2,660 Posts
Default

Jimmy, you are almost at the max charge of Bullseye so it's not the powder. Bullseye isn't known for being the cleanest powder but I have a feeling the bullet lube might be causing your soot. Have you tried a coated cast bullet? How about a plated bullet? If you did does the case look the same? If not it's a good indication the lube is the problem. Hey, just tumble them a little longer lol.
__________________
Freedom is never free!!
SWCA #3437
Reply With Quote
  #15  
Old 09-02-2018, 11:54 AM
LoboGunLeather's Avatar
LoboGunLeather LoboGunLeather is offline
US Veteran
Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question  
Join Date: Nov 2008
Location: Colorado
Posts: 7,518
Likes: 19,273
Liked 32,340 Times in 5,474 Posts
Default

I agree that the residue on cartridge case exteriors is most likely caused by pressures insufficient to completely swell the brass against chamber walls.

Only other comment I can offer is about manufacturing tolerances. Every machined part will vary to some degree, primarily due to tool wear during the manufacturing cycle. Manufacturers must allow for a range of tolerances, with chambers cut with a new cutting tool (chambering reamer) being at or near the maximum acceptable dimensions, and those cut with a worn tool becoming somewhat smaller and approaching minimum acceptable dimensions until the tool has worn to a point that it can no longer produce finished parts within the range of tolerances.

It is possible that the OP's revolver has chambers finished closer to the maximum acceptable dimensions which, coupled with relatively low-pressure ammunition, would be more likely to result in powder residue being deposited on case exteriors.

Manufacturing tolerances also appear in ammunition components. Some lots of cartridge cases can be expected to have thicker, thus stronger, case walls and/or brass that may be more or less ductile (subject to expansion under pressure).

None of these conditions (or combinations of tolerance ranges) are proof of any unsafe conditions or other concerns. Just the nature of the business in manufacturing millions of individual parts and pieces, even using the best tooling and machinery.
Reply With Quote
The Following User Likes This Post:
  #16  
Old 09-02-2018, 10:55 PM
Zero Down Zero Down is offline
US Veteran
Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question  
Join Date: Dec 2017
Location: SE Virginia
Posts: 10
Likes: 2
Liked 11 Times in 5 Posts
Default

All my 45 ACP loads do that.
I only need 674 FPS to make power factor for IDPA matches, Steel Challenge and outlaw matches are loaded considerably lower.
Nothing I have ever worried about, my S&W 625 is nicknamed "Old Smokey".
Larry A.
Reply With Quote
  #17  
Old 09-03-2018, 12:11 AM
S&WIowegan S&WIowegan is offline
Member
Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question  
Join Date: May 2004
Location: Iowa
Posts: 4,106
Likes: 14,444
Liked 3,763 Times in 1,784 Posts
Wink

I agree that the light charge causes pressure low enough to not expand the brass enough to seal the gas/smoke blow-by.

It might be of interest to some of you that this can happen with factory fresh ammo. I have an S&W 929 which I use in IPSC and steel shooting. I read reports that this revo seemed to prefer heavier bullets so I bought a case of Federal 147 gr JTC ammo. This ammo doesn't seal the revo chambers and the brass is black with soot.

Pistol Caliber Carbines have recently become popular for action shooting with 9mm being the predominant caliber. Factory Federal 147s come out with black cases. Recently Speer issued a warning to NOT use their 9mm 147 gr ammo in carbines due to potential for bullets to stick in the barrel causing damage to the barrel and danger to the shooter.

I have a friend here who just bought an AR9 style carbine. During his first firing, the first bullet did not exit the barrel and several follow-up shots stuck behind it and destroyed the barrel. The manufacturer allowed my friend to purchase a new barrel. Ammo was handloads.
__________________
Bob.
SWCA 1821
Reply With Quote
  #18  
Old 09-03-2018, 12:31 AM
gboling's Avatar
gboling gboling is offline
Member
Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question  
Join Date: Aug 2008
Location: S/W Texas
Posts: 638
Likes: 261
Liked 232 Times in 132 Posts
Default

I have difficulty accepting the light load theory. My full house 44 magnums loaded with 2400 are the dirtiest cases I ever have. I have never contemplated a cause, I just tumble them and go again.
Reply With Quote
  #19  
Old 09-03-2018, 08:04 AM
Forrest r Forrest r is online now
Member
 
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: Ohio
Posts: 1,455
Likes: 170
Liked 1,636 Times in 681 Posts
Default

Bump the load up to 5.0gr of bullseye and re-test.

FWIW:
That 4.5gr load of bullseye pushing that 200gr lead swc is no where near max anything. It's actually pretty anemic at best. It's so low companies don't even both printing the pressure of that load.

Lyman 49th 452460 200gr lswc
bullseye 4.7gr 775fps -------
reddot 5.2gr 845 -------
ww231 5.5gr 936 14,100cup

The only max load listed in that 49th manual that even bothered to print the pressure of that max load is that ww231 load. Reddot is faster burning than bullseye and lyman has no problem printing use 5.2gr of it.

The 45ar case has more case capacity than the 45acp case.
The 45ar case is just as strong if not stronger than the 45acp case.
Both cartridges are fired in the same firearms.

The 45 auto rim is another 1 of those cartridges that should be updated (along with the 44spl). A company comes out with that cartridge in 1920 and puts a soft lead bullet in it that has a hollow base to be used in the surplus 1917 revolvers that were flooding the market. The cylinders and bbl diameters varied so much on those 1917's they went with a soft bh lead bullet. They didn't want the skirts to blow off those soft lead bullets so they made the 45ar low pressure. It's been that way ever since.

Mold makers have sold hb molds for decades to home casters. A early cramer hb swc mold that casts a .454" bullet for the 45ar or can be sized down to .452" for the 45acp.


That cramer bullet is the 1 on the bottom left. Other hb cast bullets I've cast shot in the 45cal's.


You ought to get some 185gr hornady xtp hp's and push them with 6.2gr of bullseye in those 45ar cases. Those loads are flat shooting, hit hard and there isn't a lot of recoil.
Reply With Quote
  #20  
Old 09-03-2018, 11:31 AM
jwk jwk is offline
Member
Fired Cases Question  
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: San Antonio Texas
Posts: 410
Likes: 109
Liked 321 Times in 151 Posts
Default

Low pressure. Might be minimal safe charge but might be inadequate crimp even with a safe load. Are you roll crimping or taper crimping?
Reply With Quote
  #21  
Old 09-17-2018, 05:23 PM
rsrocket1 rsrocket1 is offline
Member
Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question  
Join Date: Jun 2011
Location: DFW Texas, a free state!
Posts: 755
Likes: 42
Liked 326 Times in 197 Posts
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by gboling View Post
I have difficulty accepting the light load theory. My full house 44 magnums loaded with 2400 are the dirtiest cases I ever have. I have never contemplated a cause, I just tumble them and go again.
2400 is one of the slowest handgun powders around. The case still cannot expand fast enough to seal the gases with such a slow burning powder. Try a powder puff load of 6g Clays or Red Dot and I'll bet your cases will be shiny.

In a revolver, blowby isn't much of a problem. In a semi auto, blowby often results in a blast back into your face and possibly burning powder flying back too.

Some powders have a slow initial rise in pressure. Even at max loads, you might end up with a "scorch mark" that only covers part of the case. For me, Titegroup is notorious for this. In the end, it doesn't matter, the case does seal the gases before blowby and the soot all comes off in the tumbler.
Reply With Quote
  #22  
Old 09-17-2018, 07:47 PM
Moe Mentum Moe Mentum is offline
Member
Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question  
Join Date: Apr 2014
Location: Central Florida
Posts: 798
Likes: 582
Liked 470 Times in 273 Posts
Default

I've seen smutty cases on factory ammo also, Mostly under powered causes this, but it won't hurt anything either.
Reply With Quote
  #23  
Old 09-18-2018, 10:22 AM
Funflyer's Avatar
Funflyer Funflyer is offline
Member
Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question  
Join Date: Sep 2016
Location: Central Arizona
Posts: 1,031
Likes: 1,096
Liked 1,742 Times in 585 Posts
Default

Never really thought about it until reading this thread, but when firing my revolver with 38 special vs 357, the 38 brass gets pretty sooty, where 357 brass still looks shiny new. Makes sense now.

Last edited by Funflyer; 09-18-2018 at 10:40 AM.
Reply With Quote
  #24  
Old 09-18-2018, 11:43 AM
MarkL_01 MarkL_01 is offline
Member
Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question Fired Cases Question  
Join Date: Oct 2011
Posts: 211
Likes: 63
Liked 169 Times in 69 Posts
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Moe Mentum View Post
I've seen smutty cases on factory ammo also, Mostly under powered causes this, but it won't hurt anything either.
I get a lot of this with factory 130gr fmj and wadcutter ammunition in .38 special.
-Mark
Reply With Quote
Reply

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
Forum Jump

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
34-1 fired cases sticking vonfilm S&W Revolvers: 1961 to 1980 25 06-09-2018 09:09 AM
Fired cases getting really stuck!!!!! deerslayerdfr S&W Revolvers: 1980 to the Present 55 01-04-2017 07:42 AM
How do these once fired cases look? dacoontz Reloading 14 08-06-2016 11:19 PM
Factory Fired Cases ginzo The Lounge 14 04-12-2015 12:26 AM
fired shell cases Cpo1944 The Lounge 15 06-02-2014 04:45 PM

Powered by vBadvanced CMPS v3.2.3
smith-wessonforum.com tested by Norton Internet Security smith-wessonforum.com tested by McAfee Internet Security

All times are GMT -4. The time now is 07:16 AM.


Smith-WessonForum.com is not affiliated with Smith & Wesson Holding Corporation (NASDAQ Global Select: SWHC)