Smith & Wesson Forum

Go Back   Smith & Wesson Forum > >

Reloading All Reloading Topics Go Here


Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old 01-10-2020, 11:08 PM
Pantera Mike Pantera Mike is offline
Member
Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P?  
Join Date: Dec 2017
Posts: 125
Likes: 0
Liked 69 Times in 36 Posts
Default Powder recommendation for 38 +P?

I have a Model 686 that is the wife’s home defense gun. She doesn’t want to shoot full 357 Mag so I am trying to brew up a good 38 +P load, using 158gr JHP in 38 special cases.

Load manuals led me to believe that 2400 would be a good choice, but my experience (10.0 grains, with the aforementioned 158gr JHP and magnum primers) is that it’s not burning clean, and leaving lots of unburned powder flakes.

I currently have WW231, 296, Blue Dot and 2400 in the house but I suspect there is another powder that is better suited to 38 Special +P. I have been very rigid about avoiding the latest generation of modern powders, and I think it’s time I broaden my horizons.

Looking forward to words of wisdom and sub-magnum +P load data for 158gr JHP.

EDIT: All other things being equal, a low-flash powder would be preferable.

THANKS!

Last edited by Pantera Mike; 01-10-2020 at 11:23 PM.
Reply With Quote
  #2  
Old 01-11-2020, 12:39 AM
scooter123 scooter123 is offline
Member
 
Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: Metro Detroit, Michigan
Posts: 6,603
Likes: 167
Liked 3,737 Times in 1,877 Posts
Default

Try Accurate #5. There is load data for this powder for 38 special AND 357 Magnum, so you can load from the minimum 38 special all the way to the maximum charge for 357 Magnum. I have what I call my "Magnum Lites" which puts a 158 grain Hornady XTP out of a 4 inch barrel at 900 fps. For me it's just the ticket for when I want to run some "magnums" thru my highly cherished 1972 vintage model 19-3.

BTW, I would suggest using 357 Magnum cases. You'll reduce the pressure a nudge and you wont have to deal with the powder ring left in the cylinder by the shorter 38 special cases.

Last edited by scooter123; 01-11-2020 at 12:40 AM.
Reply With Quote
  #3  
Old 01-11-2020, 01:33 AM
Bosquebass's Avatar
Bosquebass Bosquebass is offline
Member
Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P?  
Join Date: Apr 2015
Location: Ellis County, Texas
Posts: 516
Likes: 2,211
Liked 931 Times in 282 Posts
Default

Look into Unique and I think you may like what you find. It does very well for 38+P but in a 686 7 grains in a 357 magnum case under your 158 jhp may just be what you're looking for. Sort of a "magnum light". Not a lot of blast and flash but it should get around 1200 fps and shoots fairly clean too. I know a lot of folks don't like Unique but it really works well in a lot of different loads and in some calibers it's as good or better than some of the new whiz-bang powders IMHO.
__________________
"I gots to know"

Last edited by Bosquebass; 01-11-2020 at 01:36 AM.
Reply With Quote
The Following 9 Users Like Post:
  #4  
Old 01-11-2020, 10:09 AM
alwslate alwslate is offline
Member
Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P?  
Join Date: Dec 2009
Location: Indiana
Posts: 4,713
Likes: 1,611
Liked 3,860 Times in 1,822 Posts
Default

From published data 6.0 grs of Power Pistol or Hodgdon Longshot will
yield over 1,000 fps out of a 4" barrel with a 158 gr cast SWC. My own
tests do the same with 5.1 grs of 231. These are +P loads and stay
within +P limits. If you choose 158 gr JHPs for +P loads you have to
realize that you are not likely to get much if any expansion at 1,000
fps.
Reply With Quote
The Following 4 Users Like Post:
  #5  
Old 01-11-2020, 10:28 AM
Carrier Carrier is offline
Member
Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P?  
Join Date: Jul 2014
Posts: 365
Likes: 71
Liked 199 Times in 108 Posts
Default

I have found HS-6 to work very well for plus P loads. Need to use a magnum primer with it.
Reply With Quote
The Following 2 Users Like Post:
  #6  
Old 01-11-2020, 12:10 PM
Forrest r Forrest r is offline
Member
 
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: Ohio
Posts: 1,199
Likes: 30
Liked 1,095 Times in 492 Posts
Default

You never said what bbl length your 686 is. Typically, the shorter the bbl, the more attention to detail is required.

Things like cylinder gap come into play taking +/- 10fps per 1/1000" of gap. Same goes for using 38spl cases in a 357, you'll loose +/- 10fps. Doesn't sound like much but if you have a 6/1000th cylinder gap and are using 38spl cases/loads in your 357 expect to loose +/ 70fps from the published data.

Bullet selection is also huge with plated being the slowest, then jacketed and finely cast/coated bullets. There is easily as much as 50fps+ difference in the same loads by something as simple as a bullet choice.

Add to that the difference in bullet designs play a huge roll. A couple years back I did a bunch of testing 38spl p+ loads in a 2" snubnosed revolver. I used these 8 bullets pictured below along with 2 others for a total of 10 different test bullets.


At the end of the day these 4 bullets consistently out performed the other 6 with 5 different powders tested.


What they have in common is (hbwc loaded backwards) that the bullets base/body/bottom drive band is larger then the rest of the bullets and they sealed the cylinders/bbl better letting less pressure go buy to the front drive bands and past the front of the bullet. There was as much as 70+fps difference in those bullets and the worst performing bullet {top picture bottom row far right).

If your shooting 38spl's in a 8 3/8" bbl'd 686 it makes a huge difference compared to a 2 1/2" bbl'd 686. If your thought is to keep recoil down and performance up I'd be looking at a rimrock lead gas check 158gr hp along with 6.3 gr of power pistol or bluedot in 38spl cases.
Reply With Quote
The Following User Likes This Post:
  #7  
Old 01-11-2020, 01:27 PM
cowboy4evr cowboy4evr is online now
Member
Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P?  
Join Date: Jun 2016
Location: for now ,Texas
Posts: 2,108
Likes: 101
Liked 2,366 Times in 1,102 Posts
Default

Unique will get you there , but not current load data . In older manuals 5.4 grs was the +P 38special load using a 158gr bullet . One of my favorites is 7.0grs of HS-6 with a 158gr cast bullet . It needs a magnum primer , CCI 550 etc . I got the HS-6 load from one of the forum members here years ago . I hope this helps , Regards Paul

Last edited by cowboy4evr; 01-11-2020 at 01:30 PM.
Reply With Quote
The Following 3 Users Like Post:
  #8  
Old 01-11-2020, 01:51 PM
LoboGunLeather's Avatar
LoboGunLeather LoboGunLeather is offline
US Veteran
Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P?  
Join Date: Nov 2008
Location: Colorado
Posts: 5,399
Likes: 7,501
Liked 19,520 Times in 3,575 Posts
Default

OP says he has Blue Dot on hand. Excellent powder for high performance in .38 Special (also 9X19, .38 Super, .357 magnum, and several others). In addition to very good velocities Blue Dot provides clean burning and reduced muzzle flash (compared to many others).

Personally, I would prefer a good cast SWC over the jacketed bullet. A quick reference to the Lyman handbooks shows significantly higher muzzle velocities (hence muzzle energy as well), which is understandable because of the greatly reduced friction in the bore between lead and copper jacket materials.

Lyman's data shows a top load of 7.8 grains Blue Dot for 919FPS (4" test barrel) with 158-grain cast, at 16,400 CUP (standard .38 Special pressure, not +P). Compare that to 7.1 grains Blue Dot for 721FPS with 158-grain JHP, at 16,300 CUP (also standard pressure load). That amounts to 198FPS increase (27% greater) comparing cast bullet to jacketed, and that is without even stepping into +P territory.

I used Blue Dot extensively years ago, then it became difficult to find for a number of years. It was my favorite for performance loads in several handgun calibers. Since then I went back to Unique (due to general availability as much as any other factor), and my .38 Spl. +P load has been a 150 LSWC-HP with 5.4 grains Unique. That load shoots very well and is easily controllable in the medium-frame revolvers.

NOTE: Do your own research. Please don't accept my handloading experience as definitive for your uses. I have offered the above only as examples for comparison. Your methods and results may vary.
Reply With Quote
The Following 4 Users Like Post:
  #9  
Old 01-11-2020, 02:06 PM
AManWearingAHat's Avatar
AManWearingAHat AManWearingAHat is offline
Member
Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P?  
Join Date: May 2018
Location: Madison, WI
Posts: 447
Likes: 140
Liked 687 Times in 253 Posts
Default

Power pistol if you have it on hand. I personally stray away from blue dot (blue dirt), it doesn't perform well until you get near max loads and its been very dirty to shoot for me.

I had the misfortune of using it as my first handgun powder and had all sorts of problems with it, I thought I was doing something wrong until I got up near my max loads.
Reply With Quote
The Following 2 Users Like Post:
  #10  
Old 01-11-2020, 03:00 PM
oddshooter oddshooter is offline
Member
Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P?  
Join Date: Aug 2014
Location: the free state of Arizona
Posts: 584
Likes: 1,115
Liked 1,019 Times in 353 Posts
Default

Well, if you are interested in a trying a whiz-bang powder, I recommend Vihtavuori and specifically their N340. It is a versatile powder and can be used in almost all standard calibers. VV shows 5.2 hitting 856fps and max of 5.8 hitting 1017fps for a 158gr HP/XTP.

N340 is Very accurate and clean burning. More expensive powder, but you get what you pay for. The extra cost per round is negligible.


Prescut

Last edited by oddshooter; 01-13-2020 at 02:35 PM.
Reply With Quote
The Following 5 Users Like Post:
  #11  
Old 01-11-2020, 03:33 PM
Abflyboy Abflyboy is offline
Member
 
Join Date: Jan 2009
Posts: 305
Likes: 855
Liked 204 Times in 113 Posts
Default

HS-6 would be my #1 choice for .38 Spl +P, full charge under Hornady XTP. This is actually my absolute favorite load to take out and shoot. Extremely accurate with excellent performance on target, minimal recoil, minimal flash, very good performing but well-mannered load.

VV N340 would be a very close #2 choice but increased cost and lack of availability relegate it to second place.

OP specified JHP, Hornady XTP would be an excellent performer over a full charge of HS-6 as a +P .38 Spl load. I would personally choose 125 gr XTP but the 158 gr XTP will work wonderfully.

2400 is best suited at full charge for medium magnum load
W296/H110 is for HOT magnums and is super temperamental at reduced charge weights
My experience with BD and W231 are limited as I was never able to get good results and stopped using them for anything but fertilizer on the lawn.

Last edited by Abflyboy; 01-11-2020 at 04:07 PM. Reason: Edit to add
Reply With Quote
The Following User Likes This Post:
  #12  
Old 01-11-2020, 03:34 PM
Turn4811 Turn4811 is offline
Member
Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P?  
Join Date: Sep 2019
Location: NE ATL
Posts: 217
Likes: 50
Liked 169 Times in 94 Posts
Default

WW231 - No complaints for a hot 38 load
296 - no experience
Blue Dot - Burns a bit dirty as a +P load but does well in the 357mag range
2400 - probably what I would go with out of this group but lots of flash.

I am using CFEpistol in a low end 357mag load for plinking coated cast 125gr and 158 heavy plated bullets. It burns a bit dirty if I drop the load but I can push it much faster if necessary. My other favorites are Unique (slow 38 all the way to hot mag loads)and Blue Dot (Mag loads).
Reply With Quote
  #13  
Old 01-11-2020, 05:16 PM
geo57 geo57 is offline
Member
 
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: Nebraska
Posts: 52
Likes: 1
Liked 23 Times in 9 Posts
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Bosquebass View Post
Look into Unique and I think you may like what you find. It does very well for 38+P but in a 686 7 grains in a 357 magnum case under your 158 jhp may just be what you're looking for. Sort of a "magnum light". Not a lot of blast and flash but it should get around 1200 fps and shoots fairly clean too. I know a lot of folks don't like Unique but it really works well in a lot of different loads and in some calibers it's as good or better than some of the new whiz-bang powders IMHO.

Respectfully, 7.0 grains of Unique under a 158 gr. JHP in a .357 mag case will not get you close to 1200 FPS. I load that exact combo and get an average of 950 FPS from a 4" BBL. Alliant says 7.7 grs. of Unique with a 158 gr. Speer Gold Dot yields 1040 FPS in a 10 " test BBL. Sierra says 7.7 grs of Unique under their 158 gr. JHC in .357 mag cases results in 1050 FPS from a 6 " BBL and 8.2 grs gets 1100 FPS.

Last edited by geo57; 01-11-2020 at 05:27 PM.
Reply With Quote
The Following 3 Users Like Post:
  #14  
Old 01-11-2020, 05:37 PM
geo57 geo57 is offline
Member
 
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: Nebraska
Posts: 52
Likes: 1
Liked 23 Times in 9 Posts
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Pantera Mike View Post
I have a Model 686 that is the wife’s home defense gun. She doesn’t want to shoot full 357 Mag so I am trying to brew up a good 38 +P load, using 158gr JHP in 38 special cases.

Load manuals led me to believe that 2400 would be a good choice, but my experience (10.0 grains, with the aforementioned 158gr JHP and magnum primers) is that it’s not burning clean, and leaving lots of unburned powder flakes.

I currently have WW231, 296, Blue Dot and 2400 in the house but I suspect there is another powder that is better suited to 38 Special +P. I have been very rigid about avoiding the latest generation of modern powders, and I think it’s time I broaden my horizons.

Looking forward to words of wisdom and sub-magnum +P load data for 158gr JHP.

EDIT: All other things being equal, a low-flash powder would be preferable.

THANKS!

Hi Mike. For my wife's 4" Ruger Security Six I load 7.0 grs. of Unique under a bulk 158 gr. JHP in .357 mag cases. I have a hunch that it may be suitable. It averages 950 FPS and while it's a little stouter than 38 SP +P it is still mild from medium to med. large steel framed revolvers. As someone else mentioned no carbon rings left behind in chambers and less pressure concerns using mag cases vs the shorter .38 cases. Best regards.

Last edited by geo57; 01-11-2020 at 06:00 PM.
Reply With Quote
  #15  
Old 01-11-2020, 05:46 PM
max's Avatar
max max is offline
US Veteran
Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P?  
Join Date: Mar 2001
Location: illinois
Posts: 5,215
Likes: 1,123
Liked 4,218 Times in 1,407 Posts
Default

I suspect 231 will work. You may have to try some different weights to see what you like.
Reply With Quote
  #16  
Old 01-11-2020, 06:00 PM
308 Scout 308 Scout is offline
Member
Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P?  
Join Date: Dec 2016
Location: North Texas
Posts: 109
Likes: 79
Liked 149 Times in 52 Posts
Default

10.0 grs. of 2400 under cast 150 gr. SWCHP's yields 1062 fps out of my 4" Model 10's and wonderful 25 yd. accuracy. Since the load works so well, it never occurred to me to look for unburned powder.

I would suggest a subscription to Load Data | The Best Reloading Manual Online. Therein you'll find reams of .38 Special +P data not only from loading manuals but from the pages of Handloader magazine. Since subscribing a few years ago, I haven't bought a single reloading manual, and I guess I won't ever again.
Reply With Quote
  #17  
Old 01-11-2020, 06:05 PM
308 Scout 308 Scout is offline
Member
Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P?  
Join Date: Dec 2016
Location: North Texas
Posts: 109
Likes: 79
Liked 149 Times in 52 Posts
Default

10.0 grs. of 2400 under cast 150 gr. SWCHP's yields 1062 fps out of my 4" Model 10's and Model 15 and wonderful 25 yd. accuracy. Since the load works so well, it never occurred to me to look for unburned powder.

I would suggest a subscription to Load Data | The Best Reloading Manual Online. Therein you'll find reams of .38 Special +P data not only from loading manuals but from the pages of Handloader magazine. Since subscribing a few years ago, I haven't bought a single reloading manual, and I guess I won't ever again.

Above mentioned load at 25 yds. offhand.


Last edited by 308 Scout; 01-11-2020 at 10:07 PM.
Reply With Quote
The Following 3 Users Like Post:
  #18  
Old 01-11-2020, 09:38 PM
ArchAngelCD ArchAngelCD is offline
Moderator
Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P?  
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: Northeast PA, USA
Posts: 6,147
Likes: 392
Liked 2,531 Times in 1,430 Posts
Default

Most of the medium speed pistol powder will work well.

IMO some are AA#5, HS-6, CFE-Pistol, Unique, Universal, True Blue, LongShot, BE-86, Power Pistol and many others.
__________________
Freedom is never free!!
SWCA #3437
Reply With Quote
The Following User Likes This Post:
  #19  
Old 01-12-2020, 05:41 PM
Pantera Mike Pantera Mike is offline
Member
Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P?  
Join Date: Dec 2017
Posts: 125
Likes: 0
Liked 69 Times in 36 Posts
Default

Thanks all. My 686 has a 4-inch barrel, ideal for a Ďhouse guní IMHO.

I have thousands of 158gr generic JHP bullets on hand that I use for 357/44 B&D and 357 magnum, as well as a bunch of 158gr Hornady JHP I save for use in 357 Auto Mag. And I have thousands of 158gr SWC I use in 357 mag as well. So Iím kind of wedded to that bullet weight, although I suppose I could try lighter weights.

Sounds like AA#5 or HS6 is what I should be trying. I recall reading that AA meters extremely well from a progressive press powder loader (Dillon). Is HS6 similar in that regard? And is one or the other likely to result in less muzzle flash?

Thanks again for the words of wisdom!
Reply With Quote
  #20  
Old 01-12-2020, 06:44 PM
38SPL HV 38SPL HV is offline
Member
Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P?  
Join Date: Apr 2016
Location: Northern Nevada
Posts: 1,002
Likes: 635
Liked 656 Times in 325 Posts
Default

Personally, I like Power Pistol for +P loads using 158 gr lead/cast bullets. However, 158 gr JHP bullets cannot be driven at high enough velocities using published 38 Spl + P data to ensure expansion. I would load the 158 gr JHPs in 357 Mag cases using 357 Magnum mid range power loads (1,000-1,100 FPS). Alliant Powder has some nice 357 Mag mid range loads for the 158 gr JHP using Power Pistol, BE86 and Unique on their website. You could approach 1,000 FPS with these in your 4 inch revolver.
Reply With Quote
The Following User Likes This Post:
  #21  
Old 01-12-2020, 06:55 PM
BC38's Avatar
BC38 BC38 is online now
Member
Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P?  
Join Date: Nov 2013
Location: Spokane, WA
Posts: 9,427
Likes: 571
Liked 12,280 Times in 4,841 Posts
Default

There was a thread with a lot of good data for duplicating the old 158gr "FBI +P Load". IIRC the best results anybody got was with HS-6
__________________
Send lawyers, guns & money...
Reply With Quote
  #22  
Old 01-12-2020, 07:57 PM
bigggbbruce's Avatar
bigggbbruce bigggbbruce is offline
Member
Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P?  
Join Date: Apr 2011
Location: Where this month?
Posts: 3,539
Likes: 261
Liked 4,085 Times in 1,668 Posts
Default

CFE Pistol..
Reply With Quote
  #23  
Old 01-12-2020, 08:01 PM
2ndtimer 2ndtimer is offline
Member
Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P?  
Join Date: Feb 2011
Location: SE Washington State
Posts: 27
Likes: 188
Liked 9 Times in 7 Posts
Default

I agree with those other posters that a 158 gr bullet is probably not optimal for a defense load in a .38 Special or .38 +P. If you are going to shoot 158 gr weight in a .38, you might just as well load a cast SWC, since expansion below 1,000 FPS would be minimal, at best, and the lead bullet might even achieve higher velocity and improved penetration.
As for your powders on hand, I found 2400 and Blue Dot very dirty with lots of unturned powder at less than maximum loads in .357 Magnum. I expect it would be even worse at .38 Spec load levels. Of those you listed, W-231 would be okay. I would go with Power Pistol, for performance, but since you also mention a desire for low flash/muzzle blast, I would consider trying some BE-86, which is supposedly Power Pistol with a flash inhibitor.
Oh,and if it was me, I would also opt for some 125 gr or even 110 gr JHP designed to expand at .38 Special velocities.
Reply With Quote
  #24  
Old 01-12-2020, 08:07 PM
Pantera Mike Pantera Mike is offline
Member
Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P?  
Join Date: Dec 2017
Posts: 125
Likes: 0
Liked 69 Times in 36 Posts
Default

I am being convinced that lighter bullets are the way to go. Probably less recoil too. The list of powders is narrowing too. Thanks again!
Reply With Quote
The Following User Likes This Post:
  #25  
Old 01-13-2020, 01:03 PM
SixGunSancho SixGunSancho is offline
Member
Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P?  
Join Date: Dec 2019
Posts: 139
Likes: 140
Liked 151 Times in 66 Posts
Default

If I were able to start anew, I'd buy only Wihtavuori powder.

I do not load .38 Special +P. Truth be told, I do not like to load much above minimum loads. If I stay at the mimimum end, I can use my powder thrower and not have to sweat standard deviation. A couple tenths over won't matter.

I use +P for self-defense. A box of self-defense loads will last me a lot longer than the rest of my life. It makes far more sense for my needs to buy a box of factory +P. It keeps we away for precise powder measurements that are required for big game hunting ammo.

Now if I were going to load +P, I'd probably use the cleaner burning version of Unique, Longshot, or Power Pistol unless I could get my hands on VV powder. The less + in my P the better.

Also this might help you, once you hit threshold velocity for you application, more velocity might work against you. That's why I don't get nutted up of FPS.

Last edited by SixGunSancho; 01-13-2020 at 02:09 PM.
Reply With Quote
The Following User Likes This Post:
  #26  
Old 01-13-2020, 01:18 PM
Nevada Ed's Avatar
Nevada Ed Nevada Ed is offline
Member
Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P?  
Join Date: Nov 2012
Location: Reno Nv
Posts: 8,931
Likes: 1,057
Liked 6,400 Times in 3,084 Posts
Default

I have a 686 6" that I have loaded 38 special cases in with w231 powder.

Generally, I use the fast powder and lead bullets for light target loads and step up to the medium to med-slow powder for the +p loads but w231 can work.

With a full load of w231 in a 38 case and a 158 lead wc design in my 6" barrel I can reach 950fps.
Blue Dot can reach 1024fps with a full load but this extra recoil is not needed since the lighter load will work for a SD loading.

Lighter bullets have Pro's and Con's that you have to address.
Good luck.
Reply With Quote
The Following User Likes This Post:
  #27  
Old 01-13-2020, 02:46 PM
oddshooter oddshooter is offline
Member
Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P?  
Join Date: Aug 2014
Location: the free state of Arizona
Posts: 584
Likes: 1,115
Liked 1,019 Times in 353 Posts
Default

SixGunSancho wrote:
If I were able to start anew, I'd buy only Vihtavuori powder.

I totally agree with your statement. VV is the best, IMO; but someone already said it; ya can't find it and when ya do, it's expensive.

Still, in a fit of candor, I must say I have over 20 powders currently on the shelf. I love variety and I love to experiment. Trail Boss donuts are just too scrumptious. and what Big Bore guy could live without H110.

But, I will always have VV on the shelf.


Prescut

Last edited by oddshooter; 01-13-2020 at 02:48 PM.
Reply With Quote
The Following User Likes This Post:
  #28  
Old 01-13-2020, 04:42 PM
Carrier Carrier is offline
Member
Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P?  
Join Date: Jul 2014
Posts: 365
Likes: 71
Liked 199 Times in 108 Posts
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Pantera Mike View Post
Thanks all. My 686 has a 4-inch barrel, ideal for a Ďhouse guní IMHO.

I have thousands of 158gr generic JHP bullets on hand that I use for 357/44 B&D and 357 magnum, as well as a bunch of 158gr Hornady JHP I save for use in 357 Auto Mag. And I have thousands of 158gr SWC I use in 357 mag as well. So Iím kind of wedded to that bullet weight, although I suppose I could try lighter weights.

Sounds like AA#5 or HS6 is what I should be trying. I recall reading that AA meters extremely well from a progressive press powder loader (Dillon). Is HS6 similar in that regard? And is one or the other likely to result in less muzzle flash?

Thanks again for the words of wisdom!
HS-6 or AA-5 meters excellent through my LNL powder measure. I havenít had time to work up a good AA-5 load as still recovering from shoulder surgery but HS-6 with XTP 158 grain bullet is the most accurate load Iíve shot in 38 special from my 14-3 with a 8 3/8Ē barrel.
I also have a very accurate load using HS-6 in 357 magnum from my 28 with 6Ē barrel as well.
Others have used lots of other powders and bullets that work for them but HS-6 has worked very well for me.
I also use Speer 158 LSWC bullets with HS-6 that are very close to the XTP for accuracy and do not lead barrel at 38 plus P or mid upper 357 loads.
Reply With Quote
  #29  
Old 01-13-2020, 06:59 PM
max503's Avatar
max503 max503 is offline
Member
Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P?  
Join Date: Jan 2018
Location: Illinois near STL
Posts: 1,189
Likes: 400
Liked 1,492 Times in 629 Posts
Default

To the OP - you are wise to avoid unburned powder flakes. Unburned powder under the extractor can tie up a revolver.

My guns like Unique in heavy loads.

Last edited by max503; 01-13-2020 at 07:04 PM.
Reply With Quote
The Following User Likes This Post:
  #30  
Old 01-13-2020, 07:13 PM
Daniel Howe's Avatar
Daniel Howe Daniel Howe is offline
Member
Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P?  
Join Date: Mar 2019
Location: Marshall, MI
Posts: 512
Likes: 778
Liked 959 Times in 269 Posts
Default

For my fiancee I load 158 grain Hornady XTP with 4.3 grains of Hogdon titegroup. Its a fast burning powder that works good with short barrel revolvers, less muzzle flash.
__________________
Daniel
SWHF 616
Reply With Quote
  #31  
Old 01-13-2020, 09:35 PM
Abflyboy Abflyboy is offline
Member
 
Join Date: Jan 2009
Posts: 305
Likes: 855
Liked 204 Times in 113 Posts
Default

FWIW, HS-6 under a 158 gr XTP is my .357 Magnum plinking load.

HS-6 meters extremely well through my Dillon XL650.
Reply With Quote
  #32  
Old 01-14-2020, 02:32 PM
Nevada Ed's Avatar
Nevada Ed Nevada Ed is offline
Member
Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P?  
Join Date: Nov 2012
Location: Reno Nv
Posts: 8,931
Likes: 1,057
Liked 6,400 Times in 3,084 Posts
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by max503 View Post
To the OP - you are wise to avoid unburned powder flakes. Unburned powder under the extractor can tie up a revolver.

My guns like Unique in heavy loads.
Just for giggles I tried the very SLOW IMR4227 in the 38 special case with a lead 158gr bullet.
Ten grains out of a J frame snub nose gave me 571fps..........
was very dirty and locked up the cylinder, to where I had to take it home to clean it and get the cylinder to open again.

This might be why the Lyman book that I have, only list
Blue Dot as the slowest powder for the 158gr weight lead bullets.
Reply With Quote
  #33  
Old 01-14-2020, 02:37 PM
alwslate alwslate is offline
Member
Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P?  
Join Date: Dec 2009
Location: Indiana
Posts: 4,713
Likes: 1,611
Liked 3,860 Times in 1,822 Posts
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Daniel Howe View Post
For my fiancee I load 158 grain Hornady XTP with 4.3 grains of Hogdon titegroup. Its a fast burning powder that works good with short barrel revolvers, less muzzle flash.
Realize that the velocity of your load is going to be very low out
of a snubby, expansion will be zero and you may be taking a
real chance of sticking a bullet in the bore.
Reply With Quote
  #34  
Old 01-15-2020, 12:43 AM
sniper sniper is offline
Member
Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P?  
Join Date: May 2008
Posts: 170
Likes: 891
Liked 94 Times in 53 Posts
Red face

Quote:
Originally Posted by max503 View Post
To the OP - you are wise to avoid unburned powder flakes. Unburned powder under the extractor can tie up a revolver.
True...don't ask me how I know this!
Reply With Quote
  #35  
Old 01-17-2020, 12:59 PM
Pantera Mike Pantera Mike is offline
Member
Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P?  
Join Date: Dec 2017
Posts: 125
Likes: 0
Liked 69 Times in 36 Posts
Default

A couple of days ago I picked up a pound of AA#5 and a box of Speer 125gr Gold Dot Hollow Points. The Speer reloading manual has a max load of 7.8gr for +P while the older AA data has a MINIMUM of 8.3 with a warning not to reduce any further? The current AA data has a variety of loads for different 125gr bullets with a curious split, as the min and max charges vary quite a bit with different bullets. The two highest show a max of 7.8 which mirrors the Speer data. The minimum 357 magnum loads with this same bullet and powder combination are all substantially higher. So I felt safe starting off with 7.8. I won’t be able to try it until next week but will let you know how it turns out.

I did shoot a hundred rounds of my 2400 load last week, which rendered the gun filthy. It was accurate and recoil was authoritative leading me to believe that whoever was on the other end would definitely rue the day, but the gun and bench were sprinkled with unburned powder flakes. I have 150 more rounds of this stuff to get rid of and will never use that load again.

I actually bought eight pounds of 2400 last year because the reloading manual data indicated it was suitably flexible for downloading 357 and 44 to lower-than-max velocities. I have found that once the charge is reduced it no longer works effectively. I guess I can turn up the steam, but that’s why I have eight pounds of WW296?

First world problems....
Reply With Quote
  #36  
Old 01-17-2020, 01:21 PM
308 Scout 308 Scout is offline
Member
Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P?  
Join Date: Dec 2016
Location: North Texas
Posts: 109
Likes: 79
Liked 149 Times in 52 Posts
Default

2400 is a good powder, but like all other powders with a relatively slow burning rate, you must use them properly.

First, a magnum primer would be preferred for 2400. Second and most important a good, HEAVY roll crimp on the bullet. If you didn't crimp the bullets already I'd suggest you run the remaining round through the seater die crimp the bullets.

As I mentioned above, I loaded 10 gr. of 2400 for my Model 10's and 15 and haven't noticed any unburned power.
Reply With Quote
  #37  
Old 01-17-2020, 02:13 PM
Pantera Mike Pantera Mike is offline
Member
Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P?  
Join Date: Dec 2017
Posts: 125
Likes: 0
Liked 69 Times in 36 Posts
Default

Actually I have been applying a heavy taper crimp. Good enough, or no? I’ve had problems with excessive roll crimp leading to case bulge and difficulty chambering (when deliberately trying to see how far I could go). Taper crimping seems more forgiving. But is a good taper crimp as effective as a good (not excessive) roll crimp?
Reply With Quote
  #38  
Old 01-17-2020, 02:39 PM
308 Scout 308 Scout is offline
Member
Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P?  
Join Date: Dec 2016
Location: North Texas
Posts: 109
Likes: 79
Liked 149 Times in 52 Posts
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Pantera Mike View Post
Actually I have been applying a heavy taper crimp. Good enough, or no? Iíve had problems with excessive roll crimp leading to case bulge and difficulty chambering (when deliberately trying to see how far I could go). Taper crimping seems more forgiving. But is a good taper crimp as effective as a good (not excessive) roll crimp?
I don't think a taper crimp holds the bullet as well as a roll crimp. Like I said, I'm using 2400 in my .38's with zero problems, BUT I'm loading cast bullets that have a deep crimp groove. Are these jacketed bullets?
Reply With Quote
  #39  
Old 01-17-2020, 02:54 PM
Pantera Mike Pantera Mike is offline
Member
Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P?  
Join Date: Dec 2017
Posts: 125
Likes: 0
Liked 69 Times in 36 Posts
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by 308 Scout View Post
I don't think a taper crimp holds the bullet as well as a roll crimp. Like I said, I'm using 2400 in my .38's with zero problems, BUT I'm loading cast bullets that have a deep crimp groove. Are these jacketed bullets?
Perhaps youíre right? But the taper crimp is fairly aggressive.

158gr JHP on the left, Speer 125gr GDHP on the right.
Attached Thumbnails
Powder recommendation for 38 +P?-4e91e1e9-8f7a-42a2-b8fc-77d0d728fcd8-jpg  
Reply With Quote
  #40  
Old 01-17-2020, 03:49 PM
308 Scout 308 Scout is offline
Member
Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P?  
Join Date: Dec 2016
Location: North Texas
Posts: 109
Likes: 79
Liked 149 Times in 52 Posts
Default

If it were me I'd seat those bullets to the very front of the cannelure and apply a good roll crimp. Nothing to lose by trying.
Reply With Quote
  #41  
Old 01-17-2020, 04:37 PM
Pantera Mike Pantera Mike is offline
Member
Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P?  
Join Date: Dec 2017
Posts: 125
Likes: 0
Liked 69 Times in 36 Posts
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by 308 Scout View Post
If it were me I'd seat those bullets to the very front of the cannelure and apply a good roll crimp. Nothing to lose by trying.
Well, almost.

When trying to both seat the bullets further and apply a roll crimp to already-taper-crimped rounds, within the first ten rounds I had two episodes of cases collapsing. Neck tension was strong enough that when the seater plug tried to press the bullet further into the case, the case body collapsed.

So I raised the seating stem so that it no longer touched the bullet, accepting their current position in the case, and just applied a roll crimp which seemed to work okay. Itís still not a perfect-looking roll crimp, but I guess itís better? As these are basically throwaway rounds anyway Iím not overly concerned.

For my next batch though, I will forgo taper crimping and attempt a conventional roll crimp. I prefer to fully seat the bullet and then crimp separately which hopefully leads to better results.
Attached Thumbnails
Powder recommendation for 38 +P?-31bf6161-a9ba-48ff-bbc5-62d05e7f1790-jpg   Powder recommendation for 38 +P?-3fcae48a-d026-425d-96ac-9d6d7216bb3a-jpg  
Reply With Quote
  #42  
Old 01-17-2020, 10:33 PM
Pantera Mike Pantera Mike is offline
Member
Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P?  
Join Date: Dec 2017
Posts: 125
Likes: 0
Liked 69 Times in 36 Posts
Default

BTW itís difficult to convey how filthy this thing is running with 2400. The photo below show unburned powder on the frame (also all over then rug below, but difficult to see), and soot all over the crane and cylinder. The back of the cylinder is shiny only because of my fingers wiping it off while opening and closing.

This is after 100 rounds.....
Attached Thumbnails
Powder recommendation for 38 +P?-a58ba809-f786-431f-829b-2d23a08a6ebe-jpg  
Reply With Quote
  #43  
Old 01-17-2020, 11:00 PM
Grayfox's Avatar
Grayfox Grayfox is offline
US Veteran
Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P?  
Join Date: Apr 2001
Location: Bartlett, Tennessee
Posts: 5,473
Likes: 1,427
Liked 10,981 Times in 3,116 Posts
Default

I find that W231 works very well in just about any non-magnum revolver cartridge and burns very clean. Its my "go to" powder.
Reply With Quote
  #44  
Old 01-17-2020, 11:50 PM
308 Scout 308 Scout is offline
Member
Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P?  
Join Date: Dec 2016
Location: North Texas
Posts: 109
Likes: 79
Liked 149 Times in 52 Posts
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Pantera Mike View Post
BTW itís difficult to convey how filthy this thing is running with 2400. The photo below show unburned powder on the frame (also all over then rug below, but difficult to see), and soot all over the crane and cylinder. The back of the cylinder is shiny only because of my fingers wiping it off while opening and closing.

This is after 100 rounds.....
That's strange. I've been loading it in the .357 for about 35 years, then in the .38 Special for 4 or 5 years, as well as the .44 Special and 45 Colt Only the .357 loads have been really high pressure loads. Never had any issues with this powder.
Reply With Quote
  #45  
Old 01-18-2020, 12:05 AM
Pantera Mike Pantera Mike is offline
Member
Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P?  
Join Date: Dec 2017
Posts: 125
Likes: 0
Liked 69 Times in 36 Posts
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Grayfox View Post
I find that W231 works very well in just about any non-magnum revolver cartridge and burns very clean. Its my "go to" powder.
Yeah, me too. I use it for powder puff 38 HBWC target loads, as well as 45 ACP, 380 and (soon) 9mm. Itís fantastic.

But I always thought it would be too fast to be optimal for a magnum or magnum-ish revolver cartridge. I suspect AA#5 will be better suited to this task, especially in light of all the testimony above. Time will tell.

And I also have 8 pounds of 231 in the powder cabinet so Iím not ruling anything out...
Reply With Quote
  #46  
Old 01-18-2020, 07:38 PM
ArchAngelCD ArchAngelCD is offline
Moderator
Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P?  
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: Northeast PA, USA
Posts: 6,147
Likes: 392
Liked 2,531 Times in 1,430 Posts
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by BC38 View Post
There was a thread with a lot of good dat a for duplicating the old 158gr "FBI +P Load". IIRC the best results anybody got was with HS-6
There was a good thread discussing duplicates for the FBI Load. I was 1 of the group of handloaders who worked on the project.

There were several powders that "worked" but IMO HS-6 was best at the time. There are several new powders available since then which I have not tried.
__________________
Freedom is never free!!
SWCA #3437
Reply With Quote
  #47  
Old 01-19-2020, 01:01 PM
Groo01's Avatar
Groo01 Groo01 is offline
Member
Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P?  
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: ohio
Posts: 1,275
Likes: 808
Liked 707 Times in 426 Posts
Default

Groo here
As you stated a HP bullet, you should try fore an impact speed of 1000 fps.
I would NOT use a jacket bullet at such a low speed unless it is a SJHP
with A LOT of lead exposed.
GT bullets has cast lead HP bullets.
I would get a selection and try them...
Reply With Quote
The Following User Likes This Post:
  #48  
Old 01-19-2020, 02:00 PM
geo57 geo57 is offline
Member
 
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: Nebraska
Posts: 52
Likes: 1
Liked 23 Times in 9 Posts
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Pantera Mike View Post
A couple of days ago I picked up a pound of AA#5 and a box of Speer 125gr Gold Dot Hollow Points. The Speer reloading manual has a max load of 7.8gr for +P while the older AA data has a MINIMUM of 8.3 with a warning not to reduce any further? The current AA data has a variety of loads for different 125gr bullets with a curious split, as the min and max charges vary quite a bit with different bullets. The two highest show a max of 7.8 which mirrors the Speer data. The minimum 357 magnum loads with this same bullet and powder combination are all substantially higher. So I felt safe starting off with 7.8. I wonít be able to try it until next week but will let you know how it turns out.

I did shoot a hundred rounds of my 2400 load last week, which rendered the gun filthy. It was accurate and recoil was authoritative leading me to believe that whoever was on the other end would definitely rue the day, but the gun and bench were sprinkled with unburned powder flakes. I have 150 more rounds of this stuff to get rid of and will never use that load again.

I actually bought eight pounds of 2400 last year because the reloading manual data indicated it was suitably flexible for downloading 357 and 44 to lower-than-max velocities. I have found that once the charge is reduced it no longer works effectively. I guess I can turn up the steam, but thatís why I have eight pounds of WW296?

First world problems....
Mike, FWIW 2400 can be reduced somewhat and still burn at nearly 100 % efficiency. In .357 mag cases I load a bulk 158 gr. JHP on top of 13.5 grs. of 2400, employ a firm roll crimp and use standard primers. It is a 90% full power load and burns clean. If I reduce the powder charge to 12.8 grains I get a modest amount of powder granules in varying stages of burn.
Reply With Quote
  #49  
Old 01-22-2020, 05:31 PM
jtcarm's Avatar
jtcarm jtcarm is offline
Member
Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P?  
Join Date: Apr 2011
Posts: 4,039
Likes: 1,406
Liked 3,838 Times in 1,633 Posts
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by AManWearingAHat View Post
Power pistol if you have it on hand. I personally stray away from blue dot (blue dirt), it doesn't perform well until you get near max loads and its been very dirty to shoot for me.

I had the misfortune of using it as my first handgun powder and had all sorts of problems with it, I thought I was doing something wrong until I got up near my max loads.


+1 on Power Pistol. 6 grains will get you there with a 158 lead bullet.

As always, work up to it.
Reply With Quote
The Following User Likes This Post:
  #50  
Old 01-22-2020, 06:05 PM
Bronco89 Bronco89 is offline
Member
Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P? Powder recommendation for 38 +P?  
Join Date: Jan 2018
Location: TN Hills
Posts: 288
Likes: 435
Liked 601 Times in 155 Posts
Default

I've been using CFE-Pistol as of late, and getting some impressive velocities even without getting into +P. Honestly, for what I am doing, a little too much velocity. But it would make a great defensive load, and burns clean to boot. I wouldn't sweet shooting lead 38's in a 357. I've been doing it since 1988 and haven't had a problem yet.

The latest Speer book as some good lead 158gr +P loads. They list HS6 as a good performer.
__________________
Hillbilly

Last edited by Bronco89; 01-22-2020 at 06:07 PM.
Reply With Quote
Reply

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
Forum Jump

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Powder recommendation? lrrifleman Reloading 33 09-26-2016 11:30 AM
Does This Gun Use Black Powder Or Smokeless Powder? Dating H&R .32 Cal. Vest Pocket MackHR Firearms & Knives - Other Brands 2 07-08-2016 11:15 AM
What powder recommendation Clovishound Reloading 32 05-01-2016 06:41 AM
2nd pistol powder recommendation Bugkiller99 Reloading 41 07-17-2013 09:19 PM
Powder Recommendation for 38CAL 158GR SWC salemsm Reloading 29 04-19-2013 06:14 PM

Powered by vBadvanced CMPS v3.2.3
smith-wessonforum.com tested by Norton Internet Security smith-wessonforum.com tested by McAfee Internet Security

All times are GMT -4. The time now is 12:52 AM.


Search Engine Optimisation provided by DragonByte SEO v2.0.42 (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2020 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.
Smith-WessonForum.com is not affiliated with Smith & Wesson Holding Corporation (NASDAQ Global Select: SWHC)