Been watching this forum for quite some time and finally decided to take part with a question. Has anybody fired this gun? I'm concerned with the recoil. Not looking for any miracles, just manageable. I'm sure you guys know this, It's 44 Magnum, 3" compensated barrel, stainless steel. Ported by the performance center at S&W.

Been watching this forum for quite some time and finally decided to take part with a question. Has anybody fired this gun? I'm concerned with the recoil. Not looking for any miracles, just manageable. I'm sure you guys know this, It's 44 Magnum, 3" compensated barrel, stainless steel. Ported by the performance center at S&W.

I can not tell much difference with my 586 power ported gun in 357 Mag.as compared to un ported 3" 357's. I can tell a deference with Mag Na Porting so I would surmise that there my be some difference but not much. With magnums it going to kick no matter what, but there may be a little less flip. They are a good looking gun and you will probably shoot more 44 Spl anyways.

I say go for it and welcome to this forum. There will others along shortly with more knowledge than I.

REcoil isn't as bad as one would expect, the grips will impact the felt recoil as much as the gun's shape/weight. I've shot mine with 300 grain factory loads with no issues, but using the Spegel Boot Grips do make it a somewhat brisk experience.
The porting does help, though.



Please note, if you use a glove, or - alternately - slam your shooting hand in your truck door just prior to pulling the trigger, the sensation of recoil is somewhat lessened....

__________________
.............SmithNut

Can you recommend a holster for the 629 Carry Comp?

I have used a Kramer horsehide IWB for my N frames (I've used a 4" holster for the 3" guns, it provides additional length so there is no skin "pinching" on my upper thigh when seated). In the past few years, I've converted to Bladetech holsters almost universally, polymer is thinner and allows me to "cheat" a frame size pretty much universally. In other words, compared to a leather/horsehide holster, the overall thickness (thinness) allows me to carry an N frame gun with the same comfort as an L frame gun in a leather holster. I like the Bladetech IWB line, great holsters and equally great company to deal with.

__________________
.............SmithNut

Man your killin me,Ive been looking for a carry comp .44. I'd love to find a no lock model. Very nice.

Thanks for all your help, one last question.
I cant get this 629 carry comp with 3 sets of grips, factory alum case, and a Krammer paddle cowhide holster, LNIB, for $975.00, and maybe even a little less,(900.00) sound like a fair price? thanks agian, this gun is really new to me but I love it and it really helps to have someone experienced to hold my hand if you will.

DaveZ,
Value is going to depend on a lot of things, where you are, the guns condition and configuration (no lock = premium, hammer where it's supposed to be), and of course - how much you want it
I'd say that for a gun from either the first or second production runs (2000 & 2005) in ANIB condition with the goodies, that $900 would be a fair price. Most of the original PC guns listed for $1000 and up, so given that the gun you are looking at has all the desireable features the price isn't out of line.
Just my opinion.

__________________
.............SmithNut

Just to temp you a bit more... Here's the original ad/flyer from Lew Horton:

__________________
.............SmithNut

Responding to your question about how much recoil... If you're new to the larger bore handguns, start with a smaller caliber and work your way up to the larger. Maybe start with a 38 special if you've got one. Or borrow one from a friend (let him know first--some guys get testy otherwise). Then perhaps a 357 mag. Same thing. Then 44 spl in your carry comp. Once you're ok with those try the 44 mags.

And most important. WEAR HEARING PROTECTION! I wear both earplugs and over the ear protectors when I shoot my 44 mag.

Or you can just get a box of the hottest 44 mag ammo you can find and shoot away. If you do it the second way, I'd like first chance at the Carry Comp and the remaining 48 rounds...

__________________
HIKayaker

None of the pictures in posts are the same as that shown in the S&W catalog. I think the catalogued gun is very handsome. It has tempted me to buy one but I haven't caved yet.

If you like it and have any experience with guns of any recoil, get it. Reload for it or you can work up to heavier loads starting with a .44 Special and then go on to moderate factory loads or higher as your tolerance or desires indicate.

You don't have to go full house to still have a very formidable defensive gun. If you aren't using if for defensive purposes, it will still do most anything you want other than bullseye work for which it has too short a sight radius. Don

Im holding off buying a new one in hopes of finding a pre lock model. (hint hint )