Safariland COMP-2 Speed loader

vytoland · Dec 16, 2008

I have a S&W 686-4pp, .357 magnum with Hogue Grips. I was thinking about geting a Safariland II speed loader

I would like to hear from anyone who has used these............

how well do they work
do the Hogue Grips interfere with the speed loader??

vytoland · Dec 16, 2008

I have a S&W 686-4pp, .357 magnum with Hogue Grips. I was thinking about geting a Safariland II speed loader

I would like to hear from anyone who has used these............

how well do they work
do the Hogue Grips interfere with the speed loader??

Revolver King · Dec 17, 2008

It depends on what you are going to use them for, competition or carry. they are a good speed loader for carry but for comp. go with the Comp 3

Angel Eyes · Dec 17, 2008

If they make a Comp I for that model get it for carry. The comp III is the only way to go for competition.

Jellybean · Dec 17, 2008

I've used comp 2s with a 686 for duty carry and they worked fine, I prefer the 2 to the 1 myself.

I don't care for Hogue grips so can't help you there.

Your links failed when I tried to open them.

Poohgyrr · Dec 17, 2008

I haven't used the Comp 3's, but with practice the Comp 2's are absolutely smooth and without bobble in my old 4" 686 six shooter wearing Hogue Pau Ferros.

The built in grooves in the Comp 2 lined my fingers up with the cylinder flutes, which helped me with the smoothness and speed. I seriously prefer these to the Comp 1's or HKS's for carry.

Nightowl · Dec 17, 2008

I greatly prefer the Comp ll over the comp 1. Too bad they never made the Comp 11 for the N frame. Never used the Comp 111 so cannot relate for competition. They are too big to carry for duty use. I have some comp 1's that I have been using for over 20 years, so they are a good value.

Safariland COMP-2 Speed loader

vytoland

US Veteran

vytoland

US Veteran

Revolver King

Member

Angel Eyes

Member

Jellybean

Member

Poohgyrr

Nightowl

Similar threads

Latest posts