These holsters are top notch in my opinion and sell for around 70 USD. Send in an order for what you have and a few weeks later a package comes with your rig.
I'am looking for a holster for a 32 caliber S&W long revolver. A vintage S&W holster would be nice but new right handed holster I would also look at. It has a 4 1/2" barrel and the revolver was manufactured in 1903.
This place can make you a leather holster in 4 to 6 weeks designed for the S&W 986 with 5" barrel: Comfortable Leather Belt Holster | Craft Holsters(R)
I'm guessing it would fit a 586 or 686 with a 5" barrel, too.
Price is shown as $62.95 as of 9-29-17
Last edited by frog4aday; 09-29-2017 at 06:25 PM.
Reason: Clarifying that I know post was about a 686 gun but that the 986 holster should work
If function is more important than form, Blade Tech makes their Classic OWB holster for the 5" 686+. The Simply Rugged is nice but they are not tightly boned, more like a leather envelope or sandwich.