So I am a big fan of the Bodyguards; I had purchased a pair of vintage smooth J-frame "banana" grips to use with a modern J-frame magnum Model 60. Today I swapped grips between the two, and I kinda like the results - on both guns!
I also bought a pair of checkered bananas to use on my Model 60 3" -- they are very utilitarian -- gives you an almost Bisley-like grip.