|
|
11-26-2011, 03:00 AM
|
|
Member
|
|
|
Join Date: Nov 2011
Location: Pac NW
Posts: 401
Likes: 25
Liked 201 Times in 53 Posts
|
|
Brand New 629...90 Rounds Results in cylinder damage/galling.
This report comes as a mixed bag with both the positive and the negative. So lets start with the positive.
My new 629 3'' shoots better than I would have ever bet on, guessed or imagined it would. I shot a total of 90 rounds this past Tuesday, the first 25 or so fired from a bench rest while I adjusted the sights for windage. Once it was sighted in I went to work seeing just how well I could shoot this flame throwing beast. One of my targets is pictured below.
On the negative side of the equation is the damage to the cylinder I noticed once I was home and was getting ready to clean it.
I fired a total of 50 rounds of Magnum ammo and 40 rounds of special. All ammo was factory.
Does anyone else have this type of galling on the cylinder of their .44 mags?
Do I just keep shooting it, send it back to S&W or...?
I have a Model 29-2 that shows no sign of this at all.
Thanks for any and all input.
All six showed galling, this one was the worst.
Not to leave on a negative note I saved the positive for the last.
Last edited by peppercorn; 11-26-2011 at 01:12 PM.
Reason: Added photo
|
11-26-2011, 03:28 AM
|
SWCA Member
|
|
|
Join Date: Oct 2007
Location: California
Posts: 19,208
Likes: 11,815
Liked 20,511 Times in 8,548 Posts
|
|
Explanation:
That's called peening and is more prevalent on SS guns because S&W's stainless is a fairly soft alloy. But it also happens to carbon steel guns and is not abnormal in minor amounts.
Diagnosis:
Yours seems to be slightly excessive on the one notch. I think your cylinder hand is slightly to long causing it to advance the cylinder too soon before the stop clears the notch. Can you feel a little hitch when you fire it double action?
Solution:
Check for a super sharp edge or burr on the stop that aligns with the peening marks. Have the timing checked.
__________________
Jim
S&WCA #819
Last edited by Hondo44; 11-26-2011 at 03:33 AM.
|
11-26-2011, 09:50 AM
|
|
Member
|
|
|
Join Date: Nov 2010
Location: Blossvale NY
Posts: 1,295
Likes: 3,964
Liked 950 Times in 427 Posts
|
|
I have put about 150 rds through my new 629-6 Classic. So far I have discovered none of what you are experiencing....FWIW
|
The Following User Likes This Post:
|
|
11-26-2011, 10:42 AM
|
Member
|
|
|
Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: Metro Detroit, Michigan
Posts: 6,919
Likes: 179
Liked 4,294 Times in 2,106 Posts
|
|
I see only one image that is at all concerning, that is the top image. It appears that particular stop notch is peened slightly on the face opposite the lead in.
There are 2 possible causes for peening this face of the stop notch. One is a lot of rapid fire shooting typical to what is seen it some types of competitive shooting and it takes a lot of rounds downrange for this to become noticeable.
The other is when the gun fires with the cylinder just shy of the stop dropping into the notch. What happens in this case is that when the fired bullet hits the forcing cone it will cause the cylinder to rotate violently due to the "centering" action of the bullet hitting the forcing cone. The major cause of this is a timing fault called "failure to carry up". The minor cause is staging the trigger in double action, a practice that S&W discourages in the owners manual. If you pull the trigger in one complete motion when shooting in double action the inertia of the rotating cylinder will carry it into full lock even if it does fail to carry up properly in a carry up test.
At this point your damage is so minor that I don't see any need to have the cylinder replaced. However, I believe that you should test for carry up and send your 629 into S&W if you find you have a failure to carry up. I will also discourage you from staging the trigger in double action because in time simple wear will cause carry up issues to reappear. In addition, in real Combat it's not how you would use a double action trigger and I'm a believer in training how you might have to shoot if the need to defend yourself should occur.
Testing for carry up is rather simple. Put some snap caps that measure at the same diameter as a properly size round or sized empty casings in the cyliner. Then pull the trigger in double action using a super slow motion trigger pull. Listen for the cylinder stop to drop before the hammer falls. BTW, you may need to use two fingers on the trigger to pull it slowly enough. If you find a cchamber or two where the stop doesn't drop in before hammer fall, mark them with a sharpie marker or the like. In this case peening the ratchet pall for the offending cylinder position(s) is the solution. If you find carryup problems on every chamber position, a thicker hand is the fix. Since these require "touch" and some fitting, it's not a kitchen table fix so let the warranty center do the work.
I'll also note that failures to carry up with a left handed trigger pull is typical to the S&W lockwork, so typical that it's uncommon to NOT find carry up issues with the left hand. In addition, trying to achieve perfect carry up for left handed shooters usually results in a slight Hand/Cylinder bind on those guns when used right handed. Rumor has it that the Floating Hand was an attempt to correct the left hand carry up issues that didn't succeed. The simple fact is the lockwork in a S&W is right handed to a slight extent and lefties should make it a habit to NEVER stage their trigger.
|
The Following User Likes This Post:
|
|
11-26-2011, 10:45 AM
|
Member
|
|
|
Join Date: Oct 2009
Posts: 111
Likes: 7
Liked 16 Times in 8 Posts
|
|
My new 4" 629-6 is doing the same thing, plus it hangs up on two cylinders when unlocking the cylinder.
The first 200 rounds through the gun were very, very mild 240 grain LSWC doing about 850 fps. I fired them double action.
I had two local gunsmiths take a look at it and the first thing one of them said are you firing SA or DA, when I said DA, he just nodded and indicated it was more or less normal.
I'm going to be sending the gun back to S&W soon to have them repair the cylinder catch issue as well as take a look at the peening.
One smith said the cylinder "catching" was due to an out of round hole at the end of the ejector rod. The other said it was due to rough ratchets.
Right handed by the way and I was "staging" the trigger.
Last edited by Jitterbug; 11-26-2011 at 10:48 AM.
|
11-26-2011, 11:52 AM
|
|
Member
|
|
|
Join Date: May 2011
Location: Montana
Posts: 576
Likes: 392
Liked 109 Times in 79 Posts
|
|
My new 629-6 does the same thing and thought at first maybe it was that way when I got it but just hadn't noticed it. Glad you asked the question. Let us know if you do send it back and what S&W does about it. I only have 20 - 30 rounds through mine so far. I really like this gun and hope it doesn't get to the point where I have to send it back just when I need to be carring it during shed antler hunting in the spring. Is my only S&W pistol a piece of ____ ? Hope not as I really defended the S&W to a friend who tried to steer me onto a Ruger. If they are all this way isn't going to make me feel any better about this condition either.
__________________
44 Garrett Defender Ammo 4 me.
Last edited by team sidewinder; 11-26-2011 at 12:10 PM.
|
11-26-2011, 12:02 PM
|
Member
|
|
|
Join Date: Sep 2006
Posts: 39
Likes: 1
Liked 6 Times in 5 Posts
|
|
That's a sexy beast pepper, how ya been?
Sorry, have nothing to add to this. I have two 629-4's, they are doing this a little. Not as bad as yours though, good luck with it mang.
ETA: great pics as per usual,,,
Last edited by trukreltrog; 11-26-2011 at 12:04 PM.
Reason: Pics
|
11-26-2011, 12:31 PM
|
Member
|
|
|
Join Date: Mar 2010
Location: dubuque ,iowa
Posts: 678
Likes: 18,145
Liked 568 Times in 235 Posts
|
|
Wow ! Nice gun, good group . My 629-4 w/ 8 3/8 " barrel is doing the same and I only see it on the stainless guns but I would'nt worry about it.
|
11-26-2011, 01:57 PM
|
|
Member
|
|
|
Join Date: Nov 2011
Location: Pac NW
Posts: 401
Likes: 25
Liked 201 Times in 53 Posts
|
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by Hondo44
Explanation:
That's called peening and is more prevalent on SS guns because S&W's stainless is a fairly soft alloy. But it also happens to carbon steel guns and is not abnormal in minor amounts.
Diagnosis:
Yours seems to be slightly excessive on the one notch. I think your cylinder hand is slightly to long causing it to advance the cylinder too soon before the stop clears the notch. Can you feel a little hitch when you fire it double action?
Solution:
Check for a super sharp edge or burr on the stop that aligns with the peening marks. Have the timing checked.
|
I am not feeling any 'hitch' in DA 'dry' firing(with snap caps).
Quote:
Originally Posted by scooter123
I see only one image that is at all concerning, that is the top image. It appears that particular stop notch is peened slightly on the face opposite the lead in.
There are 2 possible causes for peening this face of the stop notch. One is a lot of rapid fire shooting typical to what is seen it some types of competitive shooting and it takes a lot of rounds downrange for this to become noticeable.
The other is when the gun fires with the cylinder just shy of the stop dropping into the notch. What happens in this case is that when the fired bullet hits the forcing cone it will cause the cylinder to rotate violently due to the "centering" action of the bullet hitting the forcing cone. The major cause of this is a timing fault called "failure to carry up". The minor cause is staging the trigger in double action, a practice that S&W discourages in the owners manual. If you pull the trigger in one complete motion when shooting in double action the inertia of the rotating cylinder will carry it into full lock even if it does fail to carry up properly in a carry up test.
At this point your damage is so minor that I don't see any need to have the cylinder replaced. However, I believe that you should test for carry up and send your 629 into S&W if you find you have a failure to carry up. I will also discourage you from staging the trigger in double action because in time simple wear will cause carry up issues to reappear. In addition, in real Combat it's not how you would use a double action trigger and I'm a believer in training how you might have to shoot if the need to defend yourself should occur.
Testing for carry up is rather simple. Put some snap caps that measure at the same diameter as a properly size round or sized empty casings in the cyliner. Then pull the trigger in double action using a super slow motion trigger pull. Listen for the cylinder stop to drop before the hammer falls. BTW, you may need to use two fingers on the trigger to pull it slowly enough. If you find a cchamber or two where the stop doesn't drop in before hammer fall, mark them with a sharpie marker or the like. In this case peening the ratchet pall for the offending cylinder position(s) is the solution. If you find carryup problems on every chamber position, a thicker hand is the fix. Since these require "touch" and some fitting, it's not a kitchen table fix so let the warranty center do the work.
I'll also note that failures to carry up with a left handed trigger pull is typical to the S&W lockwork, so typical that it's uncommon to NOT find carry up issues with the left hand. In addition, trying to achieve perfect carry up for left handed shooters usually results in a slight Hand/Cylinder bind on those guns when used right handed. Rumor has it that the Floating Hand was an attempt to correct the left hand carry up issues that didn't succeed. The simple fact is the lockwork in a S&W is right handed to a slight extent and lefties should make it a habit to NEVER stage their trigger.
|
I only fired the 629 SA.
I had been practicing rapid doubles in DA, no staging, with my model 19 prior to firing the 629 and found the difference in trigger pull dramatic enough to just stick with SA for the first outing with the .44.
Also, I added a photo above to show the stop.
I will try the carry up test above following the description and using snap caps as you suggest.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jitterbug
My new 4" 629-6 is doing the same thing, plus it hangs up on two cylinders when unlocking the cylinder.
The first 200 rounds through the gun were very, very mild 240 grain LSWC doing about 850 fps. I fired them double action.
I had two local gunsmiths take a look at it and the first thing one of them said are you firing SA or DA, when I said DA, he just nodded and indicated it was more or less normal.
I'm going to be sending the gun back to S&W soon to have them repair the cylinder catch issue as well as take a look at the peening.
One smith said the cylinder "catching" was due to an out of round hole at the end of the ejector rod. The other said it was due to rough ratchets.
Right handed by the way and I was "staging" the trigger.
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by team sidewinder
My new 629-6 does the same thing and thought at first maybe it was that way when I got it but just hadn't noticed it. Glad you asked the question. Let us know if you do send it back and what S&W does about it. I only have 20 - 30 rounds through mine so far. I really like this gun and hope it doesn't get to the point where I have to send it back just when I need to be carring it during shed antler hunting in the spring. Is my only S&W pistol a piece of ____ ? Hope not as I really defended the S&W to a friend who tried to steer me onto a Ruger. If they are all this way isn't going to make me feel any better about this condition either.
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by trukreltrog
That's a sexy beast pepper, how ya been?
Sorry, have nothing to add to this. I have two 629-4's, they are doing this a little. Not as bad as yours though, good luck with it mang.
ETA: great pics as per usual,,,
|
Good to see you 'trog, it's been a long while.
Quote:
Originally Posted by lscocoa
Wow ! Nice gun, good group . My 629-4 w/ 8 3/8 " barrel is doing the same and I only see it on the stainless guns but I would'nt worry about it.
|
Thanks for the input everyone.
I added a photo of the stop if that helps at all.
Last edited by peppercorn; 11-26-2011 at 01:59 PM.
|
11-26-2011, 02:09 PM
|
|
Member
|
|
|
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: Pennsylvania
Posts: 341
Likes: 1
Liked 16 Times in 7 Posts
|
|
I have never experienced damage like that on a S&W.
I own 10 pre-lock S&Ws ( all bought used ) and none show any "peening".
Firing 90 rounds of factory ammo should not cause that.
My thought is that your 629 is slightly out of time AND the locking bolt is dragging.
I would send it back and demand a new cylinder.
.
|
11-26-2011, 02:57 PM
|
Member
|
|
|
Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: Metro Detroit, Michigan
Posts: 6,919
Likes: 179
Liked 4,294 Times in 2,106 Posts
|
|
One other thought occured to me concerning carry up. That is that a very tight Barrel/Cylinder gap could create enough drag to cause carry up issues due to fouling on the face of the cylinder. I would suggest that you check your B/C gap to see if yours is a bit too tight. Personally, I consider 0.005 to 0.006 inch to be ideal and 0.004 to be the margin for correction. While that is admittedly a bit conservative I prefer a bit more gas loss in the B/C gap over optimized potential accuracy with a tighter gap. While a tight B/C gap can improve accuracy I just don't think a minor increase in accuracy potential is worth the cost of possible timing issues that a dragging cylinder can cause.
Since you were shooting in single action, checking for a tight B/C gap is one thing you'll want to check before sending it in so that issue can be corrected at the same time they are dealing with your timing fault.
|
11-26-2011, 03:58 PM
|
|
Member
|
|
|
Join Date: Dec 2009
Location: Virginia
Posts: 1,368
Likes: 13
Liked 831 Times in 390 Posts
|
|
What's the rush on the send-back?
If that's just break-in wear, and the gun functions normally otherwise, are you really going to send it back for something of such a minor cosmetic nature?
No safe queens.
__________________
WWSSD?
What would Skeeter do?
|
11-26-2011, 04:18 PM
|
Member
|
|
|
Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: Metro Detroit, Michigan
Posts: 6,919
Likes: 179
Liked 4,294 Times in 2,106 Posts
|
|
If you had just purchase a new car and one wheel wobbled around all caddywompous wouldn't you take it in to get it fixed. On a new revolver that has only been shot in single action a peened cylinder stop notch is an indication of a functional deficit in carry up. Better to have that fixed quickly than wait until some real damage has been done.
|
11-27-2011, 12:34 PM
|
Member
|
|
|
Join Date: Aug 2008
Location: Montana
Posts: 1,053
Likes: 540
Liked 587 Times in 186 Posts
|
|
I have seen peening more times than not, even on my 617. I THINK there are several reasons for that. Like has been said already.
I personally think it is not a soft alloy but when you pull the trigger upon firing the hand pushes on the ratchets a little more and any inperfection in the notch will be pushed out against the side of the notch. Just my inexperianced thought. It does not affect my guns in any other way.
John
|
11-27-2011, 01:12 PM
|
|
Member
|
|
|
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: Oregon
Posts: 2,403
Likes: 4,558
Liked 2,141 Times in 770 Posts
|
|
This thread got me curious, so I looked at four or five of my stainless guns. They've all been shot, and they all exhibit some degree of peening, similar to whats been shown in the photos. Usually there's one notch that shows a little more peening, and this seems consistent with all of my guns.
I've noticed this previously, and I put in the same catagory as flame cutting- if you shoot your guns, it happens. If it does not seem to get worse, and does not affect funtion or accuracy, then I don't consider it a problem.
Mechanical devices with metal on metal moving parts can be expected to show some wear, just the nature of the beast. IMHO, ymmv, etc.
__________________
ΜΟΛΩΝ ΛΑΒΕ
|
11-27-2011, 02:01 PM
|
Member
|
|
|
Join Date: May 2009
Location: OC
Posts: 503
Likes: 199
Liked 288 Times in 158 Posts
|
|
My 629 from the 90's, did the same thing. Break-in wear. On S&W's this is not unusual.
|
11-27-2011, 04:35 PM
|
|
Member
|
|
|
Join Date: May 2011
Location: Montana
Posts: 576
Likes: 392
Liked 109 Times in 79 Posts
|
|
WHEW!!!! Glad to hear is a normal thing. This 629 is my only revolver so am new to the ins and outs of it. Have only had semi-auto pistols before. Thanks for the input guys even though I didn't ask this question originally.
__________________
44 Garrett Defender Ammo 4 me.
|
01-22-2012, 05:24 PM
|
|
US Veteran
|
|
|
Join Date: Dec 2008
Location: New England
Posts: 4,190
Likes: 3,543
Liked 3,996 Times in 1,627 Posts
|
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by AKsRule
I have never experienced damage like that on a S&W.
I own 10 pre-lock S&Ws ( all bought used ) and none show any "peening".
Firing 90 rounds of factory ammo should not cause that.
My thought is that your 629 is slightly out of time AND the locking bolt is dragging.
I would send it back and demand a new cylinder.
.
|
On a brand new revolver, I would agree....
__________________
'Nam 1968-69.DAV,VFW,NRA Inst.
|
01-22-2012, 06:10 PM
|
Member
|
|
|
Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: Indiana
Posts: 847
Likes: 0
Liked 14 Times in 11 Posts
|
|
Maybe I just can't see the pictures real well but that looks like a lead build up from soft lead bullets. Lead round nose 44 Specials perhaps? If you're using a premium 44 Special with a jacketed bullet of some kind you're ok but lead factory Specials can be really nasty. Did you fire the Specials last?
|
01-22-2012, 06:20 PM
|
Member
|
|
|
Join Date: Dec 2011
Location: above ground, under water
Posts: 760
Likes: 722
Liked 594 Times in 263 Posts
|
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by scooter123
I see only one image that is at all concerning, that is the top image. It appears that particular stop notch is peened slightly on the face opposite the lead in.
There are 2 possible causes for peening this face of the stop notch. One is a lot of rapid fire shooting typical to what is seen it some types of competitive shooting and it takes a lot of rounds downrange for this to become noticeable.
The other is when the gun fires with the cylinder just shy of the stop dropping into the notch. What happens in this case is that when the fired bullet hits the forcing cone it will cause the cylinder to rotate violently due to the "centering" action of the bullet hitting the forcing cone. The major cause of this is a timing fault called "failure to carry up". The minor cause is staging the trigger in double action, a practice that S&W discourages in the owners manual. If you pull the trigger in one complete motion when shooting in double action the inertia of the rotating cylinder will carry it into full lock even if it does fail to carry up properly in a carry up test.
At this point your damage is so minor that I don't see any need to have the cylinder replaced. However, I believe that you should test for carry up and send your 629 into S&W if you find you have a failure to carry up. I will also discourage you from staging the trigger in double action because in time simple wear will cause carry up issues to reappear. In addition, in real Combat it's not how you would use a double action trigger and I'm a believer in training how you might have to shoot if the need to defend yourself should occur.
Testing for carry up is rather simple. Put some snap caps that measure at the same diameter as a properly size round or sized empty casings in the cyliner. Then pull the trigger in double action using a super slow motion trigger pull. Listen for the cylinder stop to drop before the hammer falls. BTW, you may need to use two fingers on the trigger to pull it slowly enough. If you find a cchamber or two where the stop doesn't drop in before hammer fall, mark them with a sharpie marker or the like. In this case peening the ratchet pall for the offending cylinder position(s) is the solution. If you find carryup problems on every chamber position, a thicker hand is the fix. Since these require "touch" and some fitting, it's not a kitchen table fix so let the warranty center do the work.
I'll also note that failures to carry up with a left handed trigger pull is typical to the S&W lockwork, so typical that it's uncommon to NOT find carry up issues with the left hand. In addition, trying to achieve perfect carry up for left handed shooters usually results in a slight Hand/Cylinder bind on those guns when used right handed. Rumor has it that the Floating Hand was an attempt to correct the left hand carry up issues that didn't succeed. The simple fact is the lockwork in a S&W is right handed to a slight extent and lefties should make it a habit to NEVER stage their trigger.
|
What is meant by "stageing the trigger"?
|
01-22-2012, 07:52 PM
|
|
Member
|
|
|
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: Oregon
Posts: 2,403
Likes: 4,558
Liked 2,141 Times in 770 Posts
|
|
A quick side trip on staging the trigger:
Staging the trigger re-visited
__________________
ΜΟΛΩΝ ΛΑΒΕ
|
01-23-2012, 01:45 AM
|
|
SWCA Member
|
|
|
Join Date: Apr 2004
Location: Warrensburg, MO USA
Posts: 5,404
Likes: 2,841
Liked 3,294 Times in 1,688 Posts
|
|
Several years ago, i purchased a new 627-2 and it also showed peening around all the cylinder stop notches in short order, causing a slight hitch in the double action pull. A machinist suggested I just peen the metal back into the cylinder. I have shot many thousands of .38 special rounds through it since, and I have only had to peen it one more time, and then only very lightly. It may be self correcting, like the flame cutting on the topstrap.
__________________
Richard Gillespie
FBINA 102
|
01-23-2012, 06:21 AM
|
Member
|
|
|
Join Date: Jun 2010
Location: Maine
Posts: 3,060
Likes: 24,416
Liked 5,766 Times in 1,275 Posts
|
|
I looked at photos real quick on my phone - looks like it starting to develop a normal turn line - nothing to get worried about - oil it up and forget about it.
|
01-23-2012, 08:24 AM
|
Member
|
|
|
Join Date: Jun 2010
Location: Maine
Posts: 3,060
Likes: 24,416
Liked 5,766 Times in 1,275 Posts
|
|
I've looked again - noticed the peening - a friend of mine has a couple of stainless smiths they all look much worse then yours and I always wondered why - untill we where shooting one day, we were no more then 8' apart and I was shooting a ported 445 supermag , I had plugs and muffs on and while I was looking at primers of the rounds I just shot I could hear this sniking sound - it was my buddy thumb cocking his gun - now I only let him shoot my rugers - I would still oil it up and forget about it - by the way those grips look great - hope this helps
|
01-23-2012, 11:01 AM
|
|
Member
|
|
|
Join Date: Nov 2011
Location: Pac NW
Posts: 401
Likes: 25
Liked 201 Times in 53 Posts
|
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by CWH44300
I've looked again - noticed the peening - a friend of mine has a couple of stainless smiths they all look much worse then yours and I always wondered why - untill we where shooting one day, we were no more then 8' apart and I was shooting a ported 445 supermag , I had plugs and muffs on and while I was looking at primers of the rounds I just shot I could hear this sniking sound - it was my buddy thumb cocking his gun - now I only let him shoot my rugers - I would still oil it up and forget about it - by the way those grips look great - hope this helps
|
Thanks alot, I really enjoy these grips.
I'm not sure I follow the 'thumb cocking'?
|
01-23-2012, 09:25 PM
|
Member
|
|
|
Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: Middle Tennessee
Posts: 106
Likes: 1
Liked 10 Times in 6 Posts
|
|
Note the cylinder stop is a MIM part, showing an uneven surface from the molds not being aligned perfectly .... causing the contact point to be only partial and the added psi pressure on the partially contacted surface in the cylinder notches showing the resulting pattern of uneven contact at each cylinder.
|
|
Thread Tools |
|
Display Modes |
Linear Mode
|
Posting Rules
|
|
|
|
|