What would be a fair price on the following two guns.

Both in excellent, nearly new shape. No box, but original grips.

1. A 57-1 with 8 3/8" barrel.

2. A 357PD with 4" barrel.

I gave 600$ for a 57 8 3/8 nickle last year, best deal I had found on one.

around here a 57-1, 8&3/8 is going to start at 700 dollars if in excellent shape and may be asking 800 from some folks

Does anyone have an idea of the price for a 357PD.

It's the 4" model -- the 41 mag version of the 329pd.

The 357PD is a rather rare bird. Took me over a year to find a good one. Pricing is hard to say, as they do not come up often from what I have seen. I paid $800 for mine about two years ago if that helps. They are no longer in production.

If like new then $700+ is right for the 57-1.

As smith said on the PD, they don't come up for sale very often and when they do will usually bring more than a .44 Magnum 329PD... The highest I've seen paid for a LNIB 357PD was just over a grand....usually they are in the $800-950 area.

Bob

Around here a 57-1 with an 8 3/8" is a min. of $800; no questions asked.