I've been carrying on the belt a 640Pro. It is a very nice J-frame revolver and is comfortable to carry. I carry it with 125 grain .357 magnum loads.

I am thinking of adding a 686 plus snubbie to my collection. I like this one: https://www.smith-wesson.com/wcsstor...686_170346.pdf

My question relates to carry. Has anyone made this J-frame to L-frame transition with a on the belt holster for concealed carry? And what is your feeling on this?

Is it a burden to carry? Do you think the extra two rounds and reduced perceived recoil worth the change?

And there seems to be very few holsters for this (on the belt carry). I like a high ride with no thumb snap. I've seen Galco's and they both have thumb snaps. Any recommendations?

About a year ago I stopped carrying my J Frames and switched over to L Frames. I now carry a 686 PC 2.5" and a 586 L Comp most often. These are the heavier all steel guns. I also carry the lighter scandium frame versions, the 386 Night Guard 2.5" (steel cylinder) and the even lighter 386PD 2.5" (Titanium cylinder).

The transition was smooth and simple. The key is a good holster and carry belt. Here is my review of the process:

Praise For Tucker Gun Leather

And another:

New Holster for my L Frame Snubbys

You might like this too:

686PC, 386NG, 386PD…The Winner Is…

Nice gun, but a heavier gun means a more stout concealed carry holster and belt combo. If I were you, I'd be looking for a quality horsehide build for that 686, since it weighs over 2 lbs. empty. I'm not trying to talk you out of the 686, but you might try a little less snappy load with your 640, if the recoil seems too sharp. The 125 gr. HP is a good defensive load, but can make range practice less than enjoyable for lighter weight snubbies. Enjoy the 686.