Ill start with this: TAX RETURN TIME!

I currently have a GP100 .357 4" and a SRH 7 1/2" .44.
I'm looking for a little guidance on deciding which of the these two S&W model's I should add to the stable. I have never fired either of the two Smith's, love the .44 mag round and find 8 rnds of .357 fascinating.

Let the opinions fly!

Thanks, Troy

Sure . I'll play. 627.

I shoot my 627 the most. It "lives" in my range bag. If you ever /never tried an 8 shot, they're something else. I had 3 gp100s and a few Redhawks. A mooncliped 8 shooter is much different.

Although I do shoot 44s,it's far less. And if you buy new ammo-more expensive.

Sent from my SM-G930T using Tapatalk

Gotta love a team player!
I'm really leaning towards the 627, more of a "racing" gun when compared to the 629.

Yes! A race gun. With very little to tinker with.
Just finding the right ammo for it and the use of the correct moonclips and you're good to go!



Sent from my SM-G930T using Tapatalk

Well.. it's done. A new 627 is on order, did a bunch of reading tonight and I think that platform suits me best. Now I'll start saving up for the 629!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

You made a wise choice!
You will use the 627 more...

Sent from my SM-G930T using Tapatalk

I'll say, I love .38/.357 and .44 magnum.

With that said, I had the same choice (.357 or .44) back in Dec and I went with the 627. The pistol is just awesome to shoot, great size, great weight, and the barrel keeps the muzzle down on repeat shots.

Like everyone else here, I love to shoot. Often and a lot. .38 is easily the cheapest to shoot (especially for me, I do not reload) so that helped my decision big time. Also, I like range time to take time so I don't want something that is going to fatigue me so fast like the .44 does.

OP, you picked a nice shooter, I'm sure you'll be more than pleased with it.

I bought the 627PC a couple years ago, and just love it.

Compared to my bought new 4in 686 No-dash, the weight and handling are nearly identical:

• 686 4in .357 loaded, weighs 43oz.
• 627PC 2.62in .357 loaded, weighs 42.4oz.

Notice that with my 627PC I get 8-rounds, plus save 0.6oz. in weight. Two extra rounds, a shorter barrel, and save weight. IMO, you can't beat that with a stick...

Thanks guys, but you'e not helping my anxiousness!
I suspect she'll be in my grubby little hands Thursday or Friday and immediate put in action.

629 all the way.I left .357 magnums 35 yrs ago and never looked back.

Well, here she is! All dirtied from a handful of rounds, went from the LGS straight to my range and broke er in. While I was at the LGS he showed me a SW 3913 that he had just taken in, I made the mistake of fondling it....$400 later it has a new home...

Hmm....can't seem to load pics...stand bye:

I own a 627 pro and a 4" 629. The obvious answer is both.