Smith & Wesson Forum

Go Back   Smith & Wesson Forum > Ammunition-Gunsmithing > S&W-Smithing
o

Notices

S&W-Smithing Maintenance, Repair, and Enhancement of Smith & Wesson and Other Firearms.


Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old 08-11-2018, 09:41 PM
Hearsedriver's Avatar
Hearsedriver Hearsedriver is offline
Member
Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch  
Join Date: Oct 2011
Location: Ft.Worth
Posts: 563
Likes: 29
Liked 106 Times in 56 Posts
Default Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch

I have a Schofield 2000 top break revolver that has 2 tabs on the bottom rear of the rear sight that I assume are to keep the cylinder from going back too far during recoil. One of the tabs is broken off as shown. Are these tabs necassary? As you can see, the tabs are making dents on the rear of the cylinder. I havent contacted S&W yet but from what I have read, they dont have any parst for these. Im trying to find a solution if anyone has any ideas. Thanks
Attached Images
File Type: jpg 010.jpg (54.9 KB, 150 views)
__________________
Cliff

Last edited by Hearsedriver; 08-16-2018 at 12:39 PM.
Reply With Quote
  #2  
Old 08-12-2018, 04:40 PM
Hearsedriver's Avatar
Hearsedriver Hearsedriver is offline
Member
Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch  
Join Date: Oct 2011
Location: Ft.Worth
Posts: 563
Likes: 29
Liked 106 Times in 56 Posts
Default

So, it looks like the part that the tab is broken off of is called the cylinder retainer. It looks like the only function of those 2 tabs is to keep the cylinder from being removed when the gun is broke open. If that is the case, I wonder how it broke and how it caused the dings on the back of the cylinder? Looking at the area where the tab broke off, it appears that that part may be a MIM part or casting of some kind. I was thinking that maybe it could be tig welded and a new tab shaped to match the other but, can it be welded? Any gunsmiths here? How you approach this repair?
__________________
Cliff
Reply With Quote
  #3  
Old 08-12-2018, 09:13 PM
Protocall_Design Protocall_Design is offline
Vendor
Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch  
Join Date: Jan 2010
Location: Kansas City area
Posts: 6,129
Likes: 53,433
Liked 13,433 Times in 4,240 Posts
Default

Maybe that's why they call them top breaks?

I have always liked the look of the Schofield, but never seen anything but a few pictures. All the S&W MIM parts I've seen can be readily TIG welded. I've done it several times. That one could probably be welded and re machined.

It's hard to tell from the one picture, but it looks like that might be a separate piece from the top strap. If it's a small removable part, I would probably just make a new one out of tool steel and properly heat treat it and be done with the problem.
Reply With Quote
  #4  
Old 08-12-2018, 09:14 PM
scooter123 scooter123 is offline
Member
 
Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: Metro Detroit, Michigan
Posts: 6,919
Likes: 179
Liked 4,294 Times in 2,106 Posts
Default

Before you repair that tab or the cylinder I think you need to address the CAUSE for this failure. Because those tabs are only intended to retain the cylinder in position during the ejection cycle when the cylinder and barrel are opened.

As for the CAUSE of this damage I suspect that the frame has been stretched, most likely by loads that are too "hot" for this top break. Originally these revolvers were chambered in a caliber that preceded the 44 special, the 44 Russian. A cartridge that was shorter and less powerful than the relatively mild (in today's terms) 44 Special. IIRC the 2000 model was chambered in 45 Long Colt and that particular cartridge can be loaded to power levels approaching that of the 44 Magnum. IMO any copy of the old Top Breaks should be considered to be as weak as the originals and any ammunition used in them be downloaded to the energy level of the 44 Russian. Meaning you should have been using what today is referred as Cowboy loads, basically powder puff versions intended for Cowboy competition shooting.

As for Repair, since this was a post 1989 manufactured revolver Smith & Wesson is obligated to stand by the terms of the Lifetime Warranty that is in place for revolvers manufactured after 1989. Unfortunately they may not have the means to repair your revolver. If so they will probably offer you an "alternative" model to replace your revolver. IF so I would suggest that you take NOTHING less than the 500 Magnum. Then sell that and use the proceeds to locate and purchase a Schofield copy made by Uberti. BTW, I have a sneaking hunch that the Schofield 2000 revolvers sold by S&W were actually produced by Uberti.

If they can repair your revolver I expect that the process will be to straighten the frame until it gages properly with the cylinder closed then they will repair the top strap and and dings in the cylinder. After that they will probably have to refinish the revolver. Obviously this would be a rather expensive repair so don't be surprised if they ask what specific ammunition was used in this revolver. They may also claim that you voided your warranty by using ammunition that was not approved for use with this revolver in the manual that came with the revolver. I would suggest that if at all possible you have the manual for this revolver in hand any time you are talking to S&W.
Reply With Quote
The Following 2 Users Like Post:
  #5  
Old 08-12-2018, 11:48 PM
Hearsedriver's Avatar
Hearsedriver Hearsedriver is offline
Member
Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch  
Join Date: Oct 2011
Location: Ft.Worth
Posts: 563
Likes: 29
Liked 106 Times in 56 Posts
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by scooter123 View Post
Before you repair that tab or the cylinder I think you need to address the CAUSE for this failure. Because those tabs are only intended to retain the cylinder in position during the ejection cycle when the cylinder and barrel are opened.

As for the CAUSE of this damage I suspect that the frame has been stretched, most likely by loads that are too "hot" for this top break. Originally these revolvers were chambered in a caliber that preceded the 44 special, the 44 Russian. A cartridge that was shorter and less powerful than the relatively mild (in today's terms) 44 Special. IIRC the 2000 model was chambered in 45 Long Colt and that particular cartridge can be loaded to power levels approaching that of the 44 Magnum. IMO any copy of the old Top Breaks should be considered to be as weak as the originals and any ammunition used in them be downloaded to the energy level of the 44 Russian. Meaning you should have been using what today is referred as Cowboy loads, basically powder puff versions intended for Cowboy competition shooting.

As for Repair, since this was a post 1989 manufactured revolver Smith & Wesson is obligated to stand by the terms of the Lifetime Warranty that is in place for revolvers manufactured after 1989. Unfortunately they may not have the means to repair your revolver. If so they will probably offer you an "alternative" model to replace your revolver. IF so I would suggest that you take NOTHING less than the 500 Magnum. Then sell that and use the proceeds to locate and purchase a Schofield copy made by Uberti. BTW, I have a sneaking hunch that the Schofield 2000 revolvers sold by S&W were actually produced by Uberti.

If they can repair your revolver I expect that the process will be to straighten the frame until it gages properly with the cylinder closed then they will repair the top strap and and dings in the cylinder. After that they will probably have to refinish the revolver. Obviously this would be a rather expensive repair so don't be surprised if they ask what specific ammunition was used in this revolver. They may also claim that you voided your warranty by using ammunition that was not approved for use with this revolver in the manual that came with the revolver. I would suggest that if at all possible you have the manual for this revolver in hand any time you are talking to S&W.
Thanks for all of the great information. I have read of this issue on a few of these guns where the tabs leave indentions on the back of the cylinder. I wonder if the cylinder was made slightly too long. I think it left the factory with something out of spec. Its had 500 rounds through it since new. I was able to dress and touch up the marks on the rear of the barrel and they dont bother me. I would also like to know why that tab broke off because the cylinder does not move back far enough to touch the tabs when the barrel is closed if I push it to the rear manually but, they obviously have since they left indentions on the cylinder. Im called S&W tomorrow with hopes that they will at least sell me the cylinder retainer. If not, I will order a Uberti replacement to see if it fits or can be fitted to my gun. They look the same in the pictures. The finish on the gun still looks new so, I dont see why it would need to be refinished although I wouldnt mind having them replace or refinish the cylinder.
__________________
Cliff
Reply With Quote
  #6  
Old 08-13-2018, 07:33 AM
2152hq 2152hq is offline
Member
Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch  
Join Date: Sep 2005
Posts: 7,724
Likes: 1,633
Liked 9,091 Times in 3,362 Posts
Default

My first guess is that the extractor rod which is simply screwed into the back end of the extractor is too long by a few .000

Perhaps it's backed out a little, or the parts are just a touch to long.

The extractor rod with the extractor attached is pushed upward (to eject the casings) as the revolver is opened.
The 'extractor cam' does that pushing. That part is located in the rounded portion of the frame at the front and is the common part in most every top break..that round washer like part with the arm like projection.

As the extractor rod w/ extractor attached are pushed upwards as the bbl is opened, the bbl reached a limit of travel (full open).
**IF the extractor rod w/ extractor reaches IT'S full limit of travel before that..and that would be to be stopped by those fragile cylinder stop tabs one of which is already broken,,,,then the extractor cam continues to push hard on the extractor rod and extractor against those tabs.
That extended motion would IMO lead to breaking the tab(s) and/or imprinting what is left of them into the rear edge of the cylinder itself.


Clean up the marks and they'll just reappear. The source is still there. Something is pushing the cylinder hard with the extractor already pushed out to it's limit in the ejection cycle.

Before you disasemble anything,,open the revolver, tease the extractor out and back as far as you can w/o it snapping back in the cylinder.
When the extractor is at it's full out/extended position,,,note if the cylinder itself is now pushed hard up against that small bbl latch tab(s).
It should NOT be.
At most when ejecting empty fired rounds some drag from the brass cases will push the cylinder back against those tabs.
But the mechanical push against the extractor rod and extractor should NOT be transfered to the cylinder so that it can then push on those tabs.
I think that is what is breaking them and marking the cylinder.

Remove the bbl latch,,if they are anything like the orig, the rear screw should only need a 1/2 turn loosened.
Then loosen the front screw.

You should be able to tilt the latch upwards to clear the small tab(s) from the cylinder edge and pull the cylinder itself right off it's axel pin.
If it won't tilt with a 1/2 turn on the rear screw,,then just remove the rear screw. The orig ones had a 1/2dia cut thru the body of the rear screw to allow disassembly w/o full removal of the screw(s).

The extractor rod hanging out the back of the cylinder should have a hole thru it. With some empty cases in the chambers, put a punch thru the hole and unscrew RH the extractor rod from the extractor and pull the parts out. A coil spring will be around the assembly and that'll slide right off.

Make note of wether the thing unscrews with any force needed or wether it's loosely assembled.
Take a look at end of the rod where the cam pushes on it. Does it look deformed a bit and heavily burnished like the cam arm was over stressed iin pushing on it..
Perhaps a slight shortening of the end of the extractor rod would do it, or maybe just tightening the assembly.

The orig bbl latch could be laser or tig welded and reshaped w/o a lot of fanfare to complete the repair.

The newer Schofield may have some modern internal refinements and differences I'm not aware of,,I've never had one apart. But this is what I recall of the orig pistol and I think may be the problem

Last edited by 2152hq; 08-13-2018 at 07:35 AM.
Reply With Quote
The Following User Likes This Post:
  #7  
Old 08-13-2018, 09:54 AM
Hearsedriver's Avatar
Hearsedriver Hearsedriver is offline
Member
Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch  
Join Date: Oct 2011
Location: Ft.Worth
Posts: 563
Likes: 29
Liked 106 Times in 56 Posts
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by 2152hq View Post
My first guess is that the extractor rod which is simply screwed into the back end of the extractor is too long by a few .000

Perhaps it's backed out a little, or the parts are just a touch to long.

The extractor rod with the extractor attached is pushed upward (to eject the casings) as the revolver is opened.
The 'extractor cam' does that pushing. That part is located in the rounded portion of the frame at the front and is the common part in most every top break..that round washer like part with the arm like projection.

As the extractor rod w/ extractor attached are pushed upwards as the bbl is opened, the bbl reached a limit of travel (full open).
**IF the extractor rod w/ extractor reaches IT'S full limit of travel before that..and that would be to be stopped by those fragile cylinder stop tabs one of which is already broken,,,,then the extractor cam continues to push hard on the extractor rod and extractor against those tabs.
That extended motion would IMO lead to breaking the tab(s) and/or imprinting what is left of them into the rear edge of the cylinder itself.


Clean up the marks and they'll just reappear. The source is still there. Something is pushing the cylinder hard with the extractor already pushed out to it's limit in the ejection cycle.

Before you disasemble anything,,open the revolver, tease the extractor out and back as far as you can w/o it snapping back in the cylinder.
When the extractor is at it's full out/extended position,,,note if the cylinder itself is now pushed hard up against that small bbl latch tab(s).
It should NOT be.
At most when ejecting empty fired rounds some drag from the brass cases will push the cylinder back against those tabs.
But the mechanical push against the extractor rod and extractor should NOT be transfered to the cylinder so that it can then push on those tabs.
I think that is what is breaking them and marking the cylinder.

Remove the bbl latch,,if they are anything like the orig, the rear screw should only need a 1/2 turn loosened.
Then loosen the front screw.

You should be able to tilt the latch upwards to clear the small tab(s) from the cylinder edge and pull the cylinder itself right off it's axel pin.
If it won't tilt with a 1/2 turn on the rear screw,,then just remove the rear screw. The orig ones had a 1/2dia cut thru the body of the rear screw to allow disassembly w/o full removal of the screw(s).

The extractor rod hanging out the back of the cylinder should have a hole thru it. With some empty cases in the chambers, put a punch thru the hole and unscrew RH the extractor rod from the extractor and pull the parts out. A coil spring will be around the assembly and that'll slide right off.

Make note of wether the thing unscrews with any force needed or wether it's loosely assembled.
Take a look at end of the rod where the cam pushes on it. Does it look deformed a bit and heavily burnished like the cam arm was over stressed iin pushing on it..
Perhaps a slight shortening of the end of the extractor rod would do it, or maybe just tightening the assembly.

The orig bbl latch could be laser or tig welded and reshaped w/o a lot of fanfare to complete the repair.

The newer Schofield may have some modern internal refinements and differences I'm not aware of,,I've never had one apart. But this is what I recall of the orig pistol and I think may be the problem
Thanks for your thourough and thoughtful post! It would definetly make sense however, when this revolver is broke open, the cylinder rest against those tabs as soon as the extractor starts to extend and is held there under the tension of the coil spring around the extractor rod. Even when the barrel is fully open, I can still easily slide the cylinder down the extractor rod about 1/16". Even if you slammed the barrel open, I dont think there is enough pressure to make the dents in the rear of the cylinder but this gun has been babied. It almost has to be something happening under recoil.
__________________
Cliff
Reply With Quote
  #8  
Old 08-14-2018, 09:12 AM
Hearsedriver's Avatar
Hearsedriver Hearsedriver is offline
Member
Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch  
Join Date: Oct 2011
Location: Ft.Worth
Posts: 563
Likes: 29
Liked 106 Times in 56 Posts
Default

I called S&W yesterday and they are sending me a replacment cylinder catch under warranty. I was happy that they had them in stock. As far as the cause of the marks on the back of the cylinder left by the cylinder catch tabs, from what I can see and from the previous posters reply, they are caused during the ejection process. I probably snapped the barrel open too fast or too hard at some point, maybe when the action was getting dirty or somthing. From checking photos posted on the web, I found several examples of the same markings on the rear of the cylinders of other 2000's. Mine has a 500 round count so, its going to show some wear. I thought that this might have been occurring during recoil but, it would be imposssible with cartridges in the cylinder. In one thread that I read, another owner was told by S&W that the marks are normal. I would imagine that most of these guns have never been shot and certainly not as much as mine has been. I would love to hear from other owners of the 2000 with higher round counts about any issues like mine that you have experienced. Thanks for the help here guys!
__________________
Cliff
Reply With Quote
The Following User Likes This Post:
  #9  
Old 08-14-2018, 11:46 AM
glowe's Avatar
glowe glowe is offline
US Veteran

Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch  
Join Date: Nov 2009
Location: Michigan Western UP
Posts: 12,912
Likes: 3,028
Liked 14,242 Times in 5,431 Posts
Default

Until you determine the cause of the issue, it will continue to occur. You are correct in that the tabs receive very little stress when opening the revolver, even quickly, should not cause even a mark on the rear of the cylinder.

Unless I missed it, you have not stated what ammunition you have been using? I believe that the marks on the cylinder are caused during firing. I would guess what is happening is that the base pin that is in the center of the ejector star is too short and not fully contacting the recoil shield and the tabs of catch are taking all the recoil of the gun. I am also wondering if you have used any hot loads??

The center pin in the ejector star of old time revolvers could actually be moved and unscrewed, but I have never tried it on any of my Model 3s. I have long believed that the base pin could be adjusted by turning it to tighten up the cylinder. If that is a possibility with your S&W 2000, moving the base pin back could solve the problem.

I can only compare your images to a Navy Arms Schofield that has had a few thousand rounds through it. I have loaded up to full charge FFF, 36 grains, that kick like a mule, but still have not one mark on the rear of my cylinder. There is only a slight click and undetectable fore & aft movement on the cylinder when closed. The catch on my Navy Schofield is exactly like yours, so you either have a short catch or a short base pin to cause the issues you have in my opinion. We are only talking about a few thousandths movement that will make the difference. I measured .012" between the rear of the brass and the recoil shield, so the brass will not stop the cylinder from traveling to the rear. You will see that a Navy Arms ejector star is a one piece cast unit, without the possibility of adjustment. An adjustable base pin would have two small slots on each side.
Attached Images
File Type: jpg P1010002.jpg (90.7 KB, 48 views)
File Type: jpg P1010004.jpg (81.6 KB, 54 views)
File Type: jpg P1010005.jpg (127.1 KB, 44 views)
__________________
Gary
SWCA 2515
Reply With Quote
  #10  
Old 08-14-2018, 11:54 AM
Hearsedriver's Avatar
Hearsedriver Hearsedriver is offline
Member
Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch  
Join Date: Oct 2011
Location: Ft.Worth
Posts: 563
Likes: 29
Liked 106 Times in 56 Posts
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by glowe View Post
Until you determine the cause of the issue, it will continue to occur. You are correct in that the tabs receive very little stress when opening the revolver, even quickly, should not cause even a mark on the rear of the cylinder.

Unless I missed it, you have not stated what ammunition you have been using? I believe that the marks on the cylinder are caused during firing. I would guess what is happening is that the base pin that is in the center of the ejector star is too short and not fully contacting the recoil shield and the tabs of catch are taking all the recoil of the gun. I am also wondering if you have used any hot loads??

The center pin in the ejector star of old time revolvers could actually be moved and unscrewed, but I have never tried it on any of my Model 3s. I have long believed that the base pin could be adjusted by turning it to tighten up the cylinder. If that is a possibility with your S&W 2000, moving the base pin back could solve the problem.

I can only compare your images to a Navy Arms Schofield that has had a few thousand rounds through it. I have loaded up to full charge FFF, 36 grains, that kick like a mule, but still have not one mark on the rear of my cylinder. There is only a slight click and undetectable fore & aft movement on the cylinder when closed. The catch on my Navy Schofield is exactly like yours, so you either have a short catch or a short base pin to cause the issues you have in my opinion. We are only talking about a few thousandths movement that will make the difference. I measured .012" between the rear of the brass and the recoil shield, so the brass will not stop the cylinder from traveling to the rear. You will see that a Navy Arms ejector star is a one piece cast unit, without the possibility of adjustment. An adjustable base pin would have two small slots on each side.
Thanks Gary. How can I move the base pin back? Unscrew it? Would that not make the cylinder closer to the rear fo the frame and those tabs on the cylinder catch? Im not quite understanding. Its only had factory cowboy loads through it. C
__________________
Cliff

Last edited by Hearsedriver; 08-14-2018 at 11:58 AM.
Reply With Quote
  #11  
Old 08-14-2018, 12:34 PM
Hearsedriver's Avatar
Hearsedriver Hearsedriver is offline
Member
Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch  
Join Date: Oct 2011
Location: Ft.Worth
Posts: 563
Likes: 29
Liked 106 Times in 56 Posts
Default

Also, as seen in this picture, there is a significant gap between the rear of the cylinder and tab with the cylinder pushed back as hard as I can. Could it be moving rearward that much more during recoil?
Attached Images
File Type: jpg 006.jpg (42.8 KB, 51 views)
__________________
Cliff
Reply With Quote
  #12  
Old 08-14-2018, 12:43 PM
Hearsedriver's Avatar
Hearsedriver Hearsedriver is offline
Member
Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch  
Join Date: Oct 2011
Location: Ft.Worth
Posts: 563
Likes: 29
Liked 106 Times in 56 Posts
Default

So that we are using the same terminology, it might help to refer to this schematic. I assume you are calling part 879 the base pin.
Attached Images
File Type: jpg AG0106_p20_SmithWessonRevolver.jpg (54.8 KB, 52 views)
__________________
Cliff
Reply With Quote
  #13  
Old 08-14-2018, 04:17 PM
glowe's Avatar
glowe glowe is offline
US Veteran

Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch  
Join Date: Nov 2009
Location: Michigan Western UP
Posts: 12,912
Likes: 3,028
Liked 14,242 Times in 5,431 Posts
Default

In original Model 3 revolvers, there is a slot on either side of what that schematic calls an extractor stud. A slotted screwdriver is used to turn the stud or base pin.

When the cylinder is open, I can move the cylinder back to make contact with the tabs. When the cylinder is closed, it will barely move because the stud is firmly bedded in the recoil shield. In order for the tabs to make contact with the cylinder, that stud has to be too short in my opinion. Turning it out until the "play" is taken out of the cylinder when closed should make it impossible for the tabs to contact the cylinder.

That is the only thing I can think of that would cause enough force to dent the cylinder.
__________________
Gary
SWCA 2515
Reply With Quote
  #14  
Old 08-14-2018, 05:02 PM
Hearsedriver's Avatar
Hearsedriver Hearsedriver is offline
Member
Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch  
Join Date: Oct 2011
Location: Ft.Worth
Posts: 563
Likes: 29
Liked 106 Times in 56 Posts
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by glowe View Post
In original Model 3 revolvers, there is a slot on either side of what that schematic calls an extractor stud. A slotted screwdriver is used to turn the stud or base pin.

When the cylinder is open, I can move the cylinder back to make contact with the tabs. When the cylinder is closed, it will barely move because the stud is firmly bedded in the recoil shield. In order for the tabs to make contact with the cylinder, that stud has to be too short in my opinion. Turning it out until the "play" is taken out of the cylinder when closed should make it impossible for the tabs to contact the cylinder.

That is the only thing I can think of that would cause enough force to dent the cylinder.
Ahhh. Ok I understand now. The extractor stud is under spring tension I guess until the barrel is closed. I am still not sure how or if that stud can be extended. There is no provision on this base pin to turn it unless it is threaded. I cant tell if it is threaded or pressed into the frame. At least you have narrowed the issue down to this area and I appreciate it! By the way, I just measured the cylinder end play at .007". Does that sounds OK or excessive?
__________________
Cliff

Last edited by Hearsedriver; 08-14-2018 at 05:11 PM.
Reply With Quote
  #15  
Old 08-14-2018, 05:10 PM
glowe's Avatar
glowe glowe is offline
US Veteran

Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch  
Join Date: Nov 2009
Location: Michigan Western UP
Posts: 12,912
Likes: 3,028
Liked 14,242 Times in 5,431 Posts
Default

My Navy Arms has a cast steel ejector star and the base pin/stud is part of the star, so no option to adjust.
__________________
Gary
SWCA 2515
Reply With Quote
  #16  
Old 08-14-2018, 05:49 PM
Hearsedriver's Avatar
Hearsedriver Hearsedriver is offline
Member
Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch  
Join Date: Oct 2011
Location: Ft.Worth
Posts: 563
Likes: 29
Liked 106 Times in 56 Posts
Default

If anyone here has a NIB Schofield 2000 and willing to measure the cylinder gap and post it here, I would apprciate it.
__________________
Cliff
Reply With Quote
  #17  
Old 08-16-2018, 12:44 PM
Hearsedriver's Avatar
Hearsedriver Hearsedriver is offline
Member
Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch  
Join Date: Oct 2011
Location: Ft.Worth
Posts: 563
Likes: 29
Liked 106 Times in 56 Posts
Default

I hope we can revist this issue that is still happening. This morning, I used the softest shooting HSM cowboy loads I had and the rear of the cylinder is still hitting the cylinder catch and leaving dents. This is happening during recoil for sure. I dont know what to do to keep the cylinder from moving back too far. I have attached some pictures of how the cylinder is setup hoping for some ideas. After 550 rounds, she sure is a good shooter! Thanks!
Attached Images
File Type: jpg 008.jpg (40.1 KB, 50 views)
File Type: jpg 007.jpg (41.2 KB, 48 views)
File Type: jpg 009.jpg (37.2 KB, 46 views)
File Type: jpg 006.jpg (46.0 KB, 50 views)
__________________
Cliff

Last edited by Hearsedriver; 08-16-2018 at 12:46 PM.
Reply With Quote
  #18  
Old 08-16-2018, 02:42 PM
2152hq 2152hq is offline
Member
Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch  
Join Date: Sep 2005
Posts: 7,724
Likes: 1,633
Liked 9,091 Times in 3,362 Posts
Default

Is there a possibility the cylinder/barrel assembly is jumping open during firing/recoil?

I know it's not supposed to open with the hammer down all the way (fired position).
But just try it and see if the bbl latch is allowing any movement with the hammer all the way down and in some way then allowing the bbl/cylinder assembly to open just a tiny amt.

If the bbl can open even a small amt during firing (and then re-lock), can the cylinder move reward during that moment on it's axle and hit those tabs?

It doesn't seem all that probable but total unlatching of topbreaks is not all that uncommon.
...Having one unlatch and then lock back up certainly is!
But none have the lock system quite like the Schofield either.

If it can't doing some simple hand manipulation of the action then this theory is out the window,,
If it can,,perhaps placing a small piece of scotch tape or similar material over the bbl latch and onto the frame and then firing the pistol to see if the tape is broken by the latch opening during live fire might reveal it.


and maybe this is another dead end too..

Just some idle thoughts in the mid afternoon heat..I keep trying
Reply With Quote
  #19  
Old 08-16-2018, 03:07 PM
Hearsedriver's Avatar
Hearsedriver Hearsedriver is offline
Member
Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch  
Join Date: Oct 2011
Location: Ft.Worth
Posts: 563
Likes: 29
Liked 106 Times in 56 Posts
Default

I dont know if it is unlatching and then relatching or not. There is a very slight about of play in the latch when I wiggle the barrel and frame but the gun actually feels pretty tight. There is about .007" inch of front to back movement of the cylinder. I dont know if shimming to reduce that endplay would solve it or not. Im wondering of the frame hasnt been stretched slightly.
__________________
Cliff
Reply With Quote
  #20  
Old 08-16-2018, 04:06 PM
glowe's Avatar
glowe glowe is offline
US Veteran

Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch  
Join Date: Nov 2009
Location: Michigan Western UP
Posts: 12,912
Likes: 3,028
Liked 14,242 Times in 5,431 Posts
Default

You still have not mentioned what you have been shooting in the gun? The latch on the Schofield was designed to take what 45 caliber ammo could offer in the day. The latch would have to travel over 1/8" before the gun could open and then there is no way it would be able to re-latch on its own.

I too have been thinking that there is a chance of a bent frame, but solid lock-up would indicate that has not happened?? My theory is that the base pin is too short, since nothing else can prevent the cylinder from traveling rearward. Perhaps a gunsmith could add length by building up a weld on the stud and shaping it until the cylinder locks solidly without enough play in the cylinder to allow it to contact the cylinder catch tabs. Shims will do nothing to prevent the damage you are seeing since they will not stop rearward movement of the cylinder.

Lastly, .007" sounds way to small?? With the action open, pull the cylinder back as far as possible and measure the gap. Now close the gun and pull the cylinder back and measure. You can figure out what you have with feeler gauges in front of the cylinder. Using my reproduction Schofield as an example, i measured the gap between the barrel and face of the cylinder when the rear of the cylinder was touching the catch tabs and it was .015" Closing the gun and pushing the cylinder as far rearward as possible, I got .009". That tells me that the recoil shield is holding the cylinder .006" away from the tabs and therefore no damage to the cylinder. Check your out with careful measurements. Snug fit with the gauges, but not forced is the key.
__________________
Gary
SWCA 2515

Last edited by glowe; 08-16-2018 at 04:14 PM.
Reply With Quote
  #21  
Old 08-16-2018, 05:16 PM
Hearsedriver's Avatar
Hearsedriver Hearsedriver is offline
Member
Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch  
Join Date: Oct 2011
Location: Ft.Worth
Posts: 563
Likes: 29
Liked 106 Times in 56 Posts
Default

You still have not mentioned what you have been shooting in the gun?
As mentioned, HSM Cowboy loads. I use factory cowboy action ammo, usually 200-230 grain traveling at between 700-800 fps. No reloads.

The latch on the Schofield was designed to take what 45 caliber ammo could offer in the day. The latch would have to travel over 1/8" before the gun could open and then there is no way it would be able to re-latch on its own.

I too have been thinking that there is a chance of a bent frame, but solid lock-up would indicate that has not happened?? My theory is that the base pin is too short, since nothing else can prevent the cylinder from traveling rearward. Perhaps a gunsmith could add length by building up a weld on the stud and shaping it until the cylinder locks solidly without enough play in the cylinder to allow it to contact the cylinder catch tabs. Shims will do nothing to prevent the damage you are seeing since they will not stop rearward movement of the cylinder.
Agreed. I wish I knew how to remove the base pin from the frame. I dont know if it is threaded or pressed in.

Lastly, .007" sounds way to small?? With the action open, pull the cylinder back as far as possible and measure the gap.
.028"
Now close the gun and pull the cylinder back and measure.
.015"
You can figure out what you have with feeler gauges in front of the cylinder. Using my reproduction Schofield as an example, i measured the gap between the barrel and face of the cylinder when the rear of the cylinder was touching the catch tabs and it was .015" Closing the gun and pushing the cylinder as far rearward as possible, I got .009". That tells me that the recoil shield is holding the cylinder .006" away from the tabs and therefore no damage to the cylinder. Check your out with careful measurements. Snug fit with the gauges, but not forced is the key.


So mines comes out to .013" vs. your .006". Wow! Kinda sounds like I have a stretched frame.

To be clear, you are calling the part I have circled the base pin, correct?

What am I missing? Here is a picture of the gap which seems more then enough between the cylinder and tab.
Attached Images
File Type: jpg 012.jpg (141.2 KB, 33 views)
File Type: jpg 013.jpg (57.8 KB, 32 views)
__________________
Cliff

Last edited by Hearsedriver; 08-16-2018 at 06:54 PM.
Reply With Quote
  #22  
Old 08-16-2018, 08:37 PM
2152hq 2152hq is offline
Member
Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch  
Join Date: Sep 2005
Posts: 7,724
Likes: 1,633
Liked 9,091 Times in 3,362 Posts
Default

The base pin (part circled) doesn't limit or control the rearward movement of the cylinder.
The cylinder only spins on it as an axel.

What limits how far to the rear the cylinder will slide back when the gun is closed is the center flat portion of the ratchet/extractor bearing on the frame,,the centerpin being engaged in the frame.
The cylinder can't go back any farther than that center portion of the ratchet/extractor bearing against the frame allows.

When the gun is open,,that interface is lost.
Now the cylinder is free to back up on the base pin and would come right off the pin,,but,,to keep it on and in position,,those 2 little tabs were designed to hold the cylinder from doing just that.
The tabs take no recoil or shouldn't,,,(clearence) when the gun is closed and fired,
Nor should they take any stress as the cylinder is opened and the ratchet/extractor is pushed to it's extreme height just before it trips off the bbl cam and snaps back into position.

Measuring with a feeler gauge at the front of the cylinder with the gun open only tells you just that, that the cylinder slides back that far to meet the tabs.
It doesn't really matter how far it slides back when it's open, that should not be a slam, bang, dent the back of the cylinder event.
It gets gently pushed back (against the limit of the tabs so the cylinder stays in the gun and on the base pin) as the empty brass is raised up to be ejected when the ejector snaps back in position.

If you measure the clearence up front with the gun closed and the cylinder pushed to the rear,,that's the bbl/cyl gap. Good to know.
But what you really want to know is wether the rear center flat area of the ratchet is engaged and turning on the frame at the center pin point.
It should be and if it is,,then that's as far as that cylinder can go backwards.
If the edge of the cylinder does not touch those tabs at this point, it can't touch those tabs.
Recoil can't make the cylinder go any further backwards against the frame unless something in or on the frame is allowing it to move backwards during firing.


The base pin doesn't limit it's movement backwards,,it allows unlimited movement backwards.
The cylinder will come right off of the base pin no matter how long you make it if the ratchet center or the latch tabs weren't there.
The ratchet center against the frame arrests the cylinders movement when gun is closed,,the tabs when the gun is open.


**In looking at the one pic of the rear of the cylinder with the ratchet/extractor in place,,I notice the small wear circle in the blue finish around the center pin.

That wear circle I'd expect to see from some use, but I'd also expect to see it as a much wider circle of worn finish. Not the very narrow edge that shows.
What really catches my eye is the Star like imprint around that narrow wear circle.
That 'Star' looks just like the cylinder chamber indexing.
Is that flat bearing area of the ratchet that runs against the frame and holds the cylinder out and away from those tabs (holds the headspace actually) be imprinting itself ever so slightly somehow into the face of the frame around the center pin hole?

If it's in a pattern that mimics the chamber index, and was enough movement upon recoil to set the cylinder back a tiny amt, that may be enough to do the damage.
Kind of like how cartridges get imprinted into the face of the recoil shield on revolvers when fired.
What does the face of the frame look like at the center pin point?,,Any imprint from the matching wear pattern 'star' on the ratchet center or displaced metal,,or anything that may allow the cylinder to set back in recoil and hit those tabs.

Just another theory of course..

Last edited by 2152hq; 08-16-2018 at 08:41 PM.
Reply With Quote
  #23  
Old 08-16-2018, 08:54 PM
Hearsedriver's Avatar
Hearsedriver Hearsedriver is offline
Member
Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch  
Join Date: Oct 2011
Location: Ft.Worth
Posts: 563
Likes: 29
Liked 106 Times in 56 Posts
Default

2142hq, thank you for the outstanding reply! I didnt think the base pin had anything to do with the forward/backward travel limit of the cylinder either. Good eye on the star pattern! I had not noticed that. Yes, the same pattern can be seen around the center hole. The star does match the indexing too. Any ideas on how to correct it? Im thinking the cylinder is just traveling back around .002-.003" by judging the marks on the cylinder. Im really surprised that the cylinder can travel back .015-.016" of an inch during recoil!
Attached Images
File Type: jpg 014.jpg (68.7 KB, 41 views)
__________________
Cliff
Reply With Quote
  #24  
Old 08-16-2018, 10:04 PM
glowe's Avatar
glowe glowe is offline
US Veteran

Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch  
Join Date: Nov 2009
Location: Michigan Western UP
Posts: 12,912
Likes: 3,028
Liked 14,242 Times in 5,431 Posts
Default

I call that a quill, and it is not the base pin or stud which is the very center of the star for me. Part 885a on your schematic in post 12 as previously discussed. Others have called it a base pin and I recall that my Navy Arms schematic calls it the same. Your schematic calls it a extractor stud and 2152HQ calls it something else, but we are talking about the thing that limits the rearward travel of the cylinder. The point of measuring the gap when the cylinder is open is he furthest back the cylinder can travel. It the gap when the gun is closed is less than when it is open, the cylinder should not be able to contact the tabs, BUT it is somehow doing that very thing??

For some reason, it looks like the area around the center hole is chewed up? I wonder if the pin or stud is not seating all the way in and might be resting on the edge of the hole until shot? This is a true mystery still.
__________________
Gary
SWCA 2515

Last edited by glowe; 08-17-2018 at 09:13 AM. Reason: Added content
Reply With Quote
  #25  
Old 08-16-2018, 10:18 PM
Hearsedriver's Avatar
Hearsedriver Hearsedriver is offline
Member
Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch  
Join Date: Oct 2011
Location: Ft.Worth
Posts: 563
Likes: 29
Liked 106 Times in 56 Posts
Default

I wonder if I could just take about .005" off of the back of those cylinder catch tabs and call it good? Maybe rounding the edges a little to cut down on the damage to the cylinder? I posted this question to other owners of these guns at the SASS forum and they responded that they are seeing the same thing on thier Schofield 2000's with higher round counts.
__________________
Cliff
Reply With Quote
  #26  
Old 08-18-2018, 11:39 AM
Hearsedriver's Avatar
Hearsedriver Hearsedriver is offline
Member
Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch  
Join Date: Oct 2011
Location: Ft.Worth
Posts: 563
Likes: 29
Liked 106 Times in 56 Posts
Default

And of course, S&W sent me the wrong part. A cylinder stop instead of the cylinder catch that I need. Nothing is easy........
__________________
Cliff
Reply With Quote
  #27  
Old 08-24-2018, 07:27 PM
WR Moore WR Moore is offline
Member
 
Join Date: Oct 2006
Posts: 6,579
Likes: 1,787
Liked 5,342 Times in 2,685 Posts
Default

Rather than bashing yourself, why not dump the problem on S&W and let them fix it?
Reply With Quote
  #28  
Old 12-01-2018, 10:19 AM
mrdix mrdix is offline
Member
Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch Schofield 2000 Top-Break Problem with Cylinder Hitting Cylinder Catch  
Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: Tully New York
Posts: 13
Likes: 0
Liked 2 Times in 2 Posts
Default

I had a Smith & Wesson schofield that did the same thing ! 2 trips back to smith and I sold the gun for an Uberti, I agree this issue happens when the gun in fired not when you eject the cartridges , the marks on the cylinder are perfectly lined up when the cylinder in inline with the barrel .
Reply With Quote
Reply

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
Forum Jump

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Schofield barrel latch problem....Help! fortyshooter S&W Antiques 13 08-01-2017 10:31 AM
Rear sight blade problem-IGNORE, Problem Solved dnonac S&W-Smithing 0 05-09-2013 08:55 AM
Schofield 2000 Monticello Marshal S&W Revolvers: 1980 to the Present 2 01-31-2013 12:44 PM
SPF: Schofield 2000 PackN GUNS - For Sale or Trade 1 02-14-2010 11:34 PM

Powered by vBadvanced CMPS v3.2.3
smith-wessonforum.com tested by Norton Internet Security smith-wessonforum.com tested by McAfee Internet Security

All times are GMT -4. The time now is 04:28 AM.


Smith-WessonForum.com is not affiliated with Smith & Wesson Holding Corporation (NASDAQ Global Select: SWHC)