Well, not really tool-less...it takes a piece of cotton t-shirt.

After replacing several marred rods, and unhappy with even the tools designed for such an operation, Bubba whispered into my ear.

First, while supervised, I insert 6 empties into the cylinder and grip thusly:







Then, the cotton fabric is carefully and tightly wound around end of rod in the direction of loosening the rod - righty-loosey



Then another couple of wraps are taken, snug but not too tightly.


The material is wound on until it’s about 1.5 inches thick. Feel free to use a bit more, if extra diameter and leverage are required.


Continue to slowly turn, and you’ll feel the fabric tighten up around the shaft. Keep turning, and you’ll feel the slight ‘pop’ as the ejector rod breaks free.


To reinstall, start the threads by hand, and wind in opposite direction until fabric tightens up, then a bit more.



I haven’t had one come loose yet, and I’ve unstuck some rather recalcitrant rods with this method. I feel that with the crane installed, there’s little damage that can occur from my ham-handedness.


Any comments or cautions welcome.

__________________
- Post No Bills -

Interesting.

I've heard of wrapping the rod in leather then using pliers, but that method never worked for me.

I've successfully used the Brownell's extractor rod tool. It's the only method I've used that worked for me.

Kinda' like a homemade strap wrench.

__________________
SWHF #595

Pretty much.


I had one that was ON there, and it took a little bit larger piece of material - but it gave way.

The small part that’s touching the knurled area will get chewed up. Cut it off and use the material again and again.

The trick is to get it tight for the first 2-3 wraps, then layer evenly. It will come tight as you twist.

__________________
- Post No Bills -

I’ve got the Brownell’s tool and it has worked for me but it wouldn’t tighten enough to work on a J-frame 317. This is extremely slick and it makes me want to try it. I have no plans to get a cat though.

I have a Power Custom tool but if ever in a situation where I don't have it handy, I will definitely try your method. Very cool and innovative!