Jayhawkhuntclub
Member
- Joined
- Oct 10, 2011
- Messages
- 740
- Reaction score
- 318
Took Smith and Wesson out yesterday afternoon.
Reliability: A
The thing was pretty impressive. We fired somewhere between 200 and 250 shots (cheap ammo by Win and Fed bulk packs). I had one FTFeed and everything else was perfect. Considering the variability of 22 ammo, particularly cheap bulk ammo, the grade maybe should be an A+.
Speed and smoothness: A+
We did some speed testing (had to have some fun) and I was amazed. My son shot 25 rounds and I timed it at 4.35 seconds. But It was much closer to 4.0 seconds as I wasn't as quick as I should have been on the button. My son clocked me shooting 25 rounds in 3.5 seconds. That's 7 shots a second! It doesn't seem possible. I would have never believed my finger could move that fast, let alone the gun. If I read this I would probably be thinking "BS". But I can't call BS on myself.
BTW, our 1 FTF was during a rapid fire sequence attempt.
Accuracy: Incomplete
Accuracy was so so, but that may have been because my rear scope mount was completely lose and I had no allen wrench. Anyhow it averaged 1.028" 5 shot groups at 25 yards with cheap bulk ammo. The best group was 0.32". The worst group was 1.95" (ouch). It was also a bit windy and that didn't help.
Even so I don't think this accuracy is horrible and was not far from what I expected. I have to think that with better conditions, decent ammo, two functioning scope rings and some trigger work, this thing could be a 2 or 3 moa gun. But right now, if I was forced to give it a grade, I'd say C+.
Trigger: D+
The only drawback to the M&P15-22 I have found is that the trigger is terrible (that didn't help the accuracy either). It is 5.75 lbs and has a ton of creep. On the plus side this is curable. I am spoiled as almost every trigger I own is either perfect or near perfect. Only one of them came that way from the factory.
Fit and finish: A
Not perfection, but very nice.
Feel: A+
The M&P15-22 is nice and rigid and has good heft. I was concerned that a "plastic" gun would have noticable flex. It does not. And the weight is perfect. It's a bit lighter than most AR15s, but heavy enough to feel like a real gun. Being a bit lighter is a plus for kids.
I was hesitant to buy this gun considering the serious issues some of the early guns had. But based on what I've seen so far, it appears they've got things worked out. My gun is a late model: DWTxxxx.
The bottom line:
Reliability: A
The thing was pretty impressive. We fired somewhere between 200 and 250 shots (cheap ammo by Win and Fed bulk packs). I had one FTFeed and everything else was perfect. Considering the variability of 22 ammo, particularly cheap bulk ammo, the grade maybe should be an A+.
Speed and smoothness: A+
We did some speed testing (had to have some fun) and I was amazed. My son shot 25 rounds and I timed it at 4.35 seconds. But It was much closer to 4.0 seconds as I wasn't as quick as I should have been on the button. My son clocked me shooting 25 rounds in 3.5 seconds. That's 7 shots a second! It doesn't seem possible. I would have never believed my finger could move that fast, let alone the gun. If I read this I would probably be thinking "BS". But I can't call BS on myself.

Accuracy: Incomplete
Accuracy was so so, but that may have been because my rear scope mount was completely lose and I had no allen wrench. Anyhow it averaged 1.028" 5 shot groups at 25 yards with cheap bulk ammo. The best group was 0.32". The worst group was 1.95" (ouch). It was also a bit windy and that didn't help.
Even so I don't think this accuracy is horrible and was not far from what I expected. I have to think that with better conditions, decent ammo, two functioning scope rings and some trigger work, this thing could be a 2 or 3 moa gun. But right now, if I was forced to give it a grade, I'd say C+.
Trigger: D+
The only drawback to the M&P15-22 I have found is that the trigger is terrible (that didn't help the accuracy either). It is 5.75 lbs and has a ton of creep. On the plus side this is curable. I am spoiled as almost every trigger I own is either perfect or near perfect. Only one of them came that way from the factory.
Fit and finish: A
Not perfection, but very nice.
Feel: A+
The M&P15-22 is nice and rigid and has good heft. I was concerned that a "plastic" gun would have noticable flex. It does not. And the weight is perfect. It's a bit lighter than most AR15s, but heavy enough to feel like a real gun. Being a bit lighter is a plus for kids.
I was hesitant to buy this gun considering the serious issues some of the early guns had. But based on what I've seen so far, it appears they've got things worked out. My gun is a late model: DWTxxxx.
The bottom line:
