|
|
10-06-2015, 11:31 AM
|
Member
|
|
|
Join Date: Oct 2015
Posts: 7
Likes: 0
Liked 0 Times in 0 Posts
|
|
Melonite, is it really better than chrome lined?
Anyone having issues with their melonite barrels? I've had my sport model for about 2 1/2 years and it's getting rust in the Bohr. It is cleaned and maintained regularly and is the only gun in the safe that has this issue. I read the reviews that state melonite is better for various reasons, but I've never seen chrome lined barrel's rust this easy. I've been in the service for seven years and seen some pretty abused weapons. Did I just get a bad one? Is anyone else having this issues?
|
10-06-2015, 11:55 AM
|
US Veteran
|
|
|
Join Date: Feb 2012
Location: Wylie, TX
Posts: 4,670
Likes: 1,075
Liked 3,823 Times in 2,040 Posts
|
|
If you have rust, something is wrong... my Sport is fairly well neglected, as in cleaned when the action becomes gritty or accuracy is affected. I don't have any rust.
|
10-06-2015, 12:02 PM
|
Member
|
|
|
Join Date: Oct 2015
Posts: 7
Likes: 0
Liked 0 Times in 0 Posts
|
|
Something wrong as in a defect in the melonite process?
|
10-06-2015, 12:20 PM
|
|
Member
|
|
|
Join Date: May 2012
Location: Concord,NC
Posts: 1,072
Likes: 468
Liked 480 Times in 275 Posts
|
|
lifetime warranty. Call S&W.
|
The Following User Likes This Post:
|
|
10-06-2015, 12:50 PM
|
|
Member
|
|
|
Join Date: Oct 2014
Location: South of Rochester , NY
Posts: 1,229
Likes: 77
Liked 1,342 Times in 559 Posts
|
|
What kind of ammo are you using ?
__________________
1st smiles,lies.Last,gunfire.
|
10-06-2015, 12:58 PM
|
Member
|
|
|
Join Date: Jan 2012
Location: Outside Philadelphia Pa
Posts: 16,601
Likes: 7,342
Liked 17,200 Times in 7,303 Posts
|
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by F75gunslinger
What kind of ammo are you using ?
|
I'm thinking the same thing even though there is no corrosive 5.56
|
10-06-2015, 01:05 PM
|
|
Member
|
|
|
Join Date: Nov 2011
Location: Baton Rouge, La.
Posts: 6,874
Likes: 7,481
Liked 8,135 Times in 3,678 Posts
|
|
What are you cleaning and maintaining it with. I'm taking maintaining as what you coat the bore with before it goes in the safe, then it will sit there and start rusting ? How long does it take for the rust to show up.
Things like WD40 will evaporate and are not proper for storage.
Gary
|
10-06-2015, 02:52 PM
|
US Veteran
|
|
|
Join Date: Feb 2012
Location: Wylie, TX
Posts: 4,670
Likes: 1,075
Liked 3,823 Times in 2,040 Posts
|
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by JdubHardin
Something wrong as in a defect in the melonite process?
|
Possibly, or something wrong with what you are using to clean the rifle... as others have asked, what ammo are you shooting, what are you using to clean, what are you using when storing, etc.?
|
10-06-2015, 02:57 PM
|
Member
|
|
|
Join Date: Oct 2015
Posts: 7
Likes: 0
Liked 0 Times in 0 Posts
|
|
I'm using Federal XM193 ammo and I use M-Pro 7 cleaner and M-Pro 7 gun oil. Last time I had it out was mid August I brought it out last night for routine wipe down that's when I noticed it. It was cleaned prior to going into the safe in August. The safe has a knock off golden rod to prevent corrosion. The bore itself looks fine as best as I can tell. The problem area is the chamber, where the case sits when the bolt is locked in.
|
10-06-2015, 03:03 PM
|
Member
|
|
|
Join Date: Oct 2015
Posts: 7
Likes: 0
Liked 0 Times in 0 Posts
|
|
It's oiled with a light coat of the M-Pro 7 prior to storage
|
10-06-2015, 06:00 PM
|
|
Member
|
|
|
Join Date: May 2012
Location: Concord,NC
Posts: 1,072
Likes: 468
Liked 480 Times in 275 Posts
|
|
Are you sure its rust? How about posting pictures? I've used M-Pro 7 for a few years now with no issues.
|
The Following User Likes This Post:
|
|
10-06-2015, 07:06 PM
|
|
Member
|
|
|
Join Date: Dec 2011
Location: So Cal (Near Edwards AFB)
Posts: 14,710
Likes: 2,926
Liked 17,102 Times in 6,271 Posts
|
|
Melonite is a treatment to the outside, not the bore.
__________________
Freedom isn't free.
|
10-06-2015, 07:54 PM
|
Member
|
|
|
Join Date: Aug 2015
Location: East Texas
Posts: 149
Likes: 47
Liked 91 Times in 54 Posts
|
|
Yeah!
They do apply it inside and out. Their claim is that it extends barrel life quite a bit. It's not as rust proof but if your sure your getting rust just use a different oil before storage. I use one of the knock off golden rod's as well and I keep Damp Rid in it also.
|
The Following User Likes This Post:
|
|
10-06-2015, 09:06 PM
|
|
Member
|
|
|
Join Date: Mar 2014
Location: New Hampshire
Posts: 2,847
Likes: 8,671
Liked 3,497 Times in 1,342 Posts
|
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by Rastoff
Melonite is a treatment to the outside, not the bore.
|
Melonite is a heat treat process,entire barrel, including the bore.
The barrels are cut and rifled before the process. The dimensions do not change during the acid dip heat treat process. It is not a coating.
What is does do is produce a super smooth molecular change. The magnified images I have seen show a remarkable finished product.
It does resist corrosion very well and holds up well under abuse.
Jim
Last edited by jimbo728; 10-06-2015 at 09:16 PM.
|
The Following 6 Users Like Post:
|
|
10-06-2015, 09:22 PM
|
|
Member
|
|
|
Join Date: Dec 2011
Location: So Cal (Near Edwards AFB)
Posts: 14,710
Likes: 2,926
Liked 17,102 Times in 6,271 Posts
|
|
I stand corrected. I knew it was a treatment and not a coating. Still, I thought it was only applied to the outside.
Learn something new every day.
__________________
Freedom isn't free.
|
The Following 2 Users Like Post:
|
|
10-06-2015, 09:47 PM
|
|
Member
|
|
|
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: Oro Valley, Arizona
Posts: 2,370
Likes: 497
Liked 943 Times in 518 Posts
|
|
I'm not familiar with MP7. Does it contain any ammonia?
You are not supposed to use an ammonia based cleaners (such as as Sweet's) with Melonite barrels, according to S&W.
|
10-06-2015, 10:41 PM
|
|
Member
|
|
|
Join Date: Mar 2014
Location: New Hampshire
Posts: 2,847
Likes: 8,671
Liked 3,497 Times in 1,342 Posts
|
|
Rastoff, It does get confusing. What makes it even more confusing is that S&W cant call it Melonite anymore although the early Sports clearly were. Now its called, as Im sure you already know, it is called "salt nitride process". Same process without legal infringements
of the Melonite label.
Jim
|
The Following User Likes This Post:
|
|
10-07-2015, 12:34 PM
|
Member
|
|
|
Join Date: Oct 2015
Posts: 7
Likes: 0
Liked 0 Times in 0 Posts
|
|
Here's the pics, keep in mind I wiped it down as soon as I noticed it.
|
10-07-2015, 12:42 PM
|
|
Member
|
|
|
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: Oro Valley, Arizona
Posts: 2,370
Likes: 497
Liked 943 Times in 518 Posts
|
|
I think we might be looking at copper residue, not rust.
|
The Following 3 Users Like Post:
|
|
10-07-2015, 02:42 PM
|
|
Member
|
|
|
Join Date: Mar 2014
Location: New Hampshire
Posts: 2,847
Likes: 8,671
Liked 3,497 Times in 1,342 Posts
|
|
Copper or brass, not rust.
Jim
|
The Following User Likes This Post:
|
|
10-07-2015, 03:19 PM
|
|
Member
|
|
|
Join Date: May 2012
Location: Concord,NC
Posts: 1,072
Likes: 468
Liked 480 Times in 275 Posts
|
|
^^^^^^ What jimbo & andy said. Use Hoppe's #9 with a soaked patch.
Last edited by AR-Getsome; 10-07-2015 at 03:21 PM.
|
10-07-2015, 09:51 PM
|
|
US Veteran
|
|
|
Join Date: Jan 2014
Location: Aliquippa, PA
Posts: 1,400
Likes: 351
Liked 714 Times in 476 Posts
|
|
Hoppe's #9 is all I use on all my firearms. Cleans everything that shouldn't be there right off. Then Rem Oil for the protection coating.
|
The Following User Likes This Post:
|
|
10-11-2015, 09:30 AM
|
Member
|
|
|
Join Date: Feb 2012
Posts: 93
Likes: 9
Liked 29 Times in 24 Posts
|
|
I have a buddy that works in the industry and swears by melonite. When I got my M&P Sport I used it for a year, including a one day class, without cleaning it. I only applied TW25b to lube the bolt and charging handle. No malfunctions and no rust. When I did clean it, finally, it was fairly easy and looks brand new and still shot great, in fact it holds better groups than my duty rifle which is high grade mil spec. This was my own little test to see if I really needed the forward assist. I'm sold on melonite plus, as was said in my M4 armorer class, we tend to do too much cleaning with the ar15 rifles.
|
The Following 3 Users Like Post:
|
|
10-11-2015, 11:11 AM
|
|
Member
|
|
|
Join Date: Dec 2011
Location: So Cal (Near Edwards AFB)
Posts: 14,710
Likes: 2,926
Liked 17,102 Times in 6,271 Posts
|
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by Granite Stater
...high grade mil spec.
|
That's just funny right there.
__________________
Freedom isn't free.
|
10-11-2015, 11:22 AM
|
Member
|
|
|
Join Date: Feb 2012
Posts: 93
Likes: 9
Liked 29 Times in 24 Posts
|
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by Rastoff
That's just funny right there.
|
Ok, I should have said high priced mil spec rifle. We have since gone to Windham Weaponry and I couldn't be happier. The Town next to us just bought shorty Colts and I'm shaking my head at how much they paid and what they got in return. I'll still put my M&P Sport up against anyone of them.
|
The Following 2 Users Like Post:
|
|
10-11-2015, 11:39 AM
|
|
Member
|
|
|
Join Date: Dec 2011
Location: So Cal (Near Edwards AFB)
Posts: 14,710
Likes: 2,926
Liked 17,102 Times in 6,271 Posts
|
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by Granite Stater
Ok, I should have said high priced mil spec rifle.
|
Now that I can agree with. After working for the Air Force for more than 30 years, I question any mil spec being "high quality". Don't get me wrong, our military has some great stuff. It's just that much of it is over priced and not as good as it should be.
The AR design is such that, even mass produced, it is still a pretty good gun.
__________________
Freedom isn't free.
|
The Following User Likes This Post:
|
|
10-11-2015, 04:51 PM
|
Member
|
|
|
Join Date: Mar 2012
Posts: 188
Likes: 120
Liked 68 Times in 45 Posts
|
|
When I see arguments of mil spec., I think mil spec Hummer H1 and civilian Hummer H1 and all points for each are valid without proving one totally superior over the other.
|
10-11-2015, 05:54 PM
|
|
Member
|
|
|
Join Date: Dec 2011
Location: So Cal (Near Edwards AFB)
Posts: 14,710
Likes: 2,926
Liked 17,102 Times in 6,271 Posts
|
|
Oh, that's easy; civ H1 is better. It has air conditioning.
__________________
Freedom isn't free.
|
The Following 3 Users Like Post:
|
|
10-12-2015, 12:27 PM
|
Member
|
|
|
Join Date: Oct 2015
Posts: 7
Likes: 0
Liked 0 Times in 0 Posts
|
|
Well I finally got the time to run some hoppes run through it and there is no change. I took a close look and it almost seems that the problem area has etched (for lack of better word) it self into the finish. I'm gonna give S&w a call and ask them what they think.
|
10-12-2015, 03:28 PM
|
|
Member
|
|
|
Join Date: Oct 2009
Posts: 14,661
Likes: 7,937
Liked 20,623 Times in 5,958 Posts
|
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by Granite Stater
Ok, I should have said high priced mil spec rifle. We have since gone to Windham Weaponry and I couldn't be happier. The Town next to us just bought shorty Colts and I'm shaking my head at how much they paid and what they got in return. I'll still put my M&P Sport up against anyone of them.
|
Windham is very good. Operated by the Bushmaster boys from years past before it sold off to Cerberus and then rifles made at a Remington plant. I have one of their rifles from the 90s. Good rifle. According to Yankee Hill Machine, they used to supply parts to Bushmaster back then. I own a Yankee Hill AR too. Small AR world...
As far as milspec... eh... each part or system must be measured on it's own merit for comparison. My Wilson Combat trigger isn't milspec. That's why I bought it.
|
10-12-2015, 05:04 PM
|
|
Member
|
|
|
Join Date: Sep 2015
Location: Penn's Woods
Posts: 212
Likes: 64
Liked 263 Times in 105 Posts
|
|
Put a little Flitz Paste Metal Polish on a cotton patch. Wrap the patch around either a chamber, or a larger caliber bore brush. Scrub the chamber for a minute, or two. Followup with clean patches.
If you elect to do so you can, then, remove the Carnauba wax left behind by the Flitz polish with several cotton patches soaked in isopropyl alcohol. Again followup with dry patches.
If the gun is going to be stored for awhile I'll coat the bore with Sentry Solutions, ' Tuf-Glide'. If I'm going to be using the gun, again, within the next several months then I use Sentry Solutions, ' Smooth-Kote' *.
I treat all my guns this way. The exteriors are wiped down with either FrogLube, or Ray's Gun Wax (Which is a local legend!) Both FL and Ray's are utterly impervious to water and will stay on the gun for a long long time - Years, in fact; and, although I've heard a lot of good things about, ' Renaissance Wax', I've personally never found anything better for the longterm storage of, 'safe queens'.)
* Bullets hit harder, and barrel cleanup is a breeze! Wear Nitrile or latex gloves whenever you clean a gun; and keep any modern high tech lubricant like Smooth-Kote away from your bare skin. These lubricants belong INSIDE, and not outside the gun - OK.
Last edited by Arc Angel; 10-12-2015 at 05:10 PM.
|
03-24-2017, 07:15 PM
|
Member
|
|
|
Join Date: May 2014
Posts: 47
Likes: 44
Liked 12 Times in 7 Posts
|
|
Here's my thoughts on ferritic nitrocarburizing vs. chrome lining in general, as I have recently changed my mind about it.
I think nitrocarburizing is a cost savings measure. I think it's durable and I believe it's easier (cheaper) to make accurate, but I DO NOT believe it's as good as the best chrome lined barrels. That's just my opinion, but this is what I base it on.
I started thinking about it recently when Iraqveteran8888 did his AR-15 meltdown video shooting 830 rounds full-auto. Originally he thought it was a squib, but it ended up merely being that the barrel failed Most of us aren't going to do that and risk blowing a barrel shooting that many rounds that quickly, but it reminds me of why our military uses FN's machinegun barrels which are some proprietary steel blend similar to 4150 that is double thick CHROME LINED. The barrels are very accurate as well. Are they stainless steel accurate? Probably not, but stainless is also more malleable than machine gun/4150 cmv steel.
Ferritic nitrocarburizing is also something like a hundred years old. Although it's been becoming more popular in the firearms industry recently, it's been used in toolmaking even before the military started using chrome lined barrels. If the military thought nitriding and similar processes were superior, they would have been using them. The way I see it it's about spending the time it takes to ensure a CHF 4150 or better steel that is chrome lined is accurate, and that takes processes and quality control efforts that are expensive. Remember when S&W first started using the melonite in their rifles? They were NOT using them for their more expensive guns, they were merely using it in their cheapest sport rifle before they realized it was becoming so popular so they dumped the melonite and 5r riflings in the original sport and started using them in their more expensive rifles.
It's true that nitrocarburizing hardens the surface to a higher extent than 4150 alone or chrome lining, but harder also means more brittle. It's also a very thin barrier of protection; much thinner than quality chrome lining (i.e. FN).
I have a FN CHF chrome lined barrel in my go to rifle. It is very accurate and I feel it's better protection against squibs and overheated barrels either or both came into play. I don't plan on doing any kind of shooting to overheat a barrel like in the video, but I could have a squib after getting the barrel very hot. I don't plan on driving my car over 100 mph either, but I like to know I have the power to do so if need be. The military could have chosen to use nitrocarburization process, but they didn't. I know they cut corners, but I doubt that's one of them.
I'm not an expert, so I am open to other opinions on the subject, but that's what it looks like to me. Never underestimate the profit motives.
|
03-24-2017, 07:23 PM
|
|
Member
|
|
|
Join Date: Mar 2014
Location: New Hampshire
Posts: 2,847
Likes: 8,671
Liked 3,497 Times in 1,342 Posts
|
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by Rastoff
Melonite is a treatment to the outside, not the bore.
|
Actually the Melonite process treats the entire barrel after rifleing is complete.
Jim
|
03-25-2017, 08:02 PM
|
|
Member
|
|
|
Join Date: Jun 2012
Location: Northern, MO
Posts: 203
Likes: 215
Liked 88 Times in 59 Posts
|
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by Rastoff
Melonite is a treatment to the outside, not the bore.
|
I thought the Melonite treatment was done after the rifling was cut.
__________________
NRA member since 1974
|
03-25-2017, 08:40 PM
|
Member
|
|
|
Join Date: May 2016
Posts: 165
Likes: 683
Liked 125 Times in 67 Posts
|
|
The melonite finish is so great you could store a barrel submerged in cat urine and it would be just like new after 40 years.
|
03-25-2017, 09:29 PM
|
|
Member
|
|
|
Join Date: Dec 2014
Posts: 654
Likes: 728
Liked 648 Times in 281 Posts
|
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by vortex360
The melonite finish is so great you could store a barrel submerged in cat urine and it would be just like new after 40 years.
|
I bet it would smell terrible as soon as you got the barrel hot!!
|
03-26-2017, 02:07 AM
|
Member
|
|
|
Join Date: Jan 2017
Location: Lousiana
Posts: 180
Likes: 107
Liked 238 Times in 74 Posts
|
|
Melonite..is decent...but ONLY if you are buying QUALITY barrels.
A $80 melonite barrel will most likely be ****...because the manufacturer doesnt prep the barrel 100% before its treated...so any problems with the barrel, will now be there forever.
|
03-26-2017, 02:49 AM
|
|
Member
|
|
|
Join Date: Jul 2016
Location: Sacratomato
Posts: 445
Likes: 65
Liked 440 Times in 206 Posts
|
|
You can make the same argument about CHF or stainless. Bad mandrel or improper stress relief on the chf, and you have a bad barrel. With chrome lining, any flaw in the bore still exists after the chrome plating. So, it all depends on who makes the barrel, and how good their QC is.
__________________
Peace was my Profession
Last edited by Westie1; 03-26-2017 at 03:17 AM.
|
03-26-2017, 09:37 AM
|
|
US Veteran
|
|
|
Join Date: Sep 2011
Location: houston,texas
Posts: 7,198
Likes: 124,841
Liked 23,177 Times in 5,749 Posts
|
|
wish there was a definitive answer as to the quality of a given barrel. I don't think price is a good indicator but it is about all the average shooter has to go on along with the reputation of the maker. Just have to buy one and shoot it!
__________________
Hue 68 noli me tangere
|
The Following 2 Users Like Post:
|
|
03-26-2017, 11:14 AM
|
|
Member
|
|
|
Join Date: Apr 2005
Location: Birmingham AL
Posts: 578
Likes: 358
Liked 273 Times in 156 Posts
|
|
Did anybody watch the video I posted just a couple of days ago where this was discussed by a rep from a company that uses BOTH processes?
Nitride or Chrome: Q&A with Faxon Rep
__________________
Registration? NEVER!
Last edited by shep854; 03-26-2017 at 11:15 AM.
|
The Following 2 Users Like Post:
|
|
03-26-2017, 12:57 PM
|
|
US Veteran
|
|
|
Join Date: Sep 2011
Location: houston,texas
Posts: 7,198
Likes: 124,841
Liked 23,177 Times in 5,749 Posts
|
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by shep854
|
Watched it and appreciated the post,may indeed use one of their barrels because of it. I was familiar with the processes but you can always learn more. I am especially interested in the skinny barrels they produce as I never experienced any problems with A1 barrels but the heavier bullets used today increase the useable range and need a faster twist rate. Thanks for your post.
__________________
Hue 68 noli me tangere
|
The Following User Likes This Post:
|
|
03-26-2017, 01:16 PM
|
|
Member
|
|
|
Join Date: Apr 2005
Location: Birmingham AL
Posts: 578
Likes: 358
Liked 273 Times in 156 Posts
|
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by vonn
Watched it and appreciated the post,may indeed use one of their barrels because of it. I was familiar with the processes but you can always learn more. I am especially interested in the skinny barrels they produce as I never experienced any problems with A1 barrels but the heavier bullets used today increase the useable range and need a faster twist rate. Thanks for your post.
|
Yes, indeed! There are always new applications and refinements coming out. From what I had seen, the two processes were pretty much interchangeable, but the video showed how, for certain purposes, one seems to be better than the other.
__________________
Registration? NEVER!
|
The Following User Likes This Post:
|
|
03-26-2017, 04:20 PM
|
|
Member
|
|
|
Join Date: Nov 2016
Location: South Texas
Posts: 329
Likes: 228
Liked 394 Times in 173 Posts
|
|
It's gotta be better than the Ruger process of just anodizing the barrel on their budget ARs. The key word here is "budget". S&W does use chrome in other locations.
I'm hoping to pick up my first Sport II at a gun show next weekend so I wish you guys would stop talking it down.
|
The Following User Likes This Post:
|
|
03-26-2017, 04:52 PM
|
|
Member
|
|
|
Join Date: Apr 2005
Location: Birmingham AL
Posts: 578
Likes: 358
Liked 273 Times in 156 Posts
|
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by Tinhack
It's gotta be better than the Ruger process of just anodizing the barrel on their budget ARs. The key word here is "budget". S&W does use chrome in other locations.
I'm hoping to pick up my first Sport II at a gun show next weekend so I wish you guys would stop talking it down.
|
I'm completely pleased with mine.
__________________
Registration? NEVER!
|
The Following 2 Users Like Post:
|
|
|
Posting Rules
|
|
|
|
|