Should I trade?

[Ironbutt1345]

I have a Model 915 that I absolutely love. I love it so much in fact, that I'm thinking of trading my Sig P250 for another 3rd Gen S&W. The Sig has 2 barrels, one in .40 S&W and one in .357 Sig., 3 13 round mags, nice plastic case and original docs. I like the Model 4566, or maybe another full size 3rd Gen in 9mm. I guess my question is, should I trade the Sig or keep it? if I do trade it, what should I ask for in trade? What would the trade value be? My P250 is in excellent shape btw. Any assistance would be greatly appreciated. So far I am really liking the 3rd Gen koolaid! Just as a point of reference, I traded a 4th Gen Glock 22 for the Sig.

[k22fan]

Since you “realize that any answers would only be opinions/conjecture” you know how to interpret mine.

I’ll guess 4th gen Glocks run around $450 used. Using that as the value of your Sig you can probably trade straight across into a nice 3rd gen 9mm but you’d have to sweeten the deal to get a .45 or 10 mm in excellent condition . It hasn’t been too long since police surplus 4566s have been on the market so you might be able to trade straight across for one of those if you don’t mind it being a little scuffed up. Since you’ve already got a 9mm if you’re a reloader I’d go for a larger cartridge.

[Ironbutt1345]

Ok thank you, that's the kind of info I need to help make my decision.