I am downsizing my PC Semi-auto collection and need opinions on the ultimate four to keep. That does not mean that I will keep only these four but to ensure that I don't sell it. I am using the term "Ultimate Four" to determine the best pistol for each of the following categories: Bullseye, Practical/Duty, Home Defense, and Concealed Carry. So, please give me your opinion of the best one for each category. I will keep the tally updated in the original post. Thanks

Current Leaders thru Post #15


Bullseye-----------945 & PPC9 tied at (3) each

Practical/Duty-----45 CQB & IDPA 9 tied at (2) each

Home Defense----45 CQB (4)

Concealed Carry--Shorty 45 (3)

Caliber wise, the 45 ACP is way out front.

Keep them coming.

Here goes:
Bullseye--- 952
Practical / duty--- shorty 45
HD-- 1911
Concealed Carry--- Recon 9

I only need two to cover those applications. A full size 945 and one of the compact 945's. I guess I am just partial to 45 cal.
Bob Ray 1815

bullseye= model 41

Bullseye - PPC-9

Pract/duty/hd - two of whichever PC service size auto you want

CCW - a smaller version of the above, but I really want a J frame for a second pistol to the above daily carry pistols.

__________________
July 4, 1776 not Jan 30, 1909

The only models considered for this thread are PC semi-autos. Thanks

Guess I'm all set there... I got em both. I was kinda thinking my PC Bone Collector Model 500... might work too... oh... it's not a semi..

__________________
Jack C

B/E PPC9 6"

Duty/Home CQB
Conceal Shorty45

if you feel like Nina

DPA5906
Shorty9

__________________
if you're gonna be a bear...

Bullseye = 945
Practical/Duty = 1911
Home Defense = CQB45
CCW = 3" 1911
...and they're all the same caliber for simplicity!

WOW, the darts are flying all over the board. My Excel spreadsheet looks like it was hit with a 12 gauge shot of #9 at 30 yards. Keep the choices coming. You can be specific within models/calibers by using barrel length or markings on the pistol such as PPC, CQB, Recon, SD, etc. No clear winners yet, but the overall current leader is the 945, followed by the CQB, 1911, 9 Recon and Shorty 45 in a close bunch.

Bullseye - 845

Duty & Home defense - 45 CQB

CCW - Shorty 45

Regards 18DAI

What NO 10mm's, You had better confront S&W to make us a Performance Center 10mm to add to your collection and mine!

Good luck narrowing things down!

If I could get the PC to make one, I would. I made the request and it was rejected. I also tried to get Paul Liebenberg, the former head of the PC, to modify one to PC specs but it was not practical. A PC starts from scratch and incorporates the special features of the Briley bushing, front cocking serrations, PC slide to frame fit, match barrel, and tuned trigger. All machining is done prior to hardening the slide and frame.

When we are finished selecting the PC Semi-autos in this thread, then I plan to start a new thread to select the favorite 3rd Gen pistol for each category. I expect the 10MMs will be very popular in that one.

BE = PPC9
Duty/HD= CQB or DPA
CC= Shorty45

__________________
PC semiauto collector

It all depends on what caliber you are interested in. If you like .40S&W, this one is a good option:


Add a Shorty 40 for CC and a M41 .22lr for target and you are set.

__________________
My sgntr is mor thn 30 chrctrs

The first tally is through post #15.