I have been debating trading my Shield 1.0 with Apex trigger, and 5 magazines in towards a Shield plus.

I looked that Shield plus and the Ruger Max 9, and I thought I would like the Max 9 better, but the Shield felt better in my hand, and I think has a better trigger, even though the Ruger has better sights and an optics mount…

I know I’ve discussed this before, I’m not one to swap to a new gun just because it’s new, I really like my shield, and would have to buy new holster, extra mags etc…

Just curious is there anyone who has done this trade-up yet? Was it worth the effort? Is the Shield plus that much better?
If I do decide to go ahead with the trade-up, I will probably wait till prices drop a little (if they do) .

Two things: Shield+ with 3.1" barrel now comes cut for optic, and the 3.1" has always fit your old Shield 1.0/2.0 holster.

I sold both my 1.0 and 2.0 and put that new + right in the same holster!

Based on the holster fit alone (assuming that's 100% true, I've seen plenty of guns advertised with "holster compatable with ____" that werent) the shield plus is probably what you want. Failing that, I'd look at the P365 or P365XL, easily my favorite of the options.

I’d check gunbroker for a shield+ stripped frame about two weeks ago there were 1-2 sellers listing frames stating they were compatible with 1.0 and 2.0 parts/slides. Not sure if that is true or not! They were listed for $125 each. Would be an easy way to put your current investment to work without taking a hit at the counter of your LGS. You’d need to buy magazines though!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

I thought about it but decided to keep my 2.0. My 2.0 works perfect and has never choked. Accuracy is great and I already have 4 magazines. A few extra rounds equates to more weight also.

I’m very happy with my 2.0 and have no intention of changing.

P365 is indicated.

You will take a financial hit.

__________________
Made it, Ma! Top of the world!

I have a 1.0 to which I have added night sights and an Apex trigger kit. I also have 8 mags for it.I would love a new PLUS but would take such a beating on the 1.0 that I will have to be buried with it!

I opted for the Performance Center version with the longer barrel and fiber optic sights. IMO it's a huge improvement over the original Shield. Carried in an IWB holster this has been my daily carry pistol all summer. If you opt for a Shield Plus you won't regret it.

Attached Images

	5736ADB4-7DCA-43F9-9A02-72491612D899.jpg (46.1 KB, 29 views)
	B89C37F9-905A-4C1B-B792-73FD2569682F.jpg (50.0 KB, 25 views)
	F84443C7-905F-4FF7-BFD1-B5B446B3ABE0.jpg (42.3 KB, 21 views)
	E0352971-DD46-4B66-A949-097580FDD868.jpg (45.7 KB, 23 views)
	96D8EB18-44EF-4845-AC5B-10087D291BC2.jpg (61.5 KB, 21 views)

Yeah I’m kind of in the same boat- maybe I’ll get better sights for my 1.0 and a flat trigger and call it a day.

This is one of the things that keeps our hobby moving forward and our bank accounts lean, innovation!!!

If other brands are in consideration, you really should look at the Sig P365XL or P365X.

The minute I shot one, my Shield was on its way out the door.

The XL especially is truly excellent

I have both a Shield 1.0 with Apex trigger and a Shield +. I truly cannot tell the difference between the triggers when shooting. The plus feels a little better in my hand with the slightly wider grip and the extra mag capacity is nice but not worth the price difference. I have also owned a 365 but gave it to my son. I shoot the Shield better so it’s my go-to compact. I have put a red dot on the 1.0 for a range toy while the plus is my carry gun. Even with the Apex trigger, I have less money tied up in the 1.0 than the plus. One more item, I can buy mags for the 1.0, none available for the plus.

I changed the P365 grip module out to the XL, now perfect for me.

__________________
Sure you did