I also have both. Here are pictures of the same gun, (same gun, different grips). It is a 442, but it gives you an idea about the Lobo holster and a S. R. holster that are made for the same gun. With appoligies to S. R., I like the Lobo holster the best. I am now waiting for one of Ray's, (Lobo) Enhanced Pancake Holsters for the same gun.

S. R. Holster & 442 #2.jpg 442 in Style 1 Pancake Holster.jpg